This is part one in a series.
The ship has sailed on vaccine equity. Rich countries have preordered enough COVID-19 vaccines to inoculate their populations multiple times. The World Health Organisation’s vision of equal access through COVAX is at risk of failing and mass immunisation in low-income countries isn’t likely until 2024 — if at all.
Vaccine nationalism — where countries put their populations first, time and time again — is being met with vaccine diplomacy, with China stepping up as a seemingly charitable friend.
Put a fork in them, the election is almost done.
Understand what happens next with our best ever discounts.
Experts say these new allegiances represent a big shift in global power relations.
Narrow self-interest and unfilled promises
COVAX aimed to deliver 2 billion vaccine doses by the end of 2021 to cover 20% of the most vulnerable people in 91 low- and middle-income countries, with a focus on frontline healthcare workers and the vulnerable. But it has secured only 1.07 billion doses so far as richer national snatch up supplies.
Now, 90% of people in 67 low-income countries stand little chance of being vaccinated in 2021.
Wealthy countries with only 14% of the world’s population have bought 53% of the eight top vaccine candidates. The UK has bought enough to give every person more than five doses.
Although the UK has vaccinated more than 11% of its population, EU countries including Italy, Poland, Finland and Germany have vaccinated only between 2% and 3%. And doses have already been delayed. AstraZeneca manufactured less of its vaccine than expected and Pfizer paused manufacturing to upgrade a plant in Belgium. Some regions have seen a 60% fall in the number of doses delivered.
University of Sydney specialist in global health security Associate Professor Adam Kamradt-Scott tells Crikey equity is off the table.
“This is precisely what COVAX was designed to circumvent,” he said. “Countries have been competing with one another for vaccine deals to ensure they weren’t let behind and the effect of this was irreversible.
“The ship for vaccine equity has sailed … Unless we see cooperation we’re looking at a pandemic that will last until 2026.”
While some countries have pledged to donate a percentage of their secured doses and manufacturers have said they will provide some vaccines to lower-income nations which don’t have deals, it’s too little too late.
“The point of the COVAX facilities is to ensure our countries have access to the vaccine at an appropriate time, as they come off the line,” WHO group lead on supply and access to medicines Lisa Hedman said in an online round table discussion last week which Crikey attended.
“Not as a donation after someone has identified that they have extra, not as a donation at the end when the prices have gone down, and not at the end when it’s no longer relevant or where it’s too late to be effective in a public health context.”
A threat to global world order
After doses didn’t arrive from the EU, Serbia became the first European country to use China’s Sinopharm vaccine. President Aleksandar Vucic said “European solidarity does not exist” and “only China can help Serbia fight the virus”.
Hungary, which complained of slow EU approval of the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine, has reached a deal with Russia for the Sputnik V vaccine which doesn’t yet have EU approval.
The EU has sustained a massive reputational hit over its handling of the pandemic — and things aren’t looking good for WHO either, global governance expert Associate Professor Max Kelly tells Crikey.
She says when the pandemic hit, many hoped it would reverse states’ recent march towards sovereignty and the rise in populism — but the opposite happened.
“We’ve been shifting away from multilateralism, but the pandemic is really compounding this issue,” she said.
“It’s entrenching the existing power relations and it’s challenging the global rules-based order, including the WHO.”
What more should Australia do?
Australia has provided $80 million to COVAX to help deliver vaccines around the world. It is also planning to deliver doses of the locally manufactured AstraZeneca vaccine to Pacific neighbours.
It also has partnerships with six Pacific nations to help them develop regulatory approval bodies, similar to the Therapeutic Goods Administration, and allow vaccines and pharmaceuticals approved by the TGA to be approved.
Australia has secured 124.8 million doses. This includes 50 million doses of AstraZeneca’s vaccine which will be manufactured in Melbourne, and 10 million doses of Pfizer’s vaccine announced this morning.
Australia’s secured supplies were “modest”, Kelly says.
“We’re not the frontrunners in terms of vaccine nationalism,” she said. “The government is taking a stronger approach to managing COVID-19 here.”
Passing off extra supplies isn’t easy, either. Australia ended up with a huge surplus of H1N1 vaccines after the swine flu pandemic in 2009 when more than half of the population decided against getting vaccinated because the virus’ threat wasn’t serious enough.
With millions of extra doses, wealthy countries donated vaccines to WHO to distribute — only for them to get bogged down in bureaucracy for months as countries fought over who would be liable for adverse side-effects if it had been improperly stored during transit.
Expect more from your journalism.
Crikey is an independent Australian-owned and run outfit. It doesn’t enjoy the vast resources of the country’s main media organisations. We take seriously our responsibility to bear witness.
I hope you appreciate our reporting and consider supporting Crikey’s work. Join now for your chance at election themed merch.
Editor-in-chief
Leave a comment
“67 low-income countries stand little chance of being vaccinated in 2021.”
Cognitive dissonance and your predictive programming article aside – what if they’re the lucky ones?
Craig Kelly eat your heart out?
Yep, for sure. Don’t you read the Age newspaper? I thought all you pro vax lefty types read the Age. I posted here on Crky six months ago the possible anti covid benefits of hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin and you all called me a li-r and a fool. The MSM and the Industrial Health & Medical Complex have kept this hidden. Nothing is allowed to stand in the way of the vax juggernaut.
Craig Kelly’s only mistake was to over-lap Trumpism and QAnon with genuine conspiracies.
Long live the Craig Kellys of the world.
Alright, just for the form of it I’ll start off the negs.
To misquote 7of9, “Dissent is Futile!“.
It’s funny that a truly global problem is showing how fractious the global community is. China taking it as a matter of national insult at the suggestion the virus emerged in their country should have been a warning sign that we’re all in this together only in so far as we feel the effects of what other countries do.
Vaccination en masse is the only way to return to any sense of normalcy – that transcends borders because we live in an interconnected world. Isn’t this what bodies like the UN and WHO should be fighting to ensure?
I think it is clear that the UN are an advisory board with no real power. They have been urging developed nations to aid those less fortunate. All they can do is urge, they cannot act! They also twiddled their thumbs as they watched as an International inevitable pandemic was unfolded.
Hold your horses, hold your horses. Ok! Now we are F*****! Take heed! And good luck!
Trump is a parasite for democracy. Always will be. ‘Lite’ Tony.
Trump hate him, loathe him, abhor him: he was right to suggest that WHO is just an overpriced and ineffectual authority figure. Just as the UN were in their delivery of justice to the state of Israel, throwing Palestinians to the curb.
I have never read Marxist theory. I read the first page and that was enough. I know what socialism is. You see it around in bastardised form every day. I see exclusive communism in my country too, each and every day that I turn on the TV, listen to the radio, when I go to the pharmacist, the green grocer. It is all there in some form. All you have to do is read life empirically to develop a cognition of sociology, anthropology, theology, and all those invoking components that make humans who were are. That make life on earth so unique.
We an do better. Be have to do better. Reinstate adequate foreign aid funding! LNP cut here, cut there, cut everywhere, except if you are one of their mates. You will be in line for the first vaccine.
I will wait impatiently behind you, with all the elderly and those who have their physical health compromised.
*Salute civilized people of the developed and privileged world.
Edited – Apologies
I think it is clear that the WHO are an advisory board with no real power. They have been urging developed nations to aid those less fortunate. All they can do is urge, they cannot act! They also twiddled their thumbs as they watched as an International inevitable pandemic was unfolded.
Hold your horses, hold your horses. Ok! Now we are F*****! Take heed! And good luck!
Trump is a parasite for democracy. Always will be. ‘Lite’ Tony.
Trump hate him, loathe him, abhor him: he was right to suggest that WHO is just an overpriced and ineffectual authority figure. Just as the UN were in their delivery of justice to the state of Israel, throwing Palestinians to the curb.
I have never read Marxist theory. I read the first page and that was enough. I know what socialism is. You see it around in bastardised form every day. I see exclusive communism in my country too, each and every day that I turn on the TV, listen to the radio, when I go to the pharmacist, the green grocer. It is all there in some form. All you have to do is read life empirically to develop a cognition of sociology, anthropology, theology, and all those invoking components that make humans who were are. That make life on earth so unique.
We can do better. We have to do better. Reinstate adequate foreign aid funding! LNP cut here, cut there, cut everywhere, except if you are one of their mates. You will be in line for the first vaccine.
I will wait impatiently behind you, with all the elderly and those who have their physical health compromised.
*Salute civilized people of the developed and privileged world.
it’s a GLOBAL pandemic – no point in looking after your little neck of the woods, only to have vast reservoirs of the virus spreading and mutating
it’s already happening and, sooner or later, the genetic lottery will toss up something truly horrifying that will make the current vaccines useless
the virus must be stopped soon and everywhere – if we don’t, then we will only have our own short-term selfishness to blame
“the genetic lottery will toss up something truly horrifying that will make the current vaccines useless”
Vaccines are useless before they even commence. Go to the Pfizer website or any other vaccine manufacturer website. Vaccines do not prevent covid infection. I think it’s called the horses mouth.
No but they stop you dying from it. Very few vaccines dtop you getting the virus, they stop you getting ill and sometimes they stop you being infectious. This is variable. But your comment show a lack of understanding of the way vaccines work.
“No but they stop you dying from it”
Do you have peer reviewed articles or solid scientific medical evidence to back up your claim?
I can see you put a lot of work into this piece but you might be wagging the microbe a wee bit. ..or better said, jumping the gun.
Warning: don’t read sycophant commenters. They use you to prosper their agenda.
You can’t help some nations, Ukraine can’t get western supplies and has refused Sputnik V even though it has been offered free of charge, though the people in Donbas are getting it. The US can send a load of freedom cookies instead.