Scroll to top

What the CPRS could (and should) have been

Crikey readers unpack the CPRS and the ongoing fight for effective climate action, while former PM Kevin Rudd drops us another line to reaffirm his legacy.

power plant carbon emissions carbon capture
(Image: Getty)

On the CPRS

Richard Letts writes: The Greens made a political miscalculation, when there was more innocence around climate politics. But their position that climate action by the government should address the actual problem effectively is reasonable and principled even if doomed. Labor is undependable, concerned above all with the politics and it would be hard to justify its attacks on the Greens as principled. The Coalition is dependably appalling in more ways than can be counted.

Roger Clifton writes: The CPRS was all carrot and no stick. It failed to state the blindingly obvious: it is criminal for anyone to emit fossil carbon now that we know the consequence of our action. Any trading scheme that sells an industry a “right” to emit is complicit in that crime. On the other hand, a carbon tax that taxes all fossil carbon as soon as it leaves the ground, or crosses our borders, is taxing a bad, much better than taxing a good.

Keryn Robinson writes: The press gallery is happy to support Labor’s claim about the Greens wrecking the CPRS because it fits one of its favoured narratives: that “extremists” on both sides have wrecked the chance of effective climate action, and that if only the “sensible centre” would be allowed to govern things would be OK. But when it comes to climate action, this is both wrong and irrelevant. Climate change is caused by basic physics. You either reduce carbon emissions or you cook the planet. The CPRS wouldn’t have reduced emissions — just given huge taxpayer-funded handouts to polluters. The press gallery’s centrist “fault on all sides, extremism is wrecking civility” hand-wringing will never change the basic maths, just guarantee we’re stuck in a permanent loop of climate failure.

Invest in the journalism that makes a difference.

EOFY Sale. A year for just $99.

SAVE 50%

James Burke writes: The Coalition’s been in government for six years. So why is Labor attacking the Greens again? For ten years Labor’s been trying to summon the courage to stand up to the schoolyard bullies. Every morning it whispers into the mirror: “This time. Today’s the day I tell Rupert and Gina and Alan and the rest to piss off, and they’ll see I mean business and leave me alone!” Yet every day, year after year, it wets its pants and hands over its lunch money… then goes looking for a smaller kid to pick on.

On Kevin Rudd’s legacy

Kevin Rudd Writes: Thanks for inviting readers to share their reflections on my legacy as prime minister. Now it’s known that I’m a reader, let me provide you with some of my highlights. 🙂

  • Making an apology to Indigenous Australians for past wrongs and setting the Closing the Gap targets to begin fulfilling the Apology’s promise to our first peoples.
  • Ratifying the Kyoto Protocol, setting a mandatory Renewable Energy Target and introducing to parliament Australia’s first legislation to put a price on carbon pollution.
  • Abolishing John Howard’s WorkChoices laws and restoring fairness to industrial relations through the Fair Work Act.
  •  Keeping Australia out of recession, avoiding mass unemployment and protecting Australians’ savings through a world-leading response to the Global Financial Crisis.
  • Legislating to increase the compulsory Superannuation Guarantee Levy to 12%, addressing fundamental inequality in Australians’ retirement savings.
  • The biggest ever increase to the aged pension, helping to lift thousands of older Australians out of hardship.
  • Bringing Australian troops home from Iraq after the invasion launched by George W. Bush and John Howard in 2003.
  • Overhauling the nation’s Freedom of Information regime to foster more transparency and a culture of disclosure in government.
  • Amending almost 100 federal laws to remove discrimination against gay and lesbian couples including in superannuation and family law.
  • A national school curriculum to apply modern, high and consistent standards across schools regardless of where they are situated.
  • Major health reforms to preserve the long-term viability of the public health system and prevent patients being lost in the system.
  • Building or refurbishing almost 100,000 units of social housing after years of neglect under the Liberals, while attracting new investment into affordable housing for low- and middle-income households.
  • Launching the National Disability Insurance Scheme to support the needs and aspirations of all Australians with disabilities, regardless of where they live.
  • A 10-year, multi-billion-dollar housing partnership to address overcrowding and other dangers in remote Indigenous communities.
  • Establishing Infrastructure Australia as an independent guide of the nation’s infrastructure needs, and launching the biggest infrastructure investment since the Snowy Mountains Scheme.
  • Starting construction of a high-speed, full-fibre National Broadband Network that connected tens of thousands of Australians.
  • Modernising facilities across every primary school in Australia while achieving value for money and supporting 100,000 construction jobs.
  • Helping to establish the G20 summit to guide international economic policy, with Australia having a seat at the head table.

Send your comments, corrections, clarifications and cock-ups to boss@crikey.com.au. We reserve the right to edit comments for length and clarity. Please include your full name if you would like to be considered for publication.

Save this EOFY while you make a difference

Australia has spoken. We want more from the people in power and deserve a media that keeps them on their toes. And thank you, because it’s been made abundantly clear that at Crikey we’re on the right track.

We’ve pushed our journalism as far as we could go. And that’s only been possible with reader support. Thank you. And if you haven’t yet subscribed, this is your time to join tens of thousands of Crikey members to take the plunge.

Peter Fray
Peter Fray
Editor-in-chief
SAVE 50%
12 comments

Leave a comment

Subscribe
Notify of
12 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
CrowReally
CrowReally
2 years ago

Always a pleasure to hear someone speak on their favourite subject.

Fairmind
Fairmind
2 years ago
Reply to  CrowReally

True enough, but let’s see a similar list from Abbott or Turnbull, or a progress report from Morrison, to compare results.
Maybe even just a note to confirm they know what Crikey readers know….

Johnny Rotten
Johnny Rotten
2 years ago
Reply to  CrowReally

Smart alec. I suppose you fought the GFC all by yourself

Johnny Rotten
Johnny Rotten
2 years ago
Reply to  CrowReally

Summing up the Greens

“The real corruption to be found in the voluminous records of micro-aggressions is of language. Disagreement becomes abuse. Debate is violence. Ordinary requests are bullying. Frivolity is recklessness. I have encountered sensitivity so pronounced, so easily disturbed, that it resembles madness. And I detect in this hypersensitivity an imperious individualism, an almost hysterical primacy of one’s feelings — impractical in a political party and disastrous for the communal values of debate”

https://insidestory.org.au/uneasy-being-green/

parrick
parrick
2 years ago

Come back Kev. All is forgiven.

CML
CML
2 years ago

Thank you for that, Mr Rudd…to read/listen/view the media in this country (including Crikey), you neither did, nor achieved, ANYTHING during your time in office.
Talk about FAKE news…this country is full of it!
You can come back anytime as far as I’m concerned!!

Johnny Rotten
Johnny Rotten
2 years ago

Thank you Kevin. The smart arses think all these things happened by magic. They should consider the last 6 years and crawl back into whatever cave they came from.

Cameron Bray
Cameron Bray
2 years ago

I hold no particular brief for KRudd, and any ex-PM wittering on about their legacy is going to write a pretty self serving list…. but jeez even with those caveats, its a pretty sad indictment on the current mob isn’t it? What’s their list?
Knifed a sitting PM. Failed to pass a bunch of Bills. Stuffed the economy. Kicked the difficult stuff into the long grass. Gave cash to some mates. Had a conga line of Ministers struggle heroically against the forces of accountability. Organised some politically-motivated national security raids.
You must all be so proud.