Malcolm Turnbull company tax cuts

Yesterday, Crikey readers were a little less than convinced by the arguments (from Bernard Keane and Glenn Dyer) that Malcolm Turnbull would, in a universe where he wasn’t unceremoniously axed, be in a strong position to lead the LNP to victory at the next federal election. Whether it was the holes in his economic strategy, or simply the implausibility of a truly united Coalition, they weren’t buying it. Elsewhere, we had some notes on Scott Morrison’s campaign bus (which definitely isn’t a campaign bus, honest).

On a hypothetical Turnbull 2019 victory

The Curmudgeon writes: This theory requires the imagination of an alternative universe in which the Liberal Party is united behind Turnbull, the extreme right pull their head in and there is some connection between the concerns of the party and those of voters. As this was unimaginable even had Turnbull stayed on, I’ll back the old “disunity is death” theory over the elite-driven “good” economic news which will indeed be news to those trying to pay the bills.

jon kotsopoulos writes: I once called Costello’s “miracle economy” a debt fuelled time bomb. The economy is in an even more precarious state now with ballooning federal debt, negative wages growth, misleading headline inflation and a scarily low and finishing level of personal savings. It is widely acknowledged that Australia is currently much less well placed to handle a world wide economic slowdown. The average person instinctively knows the real situation and is unlikely to reward the LNP for their economic record no matter what Mr Keane thinks.

See how power works in this country.

News done fearlessly. Join us for just $99.


BeenAround writes: This article assumes that “good” economic data would boost the LNP’s chances at a federal election. I respectfully disagree. Whilst most Australians could not define what neoliberalism is, I am pretty sure they have decided that its manifestation through chaotic and lazy LNP policies is not what they want. I also think that the majority of Australians are thoroughly fed up with the influence the right wing nutters in the Liberal and National parties have on sensible coalition policy. So, regardless of this untestable speculation, I very much doubt Turnbull could have pulled off a win. And on Thursday night I suspect he will absolutely ensure that the current bunch of stint clowns have no chance.

Paddy writes: We’re actually all a lot better off with Scotty, because he doesn’t even have the emperor’s leather jacket to hide his stupidity.

On the ScoMo express

Franki Elliot writes: Kinda symbolic really: it’s his bus, but nobody is on it.

Send your comments, corrections, clarifications and cock-ups to We reserve the right to edit comments for length and clarity. Please include your full name.

See how power works in this country.

Independence, to us, means everyone’s right to tell the truth beyond just ourselves. If you value independent journalism now is the time to join us. Save $100 when you join us now.

Peter Fray
Peter Fray
SAVE 50%