After news broke than an SUV that had smashed its way through a very familiar part of Melbourne on Thursday, news outlets reported it was a deliberate incident, not just an accident. Later, terrorism was ruled out, the perpetrator having a long history of drug abuse and mental illness.

We soon learned the driver was an Australian of Afghan heritage. The hateful commentators, columnists and trolls were waiting for this moment. “These Afghans come to our country and refuse to follow our ways”. “Wherever the Afghans go, terrorism follows”. “Afghans are the ones who filled our country with drugs”. On and on they went.

No, I’m not talking about Newscorp tabloids. At least not yet. The anti-Afghan hatred didn’t need much of a trigger to be set off in Pakistan where racist politicians and columnists and TV anchors are doing the dirty work of successive governments that want Afghan refugees of the Soviet-Afghan war and US-led invasion to go home.

Invest in the journalism that makes a difference.

EOFY Sale. A year for just $99.


The Peter Duttons of Pakistan are declaring Afghanistan to be safe enough for Afghans of the Hazara ethnic group to … um … be blown to smithereens by the sectarian Taliban. As if that isn’t already happening in Pakistani cities where the Hazaras have settled, studied, established businesses, learned local dialects and, well, integrated. But the Hazara look different and they follow a different sect. Hence an incident in Melbourne can send shivers down the spines of Hazaras in Pakistani cities.

Hatred is generated by incidents we know little about or which we compare to past incidents and to what we are taught about certain groups. The post-Flinders hate was making its voice heard even before police had confirmed any motive. As at the time of writing, we learn that the driver referred to the “perceived mistreatment of Muslims” among other “utterances”. And what utterances were they? Who knows? Who cares? The guy was an Afghan; Muslim and with a grievance, and inspired by identity politics. Even one Indigenous “leader” has already decided this was an act of terrorism.


Daily Telegraph columnist Miranda Devine retweeting United Patriots Front and Hilter sympathiser Blair Cottrell

This shouldn’t surprise anyone. Recent research by All Together Now has shown the media is often the only exposure the average Aussie has with people of non-white races and non-Christian ethno-religions. Which makes the media’s role in all of this crucial in maintaining social cohesion: “… the media has an agenda-setting role that informs how the general public treats migrants. And, when ethnic minorities occupy a central role in mainstream media, they are often portrayed as threatening to the Anglo mainstream.”

From a sample of opinion articles, the report showed that “negative portrayals of race were most often published on News Corp Australia online newspapers such as Daily Telegraph (24 articles), The Australian (17) and Herald Sun (11). The data analysis showed that the highest number of articles about a single group of people were about Muslim people, with other groups represented in smaller percentages.”

These are also the papers that rarely allow any room for Muslim authors or academics to write on their pages. So allegedly conservative media expect Muslims to speak out but won’t allow them space to do so. How is this so? Is there some kind of agenda at work here to marginalise minorities? If you have any doubts about the attitudes of some of our most powerful opinion makers, just follow their tweets. ​


Australia has spoken. We want more from the people in power and deserve a media that keeps them on their toes. And thank you, because it’s been made abundantly clear that at Crikey we’re on the right track.

We’ve pushed our journalism as far as we could go. And that’s only been possible with reader support. Thank you. And if you haven’t yet subscribed, this is your time to join tens of thousands of Crikey members to take the plunge.

Peter Fray
Peter Fray
SAVE 50%