Across the country, commentators are pretty much in agreement on what’s behind Labor’s landslide victory in the Western Australian election on Saturday.

Peter van Onselen writes in The Australian today:

“The ‘it’s time’ factor best encapsulates the explanation for Western Australia’s election outcome, but the size of the defeat adds complexity to the analysis,” 

The West Australian put its support behind Labor in its editorial on Friday, and today Gary Adshead writes that as well as needing a change, voters wanted a succession plan for the leadership that was not forthcoming.

The Liberals’ loss of government was expected, but the Oz begged its WA readers to give Barnett another chance on Friday:

“However aggrieved West Australians may be with Mr Barnett, who has failed to develop a succession plan, voters should be careful in what they wish for by turning to Labor or to One Nation. If anything, the campaign has refocused the Liberal Party’s thinking and its plan is sound. Voters would best serve their own interests by retaining the status quo.”

The West Australian took exception to the national broadsheet leaping into WA politics:

“Rupert Murdoch’s great vanity project, which for decades dominated the nation’s journalistic landscape, has lost the plot. That the self-professed powerhouse of Australian journalism could endorse the Barnett government for a third term shows the people running the paper have no feel for WA. That voters did the polar opposite of what The Australian suggested is yet more proof that the paper’s power is vastly overstated.”

Andrew Bolt reckons Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull is to blame, even though he helped somewhat by staying away from the campaign. 

“And, yes, Turnbull stayed far away during the campaign, dropping in on Perth for just one visit that lasted less than a day. But that visit alone said so much to federal MPs desperately needing a leader who can campaign for their political lives. Turnbull campaigned horribly in last year’s federal election, nearly losing, and last month all but killed Barnett, too.”

But even Bolt concedes Barnett had done his dash:

“When voters are over you, it really is over. There really is almost no way back.” 

The other big issue in the result is, of course, One Nation’s failure to win any lower house seats, and its very average performance in the upper house.

Per Bolt’s column today:

“Forget the spin that Turnbull was actually helped by the WA result because Pauline Hanson was humbled and Turnbull’s Right-wing critics put in their place. That wishful thinking by Leftist journalists centres on the claim that the WA Liberals were tainted and smashed by their preference deal with Hanson’s One Nation party. In fact, the WA Liberals were in much the same desperate strife in the polls for the past year. The Liberals didn’t crash because they preferenced One Nation; they preferenced One Nation because they’d crashed.”

As recently as Wednesday, former Tony Abbott adviser and Sky News commentator Peta Credlin was certain One Nation would be a great success in WA.

This morning, Bolt has continued his prolific blogging, saying he thinks the “lefties” writing off One Nation are premature — according to ABC election analyst Antony Green, the party won 8% in seats it contested. Says Bolt:

“Journalists writing off One Nation are writing what they’d love to believe rather than the objective truth. I expect she will learn and improve, although there’s no doubt she’ll be and feel bruised.”

Peter Fray

Support journalism that makes things better, not worse.

Rupert Murdoch had never had a US president in his pocket before Donald Trump landed there in 2016.

This week, we explored the relationship between the two men and why Murdoch should be held to account for the making of Trump.

Where do you start with dismantling the media empire that delivered us a phenomenon like Trump?

Here’s one thing you can do: Support the journalism that makes things better, not worse.

Subscribe to Crikey today with the promo code MADEMEN and get 50% off an annual membership.

Hurry, 48 hours only.

Peter Fray
Editor-in-chief of Crikey

JOIN NOW