
Is Bronwyn Bishop being encouraged by her party to take her bat and helicopter and go home?
Over the weekend, The Australian reported that MediaReach polling of 877 residents in Bishop’s seat of Mackellar showed Bishop would only get 21% of the primary vote, with potential independent rival Dick Smith securing 54% of the vote if he were to run against her. The Oz report says the paper “obtained” the polling. A news.com.au report using the same data stated the polling had been conducted for News Corp, but Crikey understands that is not the case.
We hear from our Anonymous Denizen of Mackellar that the polling was likely commissioned by someone within the Liberal Party as it was unlikely the Greens, Labor or Smith would conduct polling while the Liberal preselection process was still ongoing. Given that The Australian story quotes a “senior party source”, suggesting that the party wouldn’t risk the distraction of having to fight to keep a key safe seat, our source told Crikey that the polling and the commentary was less of a gentle push and more of a sharp-elbowed shove for Bishop to get out of the race. We hear the Liberals are concerned at the prospect of spending money fighting to keep what should otherwise be a blue-ribbon Liberal seat, rather than spending cash in marginal seats where it is needed more.
Bishop faces six preselection opponents, and locals will make their decision on April 16. Former Warringah councillor Jason Falinski and former Baird campaign director Walter Villatora are considered the favourites.
Rumours abound in Mackellar that Bishop might be considering withdrawing from the race for “the good of the party”, but our spy suggests that locals would need to see it to believe it:
“Mrs Bishop lives in a bubble surrounded by her own cheer squad who assure her she has the numbers. It’s a bit like the emperor’s new clothes. It’s also obvious to Bronny-watchers she suffers from that affliction so common amongst older politicians on the cusp of retirement: relevance deprivation syndrome. The big trouble for the party is that she still believes she’s relevant even though the poll results clearly show the majority of her electorate disagrees with her.”
The polling suggests there will be much more action in the seat of Mackellar before April 16. The timing also means that Bishop’s future will be known before Parliament resumes for the extra three sitting weeks starting April 18.
Another spy tells us Bishop was looking particularly chummy with Malcolm Turnbull at the Opera on the Harbour opening on the weekend, refusing to leave the Prime Minister’s side and turning into a bit of a third wheel for Malcolm and Lucy Turnbull. Pleading for her political life, perhaps?
There has also been dramatic movement in the Sportsbet odds for Bishop between February 16 and March 24. Bishop has dropped from odds of $1.83 down to $2.50, while Falinski has moved from $7.50 to $1.60 as the firm favourite. Villatora has dropped, however, down from $3.00 to $5.00.

18 thoughts on “Bronwyn Bishop’s high-flying Mackellar campaign comes crashing down”
klewso
March 29, 2016 at 1:44 pmSo the Liberal house of cards has landed on the Wicked Witch of the East?
sang froid
March 29, 2016 at 2:04 pmInstead of relevance deprivation, what about value adding? Something that ceased in Mackellar decades ago.
Flat tyre
March 29, 2016 at 2:13 pmI can remember when Bron was talked about as a future PM. In fact the first female PM.
I sure am glad that never happened.
Time to ride off into the sunset Bron.
Doubt that will happen though, someone will have to pry the seat from her cold hands.
Norman Hanscombe
March 29, 2016 at 2:25 pmWith Dick Smith’s record of destroying local electrical goods industries with cheap imports followed by similar behavior in the electronics industries with Dick Smiths Stores, capped off by his wasteful use of resources to keep himself in the news, if I were a loyal Liberal Party member I’d be working flat out in the Nation’s best interests hoping the Liberal candidate with the best chance of beating Smith was going to win the preselection.
I can of course understand why the Crikey Commissariat and its fellow travelers wouldn’t mention this, and instead concentrate on what they’re best qualified for, i, e. sniping at those who don’t follow Crikey’s various Holy Grails.
zut alors
March 29, 2016 at 2:50 pmBishop’s legacy will be her reputation as the Oz parliament’s worst Speaker in living memory. But if Hansard records are compared she may rate as the most biased since federation.
Alan
March 29, 2016 at 2:55 pmWell, she did keep winning elections, why wouldn’t she want to stay on?
Interrobanging On
March 29, 2016 at 3:08 pmAt least Dick and Bronnie have helicopters in common…
As it happens, I was one of those polled. It sounded a bit like a Dick Smith push, in fact, because there were specific questions and an oh-so-subtle favourable intro about him. But Liberal internal rumblings, maybe… (Internal Liberal rumblings are like those created by some particularly nasty strain of amoebic dysentery.)
I said Bronny was a dud (well, der!). In retrospect, I have wondered if I should have lied and said she is great and I will only vote for her. Thus fooling those in the Liberal bubble that she should be preselected, only to lose.
I was ambivalent about Dick Smith, because he should run anyway if he is committed and genuine. Frankly, the appalling prospect of ANY candidate the Liberal Party will vomit up in this day and age makes finding independents valuable, not only in certain cases eg Kerosene Bronnie, Barnyard Joyce and the Odious Mirabella (stirring zombie-like to return to suck our brains once again).
I have enjoyed the reviling she gets (deserved), but there are more than a few of the thoroughly decent oldies in Mackellar who are fretting about their Bronwyn (‘she works so hard!’). They should have tapped her to resign, instead of misguided loyalty.
One way or another, time for her to chopper into the sunset and leave us undefended against terrorists.
Honest Johnny
March 29, 2016 at 3:15 pmWinning elections in Mackellar does not translate into personal loyalty, as it is a deeply conservative electorate that simply votes Liberal. The voters there do not suffer fools, however, a situation that was witnessed in the State bi-election after John Brogden quit when the Libs tried to parachute in an unknown party official.Then and only then the voters of Pittwater turned to a popular independent to send their preferred party a message. They’ll do the same thing again if Bishop wins pre-selection and vote for Dick Smith.
Jaybuoy
March 29, 2016 at 3:31 pmBronny actually suffers from a much rarer form of Phantom relevance deprivation syndrome…it’s all in her mind..she just needs a good kero bath and a lie down..
Venise Alstergren
March 29, 2016 at 4:16 pmNORMAN HANSCOMBE: The only holy grail for Oz politicians is the astonishing belief the old dears whose raisons d’etres were formed in the 1950s-by their parents, grandparents, or just passed on-without thought-to a hapless electorate were valid.