Caution slammed. As news filtered out of last Friday’s shooting at a Parramatta police station, many media outlets explicitly stated the incident was not terror-related in early coverage, despite some witness accounts suggesting it was.

In The Daily Telegraph, however, columnist Tim Blair takes aim at the “love media” (as some have taken to calling the ABC, Fairfax, The Guardian and other more liberal-left outlets). Here he is on The Guardian:

“Parramatta real estate agent Edwin Almeida spotted the killer and offered this perfectly accurate description to reporters: ‘I saw the man wielding a handgun, dressed in black robes.’

“This newsworthy line was deliberately omitted from the Guardian‘s online coverage, presumably because the murderer’s clothing may have hinted at a certain unmentionable faith. “I won’t go into reports about what the man identified by eyewitnesses as carrying a gun was wearing or what he looked like,” the Guardian‘s Calla Wahlquist decreed, which is an unusual approach to journalism.”

And on Fairfax:

“In more than one report, Fairfax described the killer shouting ‘religious slogans’. Seriously. In the US, the Daily Caller’s Jim Treacher took a shot at guessing what those slogans could have been. ‘Merry Christmas? Mazel tov? May the force be with yous?’.”

This caution was, it’s worth noting, strongly encouraged by police, with NSW Police Commissioner Andrew Scipione taking care to use neutral, non-specific language in early media briefings. Though this has also come in for criticism. The Oz‘s media diary described his conference as “evasive to the point of misleading”. — Myriam Robin

To name or not to name. US media outlets are debating about whether or not to name gun-shooting offenders following the Oregon school massacre. Some, including local police sheriff John Hanlin, argued removing the name of the offenders could both obliterate their memory and deny the offenders the notoriety or perverted glory they hoped to gain through their crimes. It’s a suggestion that’s been endorsed by both Fox News, and other outlets like CNN have not shown the gunman’s face, and very rarely said his name. A public campaign called “No Notoriety”, founded nine months ago, is extolling the media to stay firm on not giving mass shooters the spotlight they claim.

But there is pushback. TalkingPointsMemo editor Josh Marshall said the refusal to name the offenders was “transforming into a purported symbol of action and defiance”, but was a distraction from the real issue, which was the growing scourge of mass gun violence in America. Those who opposed efforts to regulate gun purchases, he said, were hoping such token efforts would allow people to feel like they were doing something, while not addressing the core problem. — Crikey intern Sunny Liu

Video of the day. Hillary Clinton gets a second job …

Front page of the day. North Queensland’s first …

Peter Fray

Get your first 12 weeks of Crikey for $12.

Without subscribers, Crikey can’t do what it does. Fortunately, our support base is growing.

Every day, Crikey aims to bring new and challenging insights into politics, business, national affairs, media and society. We lift up the rocks that other news media largely ignore. Without your support, more of those rocks – and the secrets beneath them — will remain lodged in the dirt.

Join today and get your first 12 weeks of Crikey for just $12.

 

Peter Fray
Editor-in-chief of Crikey

JOIN NOW