The Australian Jewish News has defended its reporting of an interview with new Greens leader Richard Di Natale, uploading the audio of a question in which Di Natale appears to support the existence of Israel as a Jewish state. The controversy started when The Australian Jewish News published an interview last week under the headline “Di Natale in his own words”, which opened “Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas must acknowledge Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state, new Australian Greens leader Richard Di Natale says”.

A spokesperson for Di Natale told Crikey the issue is an “unfortunate miscommunication”, emphasising that Greens were not accusing the paper of misreporting. “It’s a case of the question that Richard answered was slightly different to what was actually asked”.

The audio confirms that when asked about the right of Israel to exist as a Jewish nation, Di Natale said: “Of course. How can you have a two-state solution when you refuse to acknowledge the right of one state to exist? It’s patently nonsense.”

Di Natale’s spokesperson says that his position on the issue hadn’t changed, but that he was responding as if asked about an “Israeli state”.

The comments were interpreted by some pro-Palestine activists as part of Di Natale’s plan to move the Greens towards the mainstream, and they wrote to him about the interview, in which he also said that the Greens didn’t support the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions campaign against Israel. The activists received (and published on Facebook), this reply from Di Natale’s executive assistant,  Tom Bennett, which said “Like you, Senator Di Natale was concerned about the way in which his comments were reported”.

“We would like to take this opportunity to reassure you that, consistent with Greens policy, Senator Di Natale supports a peaceful, two-state solution for the Israel-Palestine conflict that upholds the legitimate rights and aspirations of both the Palestinian and Israeli people to live in peace and security in their own independent, sovereign states. The establishment of a ‘Jewish state’ (as opposed to an ‘Israeli state’) is not conducive to this outcome, and Senator Di Natale did not intend for his comments to be construed as such and this is not Australian Greens policy.”

The Australian Jewish News’ Facebook page posted about the issue twice yesterday and again today, first stating that the paper hadn’t been contacted by Di Natale’s office with any complaints about the article:

“If The Greens are concerned, they’re not concerned enough to contact The AJN about the report. In fact, we’ve contacted the Senator’s office ourselves, and offered them the opportunity to send us a letter of clarification that we have promised to publish … Seriously, The AJN stands by the story and our journalist 100 per cent.”

In a further post yesterday evening, it said “Wasn’t an error in reporting after all. It was just a misunderstanding — and not ours. For those of you whose social justice voting tendencies were stroked just a bit, no dice — we’re afraid the Greens aren’t quite kosher yet.”

Di Natale’s spokesman told Crikey that the Greens bear no grudge against the paper: “there’s no hard feelings from our perspective”.

General manager of The Australian Jewish News Rod Kenning told Crikey that he was “disappointed” with how the Senator’s office had handled the issue, saying they had no idea there was a problem with the piece until seeing a post on Facebook. He said they were “really happy with the response from readers” to the piece, which had been very popular.

Kenning says he wrote to Di Natale’s office early this week, asking for clarification regarding the confusion around the piece, and to make sure there were no allegations about the journalist Gareth Narunsky. He also sent the audio of the interview with the email. Kenning says he only posted about the issue on Facebook after not hearing back for a few days. “The original interview opened up a whole new demographic for the Greens. I’m sorry that due to foot-in-mouth disease, that demographic is closed again.” Kenning said that when it comes to recognising Israel as the homeland of the Jewish people, that’s a “line we’ll never cross”.

Kenning said the issue wont change how the AJN deals with the Greens in future, “at federal, state and local levels, we report on a non-partisan point of view”.

Peter Fray

Get your first 12 weeks of Crikey for $12.

Without subscribers, Crikey can’t do what it does. Fortunately, our support base is growing.

Every day, Crikey aims to bring new and challenging insights into politics, business, national affairs, media and society. We lift up the rocks that other news media largely ignore. Without your support, more of those rocks – and the secrets beneath them — will remain lodged in the dirt.

Join today and get your first 12 weeks of Crikey for just $12.


Peter Fray
Editor-in-chief of Crikey