As Crikey approached deadline the Martin Place siege was still unfolding. At least one gunman is reportedly holding at least a dozen people hostage in the Lindt cafe in the Sydney CBD. Australian Federal Police have joined NSW police at the scene.
It remains unclear who is behind the siege, but a flag associated with Islamic jihadis has been seen in the window of the cafe, where hostages are pressed up against the glass. It’s a serious and deeply frightening situation, and when so little official information is available — it took the PM two hours to make a media statement — it can be tempting to jump to conclusions.
Mainstream and social media have been in overdrive this morning, with experts in Islamic terror wheeled out in an attempt to understand the alleged perpetrators and their motives. This is understandable when there are broadcast minutes and column inches to fill, and in the absence of any concrete information.
But there’s little the media can do to help resolve the situation as it stands, and misinformation can be damaging. It’s worth remembering what happened in the aftermath of the Boston Marathon attack, when amateur sleuths on Reddit declared that a student who was missing was probably the Boston bomber. He was later found dead in a suspected suicide. The New York Post also published the pictures of two people it claimed might be connected to the bombing, under the headline “Bag Men”. They had nothing to do with the attack and later sued the paper.
Until we have more information, we urge caution on behalf of the media.
7 thoughts on “Crikey says: don’t fill the void with rumour and misinformation”
Wun Farlung
December 15, 2014 at 3:37 pmFair comment and meanwhile Hockey and Corman have wheeled out MYEFO and due to the distraction in Sydney hardly rating a mention anywhere including Crikey
Salamander
December 15, 2014 at 4:05 pmIncredible timing on MYEFO day.
James O'Neill
December 15, 2014 at 6:06 pmAm I a cynic or is it really just an incredible coincidence that a prolonged non-violent siege takes up all the news on the same day that a horror MYEFO is released. So convenient one might almost think it was planned.
Gavin Moodie
December 15, 2014 at 10:29 pmDoes Crikey ‘urge caution on behalf of the media’ or urge caution by the media?
AR
December 16, 2014 at 7:13 amGavin – perhaps Crikey is urging, on behalf of the semi sentient shoutjocks, the populace to remain calm?
Or just has no idea of syntax, uses thereof.
Norman Hanscombe
December 16, 2014 at 12:28 pmJames, in common with many posters have been re similar topics in the past, a more apt word than cynicism might be paranoia or delusion.
James O'Neill
December 16, 2014 at 1:34 pmNo Norman. When one has been around as long as I have one’s first response is cynicism. You might like to google Operation Northwoods, or Gladio as one very small introduction to the use of false flag attacks used to justify exactly the sort of government statements, behaviour and legislation that we are seeing now. There is of course a very long history in this area. The fact that the msm doesn’t talk about it or even acknowledge its existence does not make one either paranoid or delusional. Delusional is a word more aptly applied to those who accept the official version of almost any event.