Sep 1, 2014

Little common ground and less understanding at pro-life conference

Freelance writer Connor Tomas O'Brien attended the World Congress of Families. He discovered angry protesters and outraged attendees -- with neither side willing to give an inch.

In the lead-up to the World Congress of Families’ Melbourne "regional" event, it was unclear whether convener Babette Francis was a Machiavellian manipulator or simply a woman who’d found herself in way over her head. From the outside, it certainly looked as though the conference were falling apart: after the original venue pulled out, the conference was relocated to a church in Glen Iris, then to Brunswick East, and then it appeared as though no church would be willing to host the thing at all. In the week before the event was due to take place, it was rumored that no insurance or security had been organised. Then, the day before the conference, both Social Services Minister Kevin Andrews and Victorian Attorney-General Robert Clark decided to drop off the speakers' roster. The conference was initially advertised as "free admission, all welcome", and those who contacted Francis immediately following the announcement of the event were registered without vetting. In early July, though, the event was picked up by satirist and LGBTQI rights advocate Pauline Pantsdown, who encouraged protesters to send through bogus RSVPs to book out the conference with non-attendees. The conference began demanding proof of attendees' anti-abortion bona fides. “Why are you interested in our event if you are not associated with any pro-life group or church?” Francis asked me a week before the event. When I told her I wanted to attend because I was “open-minded”, Francis was unconvinced. “We are very suspicious of anyone from Carlton who is not connected to a pro-life or pro-family organisation,” she told me, offering to post me a copy of her newsletter. Strangely, after I did actually manage to make it in, one of the repeated refrains from audience members I spoke to was how disappointed they were that members of the Left seemed unwilling to truly engage the religious Right in respectful, intelligent conversation. “If they really wanted to challenge our ideas, why wouldn’t they come here, wait until question time, and then pose a question in a logical fashion?” asked Teresa Martin, state president of Cherish Life Queensland. I noted that this kind of polite dialogue wasn’t exactly possible, considering that anybody who couldn’t prove a connection to a pro-life group was being forced to stand outside and prevented from entering Catch the Fire Ministries’ Hallam compound by 50 police officers. Teresa nodded, then pointed at the front of the stage. “Were you here this morning?” I shook my head. “Sort of. I was outside. It was hard for me to get in.” “There was a protester on stage, wearing all white, and then she spilled red paint all over her crotch,” Teresa said, shaking her head. The protester was an artist named Phaedra Press, and I had seen her from the street as security had ejected her from the compound. “I poured blood on myself in front of Fred Nile!” Phaedra exclaimed, once back out on the street. “We tried to cause an evacuation, but those guys in there don’t even have bloody smoke detectors!” “We wanted to show that ‘this is what a backyard abortion looks like’,” CJ, another of the protesters, told me (she had also been ejected from the venue, despite donning a frumpy op-shop frock in order to "pass for a Christian"). But it seems that message was somewhat lost in translation. “She just re-enacted exactly what an abortion is,” Teresa Martin said, shrugging sadly.
"With news outlets treating the World Congress of Families as farcical ... attendees were simply being led to further distrust any information that did not come filtered through pro-life media channels."
In the morning a young Christian couple with two small children in tow ran the gauntlet of protesters to get into the event. “Why are you bringing your children here, you bigots?!” several of the protesters shouted, as the police swept in and created a human wall to protect them. These children would remember this moment forever, but would they side with the angry people in funny clothes who hurled abuse at their parents? Predictably, within the conference, almost everyone seemed apprehensive around journalists. “A pretty young lady came and asked me about the protesters,” I heard one older man say to another. I could immediately tell he was talking about one of the journos. “I’m not going to play into their hands! What do they want me to say: ‘they’re all idiots’?” Many of the journalists who covered the conference did nothing to assuage such fears. When I checked my RSS feed to find stories from the conference, I sighed. One journalist had misrepresented anti-abortion activist Dr Angela Lanfranchi by suggesting that Lanfranchi had only cited studies involving rats to support her breast cancer-abortion link thesis in her speech. But Lanfranchi had presented a swath of research, including at least one recent study involving several hundred Chinese women. I was one of the only writers that had managed to stick it out until the final session, and now I realised that at least some of the conference-goers were using their phones to read how the press was reporting events. At the end of the last session, in which Larry D. Jacobs, managing director of the WCF, flippantly agreed that denying pain relief to Russian women was potentially a good idea, an audience member had taken the roving microphone and told all conference-goers that Lanfranchi’s session had been misreported. “This is the media ... destructive people ... everything they twist and turn!” two women sitting directly behind me lamented. The woman sitting behind me, believing I worked for the same online publication, peered at my notebook. She could see that the last note I had taken was "brushed off idea of pain relief being withheld to Russian women seeking abortion". “Are you going to report it like that?” she said. “Do you write for them?” With news outlets treating the World Congress of Families as farcical, as a setup for a series of jokes, attendees were simply being led to further distrust any information that did not come filtered through pro-life media channels. During one speech, a speaker mentioned The Sydney Morning Herald, to snickers from the audience. Another speaker sardonically urged journalists in the room to ask audience members whether they were afraid of being in a hall full of violent people. There was no major news publication conference attendees felt they could trust; The Australian predictably offered the most sympathetic coverage by running an AAP story that limited its coverage to the protest, with only fleeting mention of the content covered at the conference itself. When I made my way out of the World Congress of Families, all the police and protesters had left. Earlier, I’d spoken to Sam Castro from the Whistleblowers, Activists and Citizens Alliance, who had explained that the protesters’ intention was always to leave early. “We rid the event of every elected representative,” she said. “Our goals have already been achieved.” An elderly woman stepped out of the church compound, its gates now wide open, and looked at the graffiti that had been scribbled across the road. “Don’t knock it ‘til you’ve tried it”, somebody had written in red chalk. “Bigots are really shit,” somebody had written in green. She looked baffled. Noting that the protesters had left, the old woman smiled, perhaps assuming this meant they had been forcibly removed by the police. “We have won the victory in Jesus’ name,” she muttered, before shuffling off down the road, back to her car.

Free Trial

Proudly annoying those in power since 2000.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

5 thoughts on “Little common ground and less understanding at pro-life conference

  1. SusieQ

    I’ve always been suspicious of people from Carlton too…..

  2. mikeb

    “Bigots are really shit,”

    Apart from the demonstrators having a poor grasp of written English they also fail to recognise irony.

  3. CML

    These people need a reality check. If they think outlawing abortion is such a good idea, then perhaps they need to see what happens to women who have a backyard job.
    I remember being in Sydney as a young midwife back in the early 1960’s, when many of these women were unceremoniously dumped on the pavement outside emergency, from cars which sped off in the night. Most of them had ‘gone wrong’ sometime before, and were barely alive at this stage. A few were saved, but most succumbed to their raging septacaemia and died quickly.
    What a total waste of a young life. It left a profound impression on me, and to this day, I continue to fight these pro-life lunatics. Abortion has been going on for centuries, and is unlikely to be stopped anytime soon. Best it be done under clinical and safe conditions.

  4. Sally Goldner

    (from me as an individual)

    ” “If they really wanted to challenge our ideas, why wouldn’t they come here, wait until question time, and then pose a question in a logical fashion?” asked Teresa Martin, state president of Cherish Life Queensland. ”

    Here are a few experiences I’ve had as a trans person and advocate or heard about first hand:

    Catholic conversion therapy proponent visits Melbourne. Asks for questions to be written down – but if question wasn’t acceptable after he read it to himself throws piece of paper away. (Catholic women sitting next to me turns to me and says “I’m ashamed to be Catholic).

    2010-ish forum on (then proposed) additions to federal anti-discrimination law. Fundamentalist Christian rants angrily about how “you homosexuals are a tiny percentage of the population, why should we listen to you?”

    Lesbian friend involved in 2008 changes to Victorian ART laws bumps into fundamentalist Christian in corridors of Parliament. Fundamentalist tells my friend “don’t take it personally.” Yes, tell lesbians the are unfit to be parents – but don’t take it personally – rrright.

    How is it possible to communicate logically with people whose emotions have such deep roots?

    A reminder that the real challenge for the world is not the so-called extreme left vs extreme right, but for moderation and reason to succeed over both extremes.

  5. Roberto Tedesco

    How can the “Catch the fire” ministries have a compound without smoke detectors? They obviously never live up to their nam. Very poor.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details