Crikey Says

Aug 7, 2014

Crikey says: Brandis fails political strategy 101

Keane on Brandis’ train wreck interview and the staffer who let it happen. Why it’s OK to be an attack dog at News -- but Fairfax will hang you out to dry. Rundle on nation states as sporting teams. S-Ferg’s farewell from 7.30. Women against feminism not as stupid as they sound. Inside the sad, lonely life of a pollie’s media adviser. Gerard Henderson's 500-word "I told you so". Should extra-curricular cock-ups end your career? And the perfect ratio of a Ukranian parliamentary brawl.

"The moment for reform [of the Racial Discrimination Act] has clearly passed," Human Rights Commissioner Tim Wilson said in opening today's "Freedom Symposium" in Sydney. "But the lessons about the need for a united approach should not." It's advice that should be heeded by Attorney-General George Brandis, who was notably absent from today's event. It's Brandis' failings that do much to show the need for that united approach -- first with the government's efforts to reform section 18C of the RDA, and then with its bungled announcement of a data retention scheme. There are many who believe Brandis lost the chance to reform 18C when he declared that people had the right to be bigots. It is a straightforward statement -- like it or not, people do have such a right -- but politically, it was a disaster that altered perceptions of the government's proposed reform away from free speech to the right of people to express crude racism and bigotry. More broadly, the government manifestly failed to learn the lesson that its predecessor struggled to grasp: that proposing any controversial reform requires voters to be convinced that there's a problem that needs fixing in the first place. It's a lesson Brandis himself might make an effort to learn as he works to reverse the debacle of the government's own attack on free speech via data retention.

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

2 thoughts on “Crikey says: Brandis fails political strategy 101

  1. klewso

    He’d have to shed his Hubris armour first?

  2. AR

    I find it truly ironic that Brandis of all people can, and appears willing, nay eager – if AM interview is true, to suffer for being correct in his principal of staning up for the rights of Bigotus Brandisii. Delectable.
    Who knows what other sound principals might lurk in that unpromising, humanoid shaped form?

  3. Scott

    I’m not sure it was Brandis’ declaration – that people have a right to be bigots – that lost the argument. I think the deciding moment might have been the government’s realisation that if they put themselves between Andrew Bolt and section 18C they would also have to throw themselves between Mike Carlton and the Israeli lobby.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details