Aug 1, 2014

Kids in detention: is Immigration malicious, or just utterly incompetent?

The Immigration Department has long known about the challenges of providing mental health services to detainees. Its failures on Christmas Island and Nauru reflect massive incompetence.

Bernard Keane — Politics editor

Bernard Keane

Politics editor

Revelations about the Immigration Department's treatment of children in detention point to one of the most serious failings in Australian public policy in years. The head of the department, Martin Bowles, should be facing dismissal if the appalling state of conditions in which children are being detained, and departmental efforts to cover them up, are confirmed. The long list of examples of failures in medical treatment provided by health professionals at yesterday's Human Rights Commission hearing into the detention of children amounts to a serious abrogation of Australia's duty of care to those it detains. The list includes removing medication from arriving asylum seekers and failing to replace it, in some cases for serious conditions; removing items such as glasses and hearing aids and not replacing them; a lack of basic medical equipment and pharmaceuticals, the withholding of medical records from health professionals, and even a lack of soap for basic sanitation. And that only relates to the physical health of the detained children. There are also manifestly widespread mental health problems among them, and frequent incidents of self-harming. It was in relation to mental health that the most serious allegation was made yesterday, by Dr Peter Young, a former officer for healthcare provider International Health and Medical Services (IHMS): that the Immigration Department had demanded information about the appalling level of mental health problems on Christmas Island be withdrawn. Having taken a decision to detain children, in some cases indefinitely, the government owes them a duty of basic care. The mental health problems of long-term detention are well known. There was a parliamentary inquiry into Immigration detention in 2011 that studied the issue in detail. IHMS is, according to that committee, contracted "to provide health services to detainees at the standard available in the general Australian community". But evidence to the inquiry showed the contracted provider, IHMS, struggling with the challenges of providing adequate mental health services on Christmas Island.
"The conditions provided for children in detention are bad enough that children would be removed for their own protection if the same conditions were found in Australia."
The mental health impacts of detention also informed the work of the 2012 independent panel of Angus Houston, Paris Aristotle and Michael L'Estrange. In recommending offshore processing on Nauru, they recommended that "appropriate physical and mental health services" be provided with "monitoring of care and protection arrangements by a representative group drawn from government and civil society in Australia and Nauru". When the Gillard government reopened the Nauru detention centre, Crikey reported on the problems for IHMS in providing adequate mental health services there. There is, therefore, no possible reason why the Immigration Department should not be aware of both the need to ensure adequate mental health treatment for long-term detainees, and the difficulties of doing so. Officials have had at least three years since the 2011 committee report to work out ways to ensure IHMS provides adequate mental health services. Judging by the evidence both in relation to female detainees self-harming on Christmas Island and that which has emerged in relation to children on Christmas Island and Nauru, the department has manifestly failed. The failure extends to the provision of basic physical health services. But there's never been evidence that there is some fundamental difficulty about getting antibiotics, or basics like soap, to Christmas Island or Nauru, or about replacing medication for a child with epilepsy or replacing a hearing aid or glasses taken from them (for some reasons presumably known to Immigration, but otherwise a mystery). The conditions provided for children in detention are bad enough that children would be removed for their own protection if the same conditions were found in Australia. And this is also the department that has overseen the murder of Reza Barati. It's a legitimate question, therefore, about whether Immigration's failure is a deliberate policy to inflict misery on detainees. That's a question Bowles professed to be offended at when it was put to him yesterday. But the only possible alternative is that his department is incompetent and has been incompetent for a long period. Now there is an allegation it has sought to cover up its incompetence or malice. It remains an allegation only, but if true it would be of a piece with the systematic and absurd obsession with secrecy that now attends any official discussion of asylum seeker matters. Bowles has been an enthusiastic participant in this secrecy. It's even possible that the department's culture of secrecy has backfired on the Immigration Minister, with Scott Morrison now looking ignorant and foolish for trying, presumably on the basis of departmental advice, to dismiss claims about the conditions of detainees as "sensational". The government's determination to "stop the boats" does not require abuse or negligence of detainees as some sort of warning to those contemplating trying to reach Australia. The point is asylum seekers will never be resettled in Australia and will be detained offshore until their claims are determined and a resettlement destination found. That is the deterrent, plus whatever deterrent value can be obtained from the expensive and diplomatically dangerous mechanism of sending boats back to Indonesia. While we detain them, especially children -- who have made no decision to attempt to come to Australia -- we have a duty of basic care that Martin Bowles' department appears to have abrogated. And if Bowles can't do his job, he should be replaced.

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

22 thoughts on “Kids in detention: is Immigration malicious, or just utterly incompetent?

  1. Fleur

    Crocodile tears from Bernard Keane, who is an enthusiastic supporter of “stopping the boats”. What part of deterrence don’t you understand, Bernard? This is exactly what is intended by the government. If you don’t understand this, then you probably don’t understand the genocidal regimes that Hazaras, Tamils, Rohingya and other refugees are fleeing from. As the current mass murders in Gaza show, killing and maiming children is part and parcel of what states do to underline their authority over subject populations.

  2. Rod

    The inhumanity displayed by Australians is sickening.

  3. Yclept

    It is shameful that this deliberate mistreatment is being perpetrated in our names. Hopefully Karma is coming to Tony and his sidekick clowns.

  4. zut alors

    As the Abbott government perpetrators of this callous policy are practising Chrlstians (allegedly) one wonders how much better off the distressed children would be if deprived of their sanctimonious milk of human kindness.

  5. Albert Ross

    “Chrlstians”? It’s spelled “Charlatans”.

  6. Pamela

    Blaming Bowles, sacking bowles will achieve little.
    Immigration is Ruled from the top by a succession of Ministers empowered by the people of Australia.

    This portfolio is administered like no other- all power lies with the Minister of the day. Not one person exits detention without his personal approval.Not one visa is issued without this say so. This minister is supported by a coterie of cruelty competing for the masters approval which sees the deterrent policy being implemented in an increasingly cruel and brutal fashion in order to deter.

    Yesterday was unusual in that contractors and staff were subpoena’d to speak and truth was outed.
    They were repeating what advocates and whistle blowers have previously reported without concern being raised.

  7. The Pav

    My money is on incompetent following the Sir Humphrey Rule in chosing between strategy and lethergy chose lethergy with the PS

    It could be that actually they are making the situation so bad to finally force the Australian public to find its conscience and humanity and rise up against this onscenity being perpertrated in our name

    Since Joe Hockey said child detention would occur over his dead body can we assume that a new ( and hopefully competent although given the talent in the coalition this is unlikely) treasurer will be appointed.

  8. AR

    After watching those wrenched and rung out doctors giving their simple, clear statements I almost threw up when it was followed by a mr Blobby bureaucrat that commenced to begin to drone on with almost pure jargon about ‘top strategies’.

  9. Jaybuoy

    under any other parliament Morrison would have been forced to resign..the sight of his department head scurrying from the press this morning after his arcane display at a senate inquiry was instructional.. and since when does a Minister of the crown fob questions off by saying he is under the control of a “General” and will therefore not be answering lest he be in breach of his orders… wtf wtf wtf…

  10. graybul

    Any review of any Service in a civilized society that involved a “Duty of Care” as revealed by Human Rights Commission Enquiry about the treatment of asylum seekers’ children . . would result in perpetrator(s) dismissal and/or legal action via justice system.
    The Minister himself is “Legal Guardian” to many of the incarcerated, abused children.
    Fifty years of working in Community with oppressed people’s. Am in tears of rage at this Government and Senior Officers responsible.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details