Jun 3, 2014

Can Gerard Henderson judge PM’s Literary Awards fairly?

Gerard Henderson is a well-documented ideological warrior -- can he put politics aside to judge the Prime Minister's Literary Awards? Chris Feik, publisher of Black Inc, and Morry Schwartz, director of Schwartz Media, are suggesting a way to keep the judging process transparent.

Gerard Henderson was recently appointed chair of the judging panel for the Prime Minister’s literary award for non-fiction. Henderson has a history of incessant and obsessive criticism of leading Australian writers and commentators with whom he disagrees politically. This can be seen at his Media Watch Dog blog, in his numerous columns and extensive correspondence. He is an ideological warrior whose regular targets include David Marr, Peter FitzSimons, Robert Manne, Elizabeth Farrelly, Margaret Simons, Malcolm Fraser, Virginia Trioli, Mungo MacCallum, Waleed Aly, Guy Rundle, Laura Tingle, Jonathan Green, Fran Kelly, Malcolm Farr, Mark Latham, Paul Bongiorno, Phillip Adams, Tim Flannery, Tim Soutphommasane, Nick Dyrenfurth and Hugh White. In other words, among Henderson’s political targets are many of Australia’s leading writers, commentators, historians and journalists. If any of these writers were to submit a book for the 2014 Prime Minister’s Non-Fiction Literary Prize, Henderson’s history of campaigning against them means they could have no confidence of receiving an unprejudiced reading. His appointment politicises what has until now been an apolitical award based on merit. The Prime Minister’s Literary Award for Non-Fiction professes to judge the best non-fiction written by an Australian each year. The politicisation of this award means that the award’s integrity has been seriously damaged. In such a politicised atmosphere, a new transparency is essential. Black Inc. will publish a list of all books it enters for the prize. As a sign of good faith, the award should publish a list of all entries received so that readers can see what was submitted and rejected, as well as what was shortlisted. We urge this course of action, which costs nothing and increases the accountability of the nation’s richest literary prizes. * This is the text of a media release issued today by publishers Black Inc., an imprint of Schwartz Media

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

13 thoughts on “Can Gerard Henderson judge PM’s Literary Awards fairly?

  1. Rodney Adler

    Gerard Henderson must be considered a great success on numerous levels. He is a journalist of considerable note and respect. He has created one of Australia’s leading think tanks and continues to manage it with his wife and he has the respect of the greater Australian community. Granted not everyone agrees with his views all the time but he does expresses views forcibly and logically. He does create discussion— that is his job
    Just because he has strong views does not mean that he cannot be independent, transparent and fair and if “the powers” believe he is the best choice, then maybe we should respect their decision. Maybe the writers of the article have their own agenda!

  2. paddy

    “Rodney Adler” eh?
    Love your work and love the handle.

  3. Jaybuoy

    This is a bloke who to applause of the Newscorpse only came up with the Sirs and Dames to “wedge” Bill Shortens mother in law so no surprises..

  4. klewso

    Considering what he churns out, you’d think someone getting that job would have had to have “some experience with non-fiction”, as a prerequisite for the job?

  5. Kevin Herbert

    The Hendi is a right wing blatherer…hasn’t had a new idea in 40 years…please let me know when he has one.

    Mark Latham wipes the floor with Hendo every time the latter attempts to criticise the former Member for Werriwa.

    Abbott’s judgement is clearly flawed….again.

  6. Kevin Herbert

    I’m always most interested in joint by-lines.

    Did Chris write every second sentence & Morry subbed it..or the opposite?

  7. Liamj

    Graham Henderson exists to make Chris Pyne look like an adult.

    With GH as literary critic & christian chaplains as protectors of children, whats next, Ivan Milat to run the tourism commission?

  8. beachcomber

    Gerard Henderson channels BA Santamaria. As long as only only financial members of the DLP are eligible to submit books for assessment, I am sure he will do an excellent job.

  9. zut alors

    He’d be better suited as a proof reader due to his pedantry – but as a judge…?

  10. AR

    Gerontius, the junk yard dog of the literary world.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details