Facebook Google Menu Linkedin lock Pinterest Search Twitter



May 29, 2014

Inside Manus Island: expect crime, violence and deadly disease in PNG, detainees told

The Citizen journalists Rose Iser, Bec Zajac, Michael Roddan and Chris Shearer report on information being given to asylum seekers about PNG.


Asylum seekers detained on Manus Island were told that Papua New Guinea was dangerous, impoverished and corrupt as part of education sessions about the resettlement country.

Six PowerPoint modules seen by The Citizen were used to “educate” asylum seekers about life in PNG. The slides and accompanying notes painted a picture of a country plagued by crime, random violence and deadly diseases.

The Citizen understands the Department of Immigration and Border Protection approved the use of the modules after requesting education material be compiled by Salvation Army staff in Port Moresby. The material was collated partly to satisfy asylum seeker curiosity and answer detainees’ questions about the country in which they were being held. The answers were blunt, to say the least.

In a possible portent of the violence that was to erupt in February, leaving Iranian Reza Berati dead, the advice to asylum seekers read:

“The police will do whatever they can to try to control [a protest]. This has sometimes involved beatings, slashing with machetes and imprisonment.”

Regarding corruption, asylum seekers were told: “Police may ask for money or sexual favours in return for not imprisoning or beating you.” The notes continued: “[The police] might also commit crimes themselves, such as bashing or killing someone, in return for a small bribe.”

It is understood that the sessions were delivered by Salvation Army staff and personnel from PNG Immigration in December 2013 and January this year as part of the education and activities schedule at the detention centre.

The Australian and PNG governments confirmed on April 3 that asylum seekers sent to Manus Island and found to be refugees would be resettled in PNG and “no one will be resettled in Australia”.

The modules also provided frank details about child abuse in PNG: “Physical and sexual violence against children has been common, especially in families where the mother is also abused.”

A session on public safety covered topics including criminal gangs, tribal wars, human trafficking, crocodiles and volcanoes. Asylum seekers were also told that half of all deaths in PNG were caused by diseases such as malaria, tuberculosis, rabies, HIV/AIDS, cholera and typhoid.

[flagallery gid=9 name=”Gallery”]

The presentations described living conditions as impoverished and harsh:

“People often move to the cities to find work. When they can’t find a job, they usually live in a settlement. Settlements are slum areas that usually have no reliable electricity supply, no clean water, no sewers and no garbage collection.

“Many people who live in the settlements have no income at all, and no food except what is offered to them by local charities or churches.”

In other notes seen by The Citizen, the sessions were described as giving detainees an opportunity to find out facts about PNG:

“It also empowers transferees by providing the correct information about the country they will be settled in if they are determined to be refugees and issues [sic] a visa.”

The modules, created in September 2013, drew mainly on internet sources including newspaper articles, blogs and forums.

Schedules of lessons and activities show designated periods for asylum seekers to view the blunt presentations about the resettlement country. It is not clear how many asylum seekers attended the briefings, although it is believed that they were made available to about 70% of those detained on Manus Island.

Immigration Minister Scott Morrison told ABC’s 7:30 program last month that “resettlement is freedom from persecution, it’s not a ticket to a first-class economy”.

After protracted negotiations, PNG agreed in early April to resettle at Australia’s expense asylum seekers found to be refugees. The first asylum seeker claims are being finalised this month.

The Department of Immigration did not respond to inquiries from The Citizen.

*This article was originally published at The Citizen


We recommend

From around the web

Powered by Taboola


Leave a comment

16 thoughts on “Inside Manus Island: expect crime, violence and deadly disease in PNG, detainees told

  1. paddy

    Sickening and shameful.
    What sort of country have we become?

  2. Yclept

    We are just some multinational subsidiary!

  3. Pamela

    Alongside this threatening stuff, are loony tunes IHMS “counsellors” taking groups for “mindfulness” and “positive thinking”.
    With the increase in numbers, individual counselling was abandoned and the counsellors ran group therapy instead.

    Driving people crazy is the Name of the Game.

  4. Brian Williams

    While I’m not thrilled with the way the govt has handled this problem, I’ve got to say that the conditions in which the refugees are living doesn’t look any worse than that which I endured backpacking around Europe in the 1980s, except that I actually had to pay to do it.

  5. mikeb

    In what condition were the toilet and washroom facilities when originally installed? How did they end up in their current condition?

  6. Stuart Coyle

    I do hope that the Salvation Army staff doing the breifing also mentioned that they may also beat the prisoners…sorry ‘detainees’.

  7. Suzanne Blake

    How about covering what the detainees call the PNG people through the fence!! No boats in 6 months, that has saved lives, and saved us billions in costs

  8. graybul


  9. MarilynJS

    Brian, you are really, really stupid.

  10. Pamela

    Problem with toilets is no water- cant flush.
    Many folks from Middle east use water not paper.
    Water bottles used to try to clean.
    Also Contractors refuse to give men any cleaning products, cloths etc to clean the facilities on basis that someone might drink it.
    The metal cage floor is a nice post modern touch.

  11. Patriot

    When I did a stint of detention as a youth we were responsible for cleaning our own ablutions. They have to learn to do it themselves sooner or later. Clean a man’s toilet and you care for him for a day. Teach him how to clean it and not turn it into a shit heap in the first place and you care for him for a lifetime.

    I don’t care if they’re Middle Eastern. You can toilet train a 2 year old.

  12. Slinkycatsmutha

    One day this nation will have to pay a high price for the atrocities committed in these concentration camps. As a trauma specialist working with abused clients I am appalled at the conditions asylum seekers have to endure, and that after fleeing terror and oppression. Shame on the architects of these inhumane and unaustralian policies that destroy hope and crush the human spirit. Be very wary of any government that treats the most oppressed and vulnerable in this manner and all in the name of their god.

  13. graybul

    Slinkycat @ The Christian God . . is a God of “Love”. So not one individual from the Minister, the Military Strategist, Departmental Head(s) down to the Salvation Army employee ‘who allegedly threw the rock’ . . could legitimately claim to be acting in His/Her Name!! However, each individual could/can seek forgiveness for their obscene lack of care and/or accountability . . from a Christian God?

  14. Elbow Patches

    Paddy asks, ‘what sort of country have we become?’ … The answer is a very troubling one. More troubling than anything we have faced in recent times. Our best hope, is that many are being roused from complacency, and preparing themselves to go beyond the usual responses, of despair, or cynicism,pretending it will go away, or escapism. Rather, I hope that good people will recognise what has once been referred to as the banality of evil, and refuse to let it pass. There have been examples of Liberal people standing up to their party going in the wrong direction on other fronts – in Qld Dr Chris Davis resigned on principle. In the federal parliament a backbencher has called them out on their extremely poor science policies. Brave people exist. Don’t leave them to do it alone. Everyone with a conscience needs to stand up for what they know is right. Give support to those who do the right thing. Don’t just laugh at all of what is going on. What sort of country have we become? Yes, the times are troubling, but ultimately, the answer is in our hands.

  15. graybul

    Elbow Patches@ Best Post have read for some time! Measured, focussed and right on the button.

  16. Dan B

    Many times a “distressed asylum seeking vessel” called our emergency services faking a MAYDAY call. Emergency services arrived on-scene only to find a boat load of illegals smiling, and asking for a tow to Australia. They used numbers given to them by previously successful illegals who made it ashore.
    Let them now tell their friends back home that the free ride is over.


https://www.crikey.com.au/2014/05/29/inside-manus-island-expect-crime-violence-and-deadly-disease-in-png-detainees-told/ == https://www.crikey.com.au/free-trial/==https://www.crikey.com.au/subscribe/

Show popup

Telling you what the others don't. FREE for 21 days.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.