Saville's Shout

Feb 17, 2014

Saville’s shout: few law jobs … work from home … setting a scene …

There are far more law graduates than jobs in the legal profession at the moment, with law school grads being encouraged to choose another profession. Plus other bits and pieces.

Margot Saville — <em>Crikey</em> Sydney reporter

Margot Saville

Crikey Sydney reporter

The first thing we do, let's kill all the lawyers. Recent news in Fairfax papers that the number of Australian law graduates has doubled over the past decade should strike fear into the heart of any graduate hoping to pay off his or her HECS debt and earn a living. More than 12,000 lawyers are graduating from law every year, into a profession that currently stands at around 60,000 members. Most of the that growth has come in the area of post-graduate law, the numbers for which increased from 1635 in 2001 to 7036 in 2013. The Australian Law Students Association said at the end of 2013 it was concerned about the decreasing number of jobs for graduates, with the pool of graduate positions shrinking largely due to post-GFC cost constraints and an increasing tendency of firms to outsource routine legal work, much of it to lower-cost countries like India. In the US, these kinds of changes have led to a substantial drop-off in the number of law school enrollments. In an article in The Atlantic last week, authors Richard Gunderman and Mark Mutz write that law school enrolments have almost halved in the past eight years, and more than one-third of graduates are unable to find full-time work. One of the most fundamental problems for lawyers is the downgrading of legal work from a noble profession imbued with special characteristics to that of a legal services factory in which success is judged solely on money, the authors say:
"To professionals who choose careers in fields such as law, medicine, and teaching, it is demoralizing to be treated as a unit of production. Even some of the lawyers earning millions of dollars report that they find little or no fulfillment in the work they do."
The role of the average lawyer has fundamentally changed, they write.
"As a mere service provider, success is measured not in the professional insight and practical wisdom she offers but in the technical efficiency with which she provides services and her ability to attract other clients willing to pay her to do the same. The sense of professional fulfillment associated with the role of service provider is small at best."
When surveyed, more than six out of 10 US lawyers said they would advise students to "seek a different career". When I graduated from law school in the 1980s, the profession more closely resembled this description by British politician David Mellor:
"Lawyers are like rhinoceroses: thick skinned, short-sighted, and always ready to charge."
Get out of my office. If anyone asked you where you did your most productive work, "at the office" would probably not be at the top of the list. For most of us, our best work happens in an environment over which we have more control -- at home, or tucked up in a corner of the local library. A new book from businessmen Jason Fried and David Hansson, entitled Remote: Office Not Required,  produces evidence to show why this is the case. In a thesis that will seem horribly familiar to all desk jockeys, the authors say that offices, particularly open-plan ones, offer smallish chunks of work time between meetings, conference calls and other interruptions. However, "the real creative work, the type that requires concentration, happens during non-peak times or when employees are away from the office in an interruption-free zone". If workers do need some uninterrupted time, they usually go in early or stay back late. "Although it seems we’re working more," Fried and Larsson say, "we’re putting in longer hours but accomplishing less because we’re not actually getting anything done at the office." Stepping away from the office is the best way to get meaningful work done. For some that place might be a cafe, and for others it could be a library or a home office. Noisy cafes can be easier to work in than the office because the type of noise is different. The authors point out:
"If you’re in a coffee shop and there’s white noise and people are having conversations that don’t involve you at all and have nothing to do with the work you’re doing, it’s easy to block them out."
However, the two men who founded successful IT company 37signals, are not advocating eliminating offices altogether. "There are benefits to social interaction at work, but most work is ultimately solo work," they say. While it makes sense to have a gathering place to brainstorm ideas every once and a while, once tasks have been delegated, "everyone should disperse to their own area to do the real work". In living colour. Don't miss the last week of New Acquisitions in Context, an exhibition at Sydney’s Museum of Contemporary Art that juxtaposes new works with pieces from the existing collection. It features works by 28 Australian and international artists ranging across painting and photography to video art and installation. Highlights include works by Howard Arkley (first below), Tracey Moffatt (second below) and Mike Parr ...

Howard Arkley

Tracey Moffatt

Free Trial

Proudly annoying those in power since 2000.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

4 thoughts on “Saville’s shout: few law jobs … work from home … setting a scene …

  1. Dogs breakfast

    “One of the most fundamental problems for lawyers is the downgrading of legal work from a noble profession imbued with special characteristics to that of a legal services factory in which success is judged solely on money”

    Yes, alas, lawyers having to join the rest of the world.

    Whenever someone informs me that they will be studying law, these days it is a boast, given the need for ridiculously high marks, I invariably ask them if they shouldn’t consider an honest profession as an alternative.

    There was a time when I thought lawyers were intelligent people, and perhaps they were, but I have now been exposed to a sufficient number to realise that as a group, they are in fact less intelligent than your average tradie (no, that’s not a put-down yo elitist scum, it is to say that they are moderately intelligent, at best)

    Of course a tradie is a hugely useful person who by the minute, hour and day actually solves real problems and gets real things done. No such luck from our highly paid lawyerly lot.

    I now find them increasingly dim, heavily over-invested in their egos, but most compellingly, hugely and hopelessly locked in linear thought, and unaware that linear thinking is really quite straightforward, as the phrase suggests. And it should be no surprise, because reading words on a page and deciphering their meaning isn’t actually that astounding an intellectual feat!

    Any out of the box problem will flummox them completely, creative or original thought is beyond them, analysis is another planet entirely.

    Oh I am having fun, you can’t see how much my tongue is in my cheek, but that isn’t to say that I believe every word I have just said.

    Good day.

    And go and find an honest profession, you blaggards

  2. Chris Hartwell

    I’m almost scared to hear your thoughts on engineers Dogs Breakfast.

  3. Dogs breakfast

    Dear Mr Hartwell,

    Be afraid, be very afraid!!!!! 🙂

    I kid you not, I have worked in a number of industries, and Lawyers and Engineers are the stand-outs in terms of other-worldly mindsets.

    But at least Engineers are useful.

  4. Thomas McLoughlin

    I agree the profession should be a profession. And it must be an honest one. However there is a really big issue with the angle on this story of a so called over supply.

    The NSW Law and Justice Foundation in recent years showed with compelling statistics that 8 million adult Australians have unmet legal service needs. Hello. This is a huge ‘market’ that has convinced itself they can never afford a lawyer, the way many cannot afford a dentist, with an under supply of service providers. Virtually every person I meet has a legal problem that needs real legal work.

    Probably like DB above, before I did real legal work I thought anyone could get the right legal information and provide the right legal advice and strategy. However this is just not the case. We live in a really big complex social contract and it’s no personal failing to not be up with the intricacies of that contract in every diverse situation – including just walking down the street.

    A real lawyer weeds out the useful primary materials and guideline judgements from secondary materials, swims in an ocean of commentary and precedent to the island of safe reliable principles, throws a safety line and buoy to the client and shows them how to avoid the sharks of prison or bankruptcy – if only by carefully outlining why they don’t have a winning case so go find – as suggested above – an alternative often non legal approach.

    But why is there such a mismatch of need to service provision? This is the real story we need written. Please investigate and write on this – professional indemnity insurance is a barrier to start ups, cost of CLE ongoing training is arguably excessive, clients themselves are frightened by the overpriced rates based on the tv legend and indeed big corporate reality of big city overheads and lavish lifestyles of the mere 5% CBD sector.

    In reality most lawyers in NSW are sole practitioners – well over 50% as I understand. If they can reduce overheads via laptop and open source software (eg back up software via major geeks website), open office suite compatible to microsoft word etc then they are on the road to the real challenge.

    The real challenge is providing a pursuasive induction to needy clients that they can actually afford sound legal asistance which empowers them, but at present think they are priced out of that service. Yes, to pay for a low priced but effective lawyer might mean going without take away coffee for a month but good legal advice saves alot of time money and trouble too.

    Just like a dentist – who charges alot more usually.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details