Jan 29, 2014

Will Abbott appoint an IPA man to a renewables review?

Talk in Canberra is the government is poised to appoint a leading anti-wind and anti-solar campaigner from the IPA to a new panel to review the renewable energy target. It spells disaster for the sector.

The renewable energy industry in Australia might be tempted to pack their bags and find another country to conduct their business if the latest talk in Canberra is true: sources say that the Abbott government will name Alan Moran, an anti-renewable zealot from the Institute of Public Affairs, to a new panel that will review the Renewable Energy Target.

According to sources, Moran will be one of three or four business people appointed to an “independent” panel that will get secretarial support from the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet — rather than departments for the environment or industry, which includes responsibility for energy.

Free Trial

Proudly annoying those in power since 2000.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

17 thoughts on “Will Abbott appoint an IPA man to a renewables review?

  1. Mark Duffett

    Moran is wrong that “the energy profile in the 1960s was not much different from today”. Renewables have actually gone significantly backwards since then: decarbonisesa.com/2013/10/19/renewable-delusions-of-granduer/

  2. Scott

    “South Australia now has more than 31% of its demand sourced from wind and solar, without the need for any new backup generation”

    The reason it doesn’t need backup generation is due to fact it can import “brown coal” energy from Victoria. Over 2012-2013, it imported 13% of its energy needs from Victoria.
    At the end of the day, someone has to provide the backup. If it’s not SA, it will be someone else.

  3. klewso

    I want to know what Abbott and his sponsors are going to do if/when the institutionalising of his/their ideology goes wrong?

  4. Honest Johnny

    The energy market is already skewed in favour of the large producers. My house produces twice as much electricity than we use, however we are forced to buy (at night) at prices 4 times more than what the electricity producers pay us for our excess during daytime peak periods. Maybe Moran can help level the playing field. Did that sound overly optimistic?

  5. Andybob

    Issues regarding renewables have become depressingly partisan. This is partly because of the money at stake and partly because both ‘sides’ rely on specious special pleading and ad hominem attacks to support their positions.

    The wind industry has spoilt the renewable brand by repeatedly giving short shrift to legitimate complaints of nuisance instead of constructively engaging in harm reduction. That has created a reservoir of suspicion and discontent in rural Australia which is fertile ground for each and every anti-global warming and anti-renewable conspiracy theory.

    It is now almost impossible to find anyone trusted enough by both renewables advocates and critics to conduct an independent review that might stand a chance of having influence. Instead we face the depressing prospect of continuous policy fluctuation as each change of government results in successive reviews making predetermined findings according to the prejudices of their political masters.

  6. Dogs breakfast

    What, no mention of the subsidies that are paid to the air-conditioned McMansion owners who overload the system on hot days and are responsible for some 20-25% of the average electricity bill, just to ensure supply on those 2 to 5 days a year?

    Giles, didn’t he mention anything about those subsidies? Didn’t he mention anything about how solar has reduced the number and severity of those peak events, where electricity wholesale prices peak at multiples of 10, 20 and 50 (100s?) times the standard non-peak Kwh hour price, making a complete mockery of a ‘market solution’.

    It didn’t get a mention? Get outta here!!!

  7. AR

    Why the surprise? The IPA wrote the nearest thing the tories have as a “to do list” which it is systematically ticking off.
    Why would it also be the source of new recruits? Not as if the current crop of Rodent retreads have a spark of IQ between them.
    Trust Duffer above to leap in first with the counterfact. My puzzlement is not “where” he finds them but “why”? What is the deep psychological need he’s trying to assuage?

  8. tonyfunnywalker

    Scott- how may homes were blacked out in Victoria during last weeks heatwave- may for a week – how many people died due to heat related reasons? How many homes were blacked out in SA last week NONE. Victoria, the polluters State has 19th century generation technology meeting 21st century needs – Climate Change aside. Lignite coupled with ageing generators means a 30% efficiency whereas PV solar creates its own efficiency at its free ( well almost ) when its needed most.
    The sooner we fire this moron of a government the better as they were not elected just be serve the vested interests of the IPA.
    I have my PV solar thanks and I love my electricity bills since I installed it. Both my wife and I are ageing and of fragile health – so rather than worry about the cost when the AC is on – at least I have a new and welcome peace of mind. If anyone thinks repealing the carbon tax will cut you electricity bill think again – its just a con like most of Abbott’s ideas. I refrain using the word policies as they are abdicated to cronies and has beens’ and Abbott Government is the government of nothing but a wanton destruction of our society especially if you are old, disabled, young families with children, unemployed, disadvantaged. The next election will not be soon enough.

  9. JohnB

    Playing the man, I see.
    The man speaks the truth and the difference is due to the reduced percentage of hydro in the system. Other parts have grown since the Snowy scheme, but not much hydro has been added.

    As a percentage of energy delivered, neither solar nor wind have made up for the declining energy share represented by hydro.

    So, renewables are going backwards in our energy mix.

    Understand now?

    Its time for an apology to MD. Are you man enough to do so?

  10. Jimmyhaz

    You know I was cautiously optimistic about this government when they were first elected, I honestly believed that they would be able to grow into something resembling a decent government.

    The more I read about them, however, the more I realise that they are a bunch of baboons so blinded by their ridiculous ideology that they are not fit to run my local lemonade stall, let alone a country like Australia.

    What is so difficult about realising that they are elected to represent the best interests of all Australians? Not those who voted for them, not the business interests that backed their campaigns, not the media that became a farce for them, but everyone.

    This government is going to go down as the worst in Australia’s history to date, the only plus is that they will be a one-term government.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details