Jan 20, 2014

Australia’s big asylum seeker policy hole

Any plans for a regional solution to asylum seeker migration is in tatters because of his Australia's approach to Indonesia. We're in a policy hole, and we just keep digging.

Professor Damien Kingsbury

Crikey international affairs commentator

Australia and Indonesia have worked hard over the past decade to build a strong bilateral relationship, seen as valuable by Indonesia and as critically important by Australia. That relationship is now in tatters. The Australian government has been at pains to explain to Indonesia that recent naval incursions into Indonesian territorial waters, intended to stop asylum seeker boats, were unintentional. From Indonesia’s perspective, it matters little whether the incursions were intentional or just the logical if unintended consequence of a much disliked Australian government policy. Similarly, Australia’s policy of giving asylum seekers lifeboats to return to Indonesia adds a further layer of complication to Australian policy. From Indonesia’s perspective, the flow of asylum seekers is not official Indonesian policy, but the Australian navy putting asylum seekers bound for Australia in Australian lifeboats bond for Indonesia is official Australian policy. This policy is seen by Indonesia as diplomatically clumsy as it is objectionable. Indonesia has said, repeatedly, that it wants Australia to abandon its policy of turning back asylum seeker boats. Putting asylum seekers in lifeboats only heightens those objections. Indonesia has now launched its own naval patrols, not to stop asylum seekers leaving Indonesia but to stop Australian naval incursions. Australian naval vessels will no doubt be extra cautious about future transgressions into Indonesian territorial waters and, beyond that, there are a series of warnings to go through before confrontation. At best, however, the bilateral relationship is continuing to deteriorate. At worst, mistakes can happen. The Australian navy may continue to turn (or tow) asylum seeker boats back to near Indonesian territorial waters. But it will not be able to compel asylum seeker boats to remain within them. When the monsoonal season ends and the "sailing season" resumes, around April, the flow of asylum seeker boats is again likely to increase. The problem faced by the Australian Navy will, therefore, become more rather than less complicated. The first question is, then, whether Australia’s defence approach to an immigration issue is sustainable. The second and larger question is whether Australia can continue to alienate, seeming indefinitely, its most important strategic relationship. If Australia is serious about finding a long-term solution to the asylum seeker issue, it needs to work closely with Indonesia and other regional neighbors to put in place agreed and workable policies. Such policies go beyond the simple, if failed, "policing"" that existed until late last year. Indonesia, probably Malaysia and possibly Thailand and Singapore need to have in place stricter immigration policies, to screen "onward bound" travellers. There also needs to be regional co-operation around the quicker and internationally recognised processing of those asylum seekers who do end up in the region. Such a policy would limit the flow of asylum seekers, would meet Australia’s international obligations and would not alienate critically important relationships. However, this would require the type of trust and co-operation that Australia’s existing approach to asylum seekers has effectively ended. The Australian government’s approach to asylum seekers worked well as a pre-election slogan, but lacked a properly developed plan. As a result, Australia has dug itself into a policy hole. If Australia now wishes to extricate itself from this situation it must start by following the first rule of holes: when you are in one, stop digging. *Professor Damien Kingsbury is director of the Centre for Citizenship, Development and Human Rights at Deakin University

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

27 thoughts on “Australia’s big asylum seeker policy hole

  1. Tamas Calderwood

    Still, this ‘clumsy’ and ‘objectionable’ policy does seem to have stopped the boats… And the same policy acted as a ‘long term solution’ when it was implemented by the Howard government.

  2. Dez Paul

    Surely our Navy personnel are not that stupid, ill-equipped or incompetent to “unintentionally” stray into Indonesian waters? I bet Indonesian Officials don’t believe it.

    This gumint, on the other hand, is that stupid, ill-equipped, incompetent and/or venal to use the Navy as an excuse. What a tragedy, worsening daily.

  3. klewso

    Does this sort of patronising government policy qualify as “gun boat diplomacy”?

  4. j.oneill

    It is not just in our near north that the government is blundering around in foreign policy. As George Browning points out in The Age “Australia’s troubling stance on Israeli settlements” shows Bishop at her ignorant best. One has to assume that Bishop and Morrison are not acting off their own bat and have the support of Abbott and the Cabinet.

    If it wasn’t so potentially dangerous in all sorts of ways for Australia’s best interests it might almost be funny.

  5. klewso

    j., Bishop has an ignorant “best”?
    Reckon this hasn’t been passed by “The Credlin”?

  6. Venise Alstergren

    KLEWSO: I think it should be called “none boat diplomacy.”

    I’m perilously close to becoming ashamed to be an Australian.

  7. Observation

    It would seem the government has placed our navy in the position of prosecutor, judge and jury. The captain of each boat has been given the authority to automatically categorize everyone of these asylum seekers as illegal immigrants, every man woman and child.

    And in the name of placing these people out of a dangerous situation we tow them back towards Indonesia. How is this done, do we ensure their boat is in good mechanical order, with enough food, water and fuel to return to Indonesia only?? Do we need to encroach into Indonesian waters to do this safely? Maybe the Australian public should ask the Jakarta post to investigate?

    I hope this policy fails, because if it does not it will surely set the bar of our humanitarian level below a snakes belly.

  8. Gratton Wilson

    Are we inviting a situation where an Indonesian vessel inadvertently(?) injures Australian naval personnel loitering near the Indonesian marine borders?

  9. graybul

    Cyclone season(s) stop boats! Even then . . how would we know?? Stopping boats, is a distraction! Treatment of Refugees under ‘Rule of the Sea’ and UN Mandates, are the jagged rocks that ultimately will wreck Australian relationships externally, and social values internally.

  10. klewso

    What a pity this Murdoch government hasn’t got half to do the right thing …. that’s all it would take?

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details