Dec 10, 2013

Supermarket bullies and private labels (and why it’s so hard to find ice cream)

Woolies reckons Aldi rips off name-brand products. But it should look at its own shelves first. Crikey's business editor reports on a new code of conduct that could shake up the supermarkets.

Paddy Manning

Crikey business editor

It is hypocritical for Woolworths to attack Aldi for infringing the intellectual property of leading brands, and unfair to use this argument to pressure a rival to sign up to the food and grocery industry's new code of conduct, which Aldi had no input to. In today's Australian Financial Review, Woolworths' supermarkets managing director Tjeerd Jegen pointed to similarities between some of Aldi's exclusive brands and national brands, including Bundaberg ginger beer, Procter & Gamble's Pantene shampoo, General Mills' Old El Paso taco kits and Kellogg's Special K. "One of our major competitors has 96% of their range that is own-brand," Jegen said. "If you don't look carefully, you'd think it came from suppliers' brands." OK, Aldi does make an hilarious art form of ripping off packaging. My favourite is Saint Etienne, which looks just like Stella Artois but sells at Aldi for $29.99 a case. I haven’t bought it yet -- misguided loyalty -- but I'm sure it tastes exactly the same.

The major supermarkets are equally guilty, however. Earlier this year Craig Reucassel did a story called "Copycat" for ABC’s The Checkout program, showing how Coles and Woolworths were jazzing up their home brands into private labels by copying the packaging of successful brands like Grainwaves, Crunchy Nut Corn Flakes, Bounty, and even the Cancer Council's sunscreen -- undercutting the non-profit body's key fund raising tool. "How can you?" Reucassel asked the supermarkets, plaintively. The tactic does work to confuse shoppers. A chef mate, Jo Cook, who has been in the food business for 22 years and is a slow food advocate, was gutted to find she had brought a tub of Coles home brand ice cream to our place for dinner by mistake -- not out of snobbishness, but because she tries to support small, quality producers. She had meant to buy two different tubs of Maggie Beer:
"Sometimes I buy ice cream, when I've missed the Farm Gate market or I haven't felt like making my own. It's a complete drag because there isn't a brand that has real ice cream ingredients -- i.e. milk, cream, eggs and sugar -- they all have emulsifiers and vegetable gums and that's the premium brands as well. In the supermarket when I just wanted to grab quality ice cream and get the hell out they were next to each other and I swear the vanilla bean was a Maggie Beer product too. I would never buy Coles homebrand."

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

14 thoughts on “Supermarket bullies and private labels (and why it’s so hard to find ice cream)

  1. smq

    I don’t go to Wooolies intentionally. (My own protest against pokies / food labelling / ripping off farmers.) I am still trying to find out what shops they own – which I know include Dan Murphy’s. I bought petrol a few months ago thinking I was in a 7/11. I didn’t know I was in a Woolies service station until I looked at the docket. THe colours of the service station were very similar to 7/11. Or am i just unobservant?

  2. zut alors

    The only home brand product I touch is Coles soda water – its only competitors are major players Shweppes and Kirks therefore there’s no conflict with the smaller private brands.

    In general the shelves are becoming increasingly stacked with home brand products sacrificing choice for the consumer. They are treating/herding us like sheep.

  3. Grumpy Old Sod

    A pox on Woolworths, a merrier band of ripoffs I have yet to meet. I made a comparison of Woolworths and Aldi over several years and have found that I save over $100 per week by shopping at Aldi. I don’t know how they do it, I don’t care but am so sick of being ripped off by Woolworths that I couldn’t give a damn if they went broke.

    There was a report by Choice (I think) that demonstrated that Woolworths have a 75% Australian content while Aldi have 90%. In addition, the suppliers of Aldi get paid promptly while those to Woolworths don’t and let’s not get started on Woolworths’ treatments of our primary producers! All in all, I reckon that Aldi is more Australian than Woolworths in their treatment of their stockists, their staff and their customers.

  4. Nici

    The St Etienne is pretty good. Don’t be seduced by the Rivet though. It’s horrible.

  5. MJPC

    GOS, I am with you.In my suburb there are two woolies in close proximity and 1 Aldi directly opposite one of the W’s.
    The prices at the W close to Aldi are noticeably cheaper than the W a distance, proof that competition works where the competitor is Aldi. Also, W’s fruit and veg is crap. I recall buying tomotoes and they lasted a day at home before starting to rot. Aldi always lasts a lot longer at home. Also, Aldi don’t have self service; I won’t support a store that actively plots to get rid of staff (although the staff have been sold the line it doesn’t take their jobs-don’t know what they think happens on Sundays and late at night). There’s plenty of room in the market for all. Revolution now!

  6. zut alors

    MJPC raises a salient point about self-serve. I refuse and queue for a checkout operator regardless of staff trying to divert me when they notice the small quantity of products in the basket. I politely tell them, “No thanks, I’m preserving your job.”

    Can’t wait for Coles’ & Woolworths’ next crude attempt at upping the ante – they’ll have us not only serving ourselves but stacking the shelves.

  7. Suzanne Kelly

    In New Zealand last year, I couldn’t help but notice the much larger range of brands in their supermarkets. Coles and Woolworths here have a lot to answer for. I seldom shop there anymore, prefering Aldi for quality and price.

  8. Yclept

    I refuse to buy W’s home brand products. If I don’t want a brand name I’ll go to Aldi or Costco. The more I can avoid W by using IGA, Aldi and Costco I will. I’m heartily sick of their corporate bully boy tactics – not that they give a rats.

  9. Raaraa

    To be fair, if I walk into Aldi, I don’t expect to see the brands that Woolworths have alleged that Aldi copied from.

    This contrasts with Woolworths where you see a homebrand product and another product on the same shelf looking like each other.

  10. John Webster

    Isn’t amazing that whenever people post responses to articles on the duopoly no one ever says they shop with either Coles or Woolworths. And they say it’s 80% control of the market.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details