Dec 6, 2013

Bitcoin: your handy guide to digital pickpocketing

Bitcoin, like any other currency, can be stolen or laundered. But if the digital currency is not linked to any government with law enforcement powers, is theft really a crime?

Stilgherrian — Technology writer and broadcaster


Technology writer and broadcaster

Bitcoin is the closest we've ever got to a workable digital currency, but its rapidly rising value through 2013 has attracted thieves as well as speculators -- and despite its magic, it's not invulnerable. The more libertarian and anarchist ends of internet culture have long dreamed of a digital equivalent to cash -- money that can be used to buy and sell goods and services online without having the transaction tracked by an intermediary like a fee-hungry bank, or credit card company, or a taxation-hungry government. But how do you create the digital equivalent of a banknote when, in the digital realm, anyone could make a perfect copy in an instant? Counterfeiting would run rife, and the currency would be worthless. There have been various attempts to solve this conundrum using complex mathematics related to that used for encryption and secure digital signatures -- hence the term "cryptocurrency" -- but the most sophisticated came in 2009 when the bitcoin protocol was published by a person or persons unknown using the pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto. It's impossible to explain here how bitcoin works in detail. But at its core is a public ledger of all bitcoin transactions, called the "blockchain". Maintaining that ledger is a task shared by many computers around the world. The fact that user X owns a certain balance of bitcoins is public knowledge, thanks to that ledger -- although users are identified by their random bitcoin addresses, which act as pseudonyms. When user X wants to transfer some bitcoins to user Y, X signs the transaction with his or her secret encryption key and broadcasts the fact -- and the network of computers does the crypto-math to confirm that it's all legit, and the transaction is added to the ledger. It's actually more complicated than that. While each bitcoin has its own identity, just as each banknote has its own unique serial number, they can also be combined or split to make change. All this is recorded in the blockchain ledger. As the chain of transactions has grown ever longer, the amount of computing power that's being deployed to confirm new transactions has also grown massively, to the point where it's now 256 times more powerful that the world's top 500 supercomputers combined. But it's worth it: anyone participating in the process is paid with more bitcoins. But with all the crypto-math precautions, bitcoin users are still vulnerable to some good old-fashioned crime. For a start, bitcoins can be stolen. A bitcoin "wallet" is just a file on the user's computer, so hackers are able to just take a copy, along with their secret key, and start spending -- especially easy of the wallet hasn't been encrypted or password-protected. If someone's got the secret key, then there's no way to distinguish them from the real owner. Some bitcoin users have used web-based wallet services rather than holding onto the bitcoins themselves -- which means the wallets can be stolen in bulk, as happened to a young Australian known as TradeFortress. Similarly, any merchants could just make off with any bitcoin credit they happened to hold on people's behalf, as seems to have happened in the massive Sheep Marketplace heist. While it'd be theoretically possible to trace the bitcoins through the transaction ledger, that's made difficult when the criminals use so-called "tumblers" -- software that automatically splits and re-combines bitcoins at high speed through a large number of fake users, shuffling them so thoroughly it's hard to see which bitcoins went where, or at least to figure it out before the crims have long since departed the scene. None of these are problems with bitcoin itself. It's digital cash, and just like regular cash it can be stolen and laundered. But it's a new arena, and not everyone at the libertarian and anarchist ends of the spectrum are eager to bring in old-school law enforcement.

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

8 thoughts on “Bitcoin: your handy guide to digital pickpocketing

  1. Jimmyhaz

    If Bitcoin is a currency then it is designed to fail, one of the most basic aspects of currency is that it must be inflationary, otherwise there is no incentive to spend. At best bitcoins are collectors items, and at worst they are the worlds largest pyramid scheme.

  2. dazza

    If you google ‘Keiser Report: Bitcoin is Beautiful (E526)
    It’s well explained especially in the second half of his show.

  3. pixeljuice


    I thought bitcoins could be mined using computer rigs. Increasing computing power will allow for more mining and more bitcoins. Is that inflationary enough to pass your basic aspect test?

  4. Aidan Stanger


    Because Bitcoin is not the primary currency of anywhere, the fact that its value can go down as well as up is sufficient incentive to spend. And because Bitcoin is not aimed at those who can’t afford to trade in any other currency, there’s no great need to encourage spending anyway.


    Story critical of bitcoins?

    Incoming crazy people ariving in 3..2..1..


    @Pixeljuice. The trend for bitcoin is more deflationary than almost anything I’ve ever seen. The price of them has jumped from about $10 maybe a year ago to nearly $1000 now (Its dropped a bit, but it’ll be up again). The end result is that the price that can be obtained for goods is dropping at an alarming rate. A year ago a pizza would sell for perhaps 2 bitcoins. Now you’d be lucky to get a couple of percent of a bitcoin.

    Such a loss of value for comodities would be nightmarish in the wider world, and represent an economic downturn like nothing else in history.

  7. Tony Harris

    Maths is the word.

  8. Phil Manhire

    Maybe it’s a sign of a true, “New World Order” technology that can survive the rigours of time…maybe not!

    Unlike the fiat currencies that we have come to see raped pillaged, bastardized in all manners until they go into total meltdown, BitCoin does seem to have potential as a survivable currency….UNLESS that dreaded ‘Black Swan’ event occurs such as……..?

    For mind, a good asset protection measure would still be to have a good slice of ‘cashable’ assets in gold…JUST in case!

    Check out for some more “Golden Thoughts” per se….

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details