Sep 13, 2013

ACMA slaps down ACA over racist ‘Asian mall’ story

A Current Affair has agreed to correct a story the Communications and Media Authority says was likely to provoke racist feeling towards Asians. It's a rare step for a TV broadcaster.

Matthew Knott

Former Crikey media reporter

Channel Nine's A Current Affair has agreed to issue a rare on-air correction tonight after the communications watchdog found a notorious story on an "Asian Mall" in Sydney breached the television code of practice. The Australian Communications and Media Authority found the story -- which claimed a shopping centre in Castle Hill was being overtaken by Asian retailers -- contained inaccuracies, placed a gratuitous emphasis on ethnic origin and was likely to promote intense dislike and serious contempt on the grounds of ethnic origin. The November story by reporter Ben McCormack was quickly debunked by local paper The Hills Shire Times, as Crikey reported last year. Accoridng to the ACMA, this is the first time a commercial TV broadcaster has made an on-air statement as a result of an ACMA investigation. The ACMA found the story, which featured a cameo from Pauline Hanson, was likely to have provoked intense dislike or serious contempt by broadcasting:
  • Negative misinformation about Australians of Asian ethnic origins;
  • Inflammatory language and visuals generating feelings of threat from people of Asian ethnic origins;
  • Language implying that Australians of Asian ethnic origins did not belong in Australia.
The story was found to contain several inaccuracies. These included claims Asian speciality shops would occupy "almost all" of the mall's lower level when the plan was four of the 16 retailers were to be Asian speciality shops. The story also claimed Aussie shopkeepers were being forced out when the plan was to relocate them within the mall. A Current Affair will make an on-air statement about the findings on tonight's episode. ACMA chairman Chris Chapman said:
"I commend TCN for acting on the ACMA’s recommendations. The broadcaster is to be congratulated for taking a mature approach to matters of such concern, and for being transparent with its viewers."
The ACMA has long pushed for the government to grant it new "mid-tier" powers including the ability to force broadcasters to issue on-air corrections.

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

4 thoughts on “ACMA slaps down ACA over racist ‘Asian mall’ story

  1. Persia

    “…four of the 16 retailers were to be Asian speciality shops. The story also claimed Aussie shopkeepers were being forced out when the plan was to relocate them within the mall.”

    Errm….the Asian speciality shops are run by “Aussie shopkeepers” – ya know, we are all Aussies now…

  2. Sharkie

    Is Ben MacCormack still employed after this? It’s about time journalists started holding the racist hacks accountable.

  3. Alex

    Yeah, good on TCN for taking the corrective action, but, what about reviewing their whole approach to reporting? How did that story ever get up in the first place?! Aside from the very distasteful taint, there’s the very sloppy journalism. Has anyone been disciplined, or even sacked?

    Upon review, it is my considered opinion that not enough’s been done, so come the revolution, I’m putting all those at TCN who were involved in the very sordid report, up against the wall! They’ll have quite a wait before it’s their turn, after all, there’s the entire management at Channel 10 to process, not to mention EVERYONE at News Limited, some of whom may undergo extended assessments by the Revolutionary Water-Board Authority (that’s “Water-Board”, not “Water Board”), but they will be put through the system!

  4. Enquvist

    I wouldn’t call saying the title of the story and then putting the ACMA link at the bottom of the screen in case viewers wish to read what the findings were as an admission.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details