Facebook Google Menu Linkedin lock Pinterest Search Twitter



Jul 31, 2013

ICAC's 'disgusting' ruling against Labor: Obeids, Macdonald face charges

There's a stench around Labor -- in NSW at least -- as ICAC hands down its findings on the Obeid affair. Criminal charges have been recommended against the men who ran the state like a private club.


Eddie Obeid

Although widely anticipated, today is a very black day for the Australian Labor Party.

A report from the New South Wales corruption watchdog, the Independent Commission Against Corruption, handed down in Sydney this morning has recommended two senior ALP figures and a family member be charged with criminal conduct. It brings to a climax a seven-month investigation into the actions of Labor powerbroker Eddie Obeid, his son Moses, and former state mining minister Ian Macdonald.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd has already moved to distance himself from the findings, telling reporters before the report was handed down he was “disgusted” by the evidence that he had heard from the inquiry. He has made sweeping changes to party rules which he hopes will stamp out such conduct.

The ICAC report recommends action by the NSW Department of Public Prosecutions, the NSW Crime Commission, the Australian Taxation Office, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission and the Australian Stock Exchange. This is surely the greatest boost to the legal profession since the Wood Royal Commission, and will lead to much rejoicing on Philip Street, the heartland of Sydney’s legal fraternity.

Back in February, counsel assisting Geoffrey Watson SC said that ICAC was investigating “corruption on a scale probably unexceeded since the days of the Rum Corp”. Later, he told Eddie Obeid, the so-called “godfather” of the dominant Labor faction (i.e. the NSW Right) that “I’m going to submit that you engaged in a criminal conspiracy … with Ian Macdonald and with members of your family and the design was to effect a fraud on the people of NSW”.

It will now be up to NSW Director of Public Prosecutions to decide whether there is enough evidence to lay criminal charges against various witnesses to the three inquiries. Whatever happens, the release of the report so close to the federal election is bad news for Labor. Obeid and his henchmen — motto “whatever it takes” — ran the state like a private club, and may have poisoned the Labor brand so profoundly that the next NSW Labor premier would be in high school now.

In addition, the report says that it has furnished evidence of the “financial benefits accrued to the Obeid family as a result of the corrupt conduct” to the NSW Crime Commission, and also disseminated relevant information to the Tax Office. If the Obeids are the subject of a successful criminal prosecution, then the NSW Crime Commission can seize the proceeds of crime, with a Tax Office investigation as the coup de grace.

Today’s ICAC report is in three parts, relating to three separate inquiries. The fourth inquiry, covering the grant of a mining licence to former union official John Maitland, will be released later next month.

“Obeid and his henchmen … may have poisoned the Labor brand so profoundly that the next NSW Labor premier would be in high school now.”

The most important inquiry relates to the granting of coal exploration leases in the Hunter Valley in NSW which benefitted the Obeids to the tune of $30 million, with the possibility of earning at least another $70 million. Firstly, the Obeid family trust, set up for the benefit of Eddie and his nine children, bought rural land in the area before coal licences were put out to tender. Then, ICAC found, he organised for his friend and political buddy, Ian Macdonald, to issue coal exploration licences over much of the land, vastly increasing its value.

A company called Cascade Coal, owned by several of the country’s wealthiest businessmen, was awarded licences in the area. What was not publicly known was the fact that the Obeids owned a 25% stake in the company, disguised through a series of trusts.

The ICAC report finds that Macdonald’s conduct in entering into the agreement with Obeids senior and junior, and providing them with confidential information (when and where the licences would be granted), was acting contrary to his public duty as a Minister of the Crown. In return, the Obeids had also engaged in corrupt conduct by entering into these agreements.

The shareholders of Cascade Coal — Travers Duncan, John McGuigan, John Atkinson, John Kinghorn and Richard Poole — have also been the subject of adverse findings. The report finds that they engaged in corrupt conduct by taking steps to conceal the Obeid involvement in the Mt Penny coal tenement.

Today’s report also made a finding of corruption against Moses Obeid in relation to an $11,000 discount on a car provided to former NSW treasurer Eric Roozendaal. It found that Moses Obeid procured the car as an inducement for the politician “to show favour to Obeid family interests in the exercise of his public official functions”. However, it made no finding of corruption against Roozendaal.

The third inquiry, which was also the most colourful, involved Ian Macdonald spending the night in a five star hotel in Sydney with a s-x worker called Tiffanie. ICAC has found that Macdonald acted corruptly by exercising his ministerial influence to arrange a meeting between businessman and murder suspect Ron Medich and an executive of a state-owned energy company, and being rewarded with the provision of a hotel room and Tiffanie’s fragrant services, which Medich paid for.

In the witness box, Macdonald, who does have an extremely thick neck, said that he had merely booked Tiffanie for a neck massage.

As Crikey reached deadline today, no response had been received from Premier Barry O’Farrell, but this must be one of the best days of his life.


We recommend

From around the web

Powered by Taboola


Leave a comment

18 thoughts on “ICAC’s ‘disgusting’ ruling against Labor: Obeids, Macdonald face charges

  1. T S

    What ICAC ruling was there against Labor? Disgusting, sensationalist headline.

  2. mikehilliard

    NSW voters are bored to death with ICAC & the findings only confirm what everyone knew months ago, all that’s left is for the media to flog a dead horse.

  3. santa claus

    Let’s watch them wriggle for a little longer, but my feeling is the protagonists’ll be off the hook before long. Money talks.

  4. klewso

    O’Farrell was probably “Out to Lunch”?
    At last, someone to out-Askin Askin, and Bjelke-Petersen next door?

  5. Pedantic, Balwyn

    Most political parties have had members who’s main intention was to line their pockets or gain inappropriate power or both. This time it is the turn of several obnoxious members of NSW Labor.
    Will it affect the vote in the Federal election, most unlikely. The locals quite rightly vented their wrath at the State election and will now focus on more important issues like which party will put the biggest amount in their hip pockets.

  6. lucas paul

    What amount of corruption and mismanagment would it take to change the opioions of some of the rusted on crikey followers? Dead Girl, live boy? Bored with corruption that might have cost the NSW Government $50m, really? I guess it is small potatoes compared to vast amounts wasted our Labor’s time.

  7. Mark from Melbourne

    Yes, why is this an ALP “disaster”. It is 2 or 3 shonky dealers who have been caught out and should suffer the full consequences.

    And it certainly points towards a lack of vigilance and vigour on the part of their colleagues but there are plenty of rotten apples amongst all parties at all levels of government.

    Root them out, throw them in jail and make it clear that those who are involved in this sort of stuff will get their comeuppance. And make it clear so that everyone else is under no illusion that this stuff wont be tolerated. And then make sure we put the measures in place that remove the risk and the temptation and to monitor that its working.

    But that’s about it.

    A corollary would be smashing the police force because of some bent coppers.

  8. Miowarra Tomokatu

    So, five businessmen are named as having engaged in corrupt conduct and two Labor politicians, yet only the two Labor politicians are to be pursued by the DPP, the ATO and all the other punitive arms of the State.

    Do I notice a political bias in the decision and the reporting?
    I had expected better from Crikey.

  9. MJPC

    ALP disaster, I hardly think so as other comments have attested. The stench of corruption can affects all politicians at all levels of government, but it is individual opportunistic actions rather than a party policy (although the Nationals came close in Queensland under J B-Petersen and his minions.
    Remember, it will be only with a change of government in NSW that the full truth about casino deals, CSG deals and other sundry unsavory activities will be revealed regading the current government in NSW.

  10. Keith Thomas

    Considering the extent to which trusts are used to obscure and hide conspiracies against the public interest, isn’t it time for all trusts and their directors to be registered publicly with an obligation that the ultimate beneficiaries be made clear?

  11. Interrobanging On

    Smelly rotten apples, yes, but corruption is not the preserve of one side, of course.

    There is a question about how much guilt by association people will assign, although this story encourages it by failing to mention Richard Torbay, endorsed Coalition candidate, who will presumably answer his case at ICAC for his association with Obeid (they have the paperwork from the National Party).

    Why does Crikey file this as a ‘Federal’ story? State and Federal often don’t equate and Rudd has probably been as effective as he can be in negating the stench by already disowning the alleged culprits and waking up Western Sydney where the problem was greatest for him with the PNG Solution.

    And people have short memories and I wouldn’t bet it will be 20 years or more until the ALP are back as is speculated here. If nothing else, the Coalition will go rotten long before that – there are already plenty of signs.

  12. bjb

    If this is a ruling against Labor, what about those arrogant, rich, directors of Cascade Coal who’ve also had adverse rulings. Not a good look for the big end of town, the natural constituency of the LNP.

  13. tonyfunnywalker

    There is no ruling against the Labor Party- it is against individuals who happened to be a part of the Party and used its affiliations to gain benefit.
    This could have happened to any Party and this sort of political affiliation is not new even in Australia as the Currency Scandal involving the Reserve Bank and the Wheat Board that engulfed the Howard Government.
    Bob Askin was the most corrupt Liberal leader ever – is he too forgotten he was certainly not charged.
    So lets get this into prospective shall we its not the Labor Party — its crooks that associated with Labor for their own benefit- watch Broadwalk Empire sometime and the rise of Al Capone.
    I wonder if the Liberals – who were associated with Obeid will be prosecuted as well.
    Seems Crikey is following the Murdoch Press into anti Labor sensationalism. It seems that Liberals — namely Abbott who rorted his expenses on the ratio of a 9/1 to Slipper – Slipper is to face the courts – Abbott blamed an unnamed staffer and got away with it.
    The Toll sponsorship of policy in sending Boat people to Nauru– is another Obeid act as they stand to benefit by millions of dollars of and tax payer dollars should the Liberals win.
    Where is the Crikey investigative journalism on that issue I wonder.

  14. Jodi Matic

    Pfft, NSW was born and bred off the back of corruption.

  15. wbddrss

    Was there not once a song called “Breakfast at Tiffanies”
    Fragrant as an adjective. Well written. I enjoyed the narrative and agree this will not help Labor’s federal re-election.

    Why would you want to follow leadership who cannot govern their own party. For the record I am one of those rusted on types.

  16. AR

    Each of this loathsome cabal had a conga line of BigBi$ principals & enablers shovelling up the cash – is it too much to hope that will they feel Plod’s hand on their crisp collars?

  17. T S

    If I wanted to read, let alone pay for, obvious partisan crap I would read a tabloid like The Australian or any of the other Murdoch press.

    If Crikey expects people to pay for quality articles, I would suggest they give Margot a miss in the future.

    I know this article has made my decision easy on whether to continue on past the trial.

  18. Merve

    Taken too long to get rid of these vermin.


https://www.crikey.com.au/2013/07/31/icacs-disgusting-ruling-against-labor-obeids-macdonald-face-charges/ == https://www.crikey.com.au/free-trial/==https://www.crikey.com.au/subscribe/

Show popup

Telling you what the others don't. FREE for 21 days.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.