Feb 8, 2013

Not closing the gap: indigenous lifespans remain too short

Aborigines are living for about a decade less than non-Aboriginal people. Crikey intern Callum Denness asks the experts what should be done about it.

Raising Aboriginal life expectancy to that of the general population is a key part of the federal government's "closing the gap" crusade -- but a report out this week shows little if any progress is being made. Indigenous health experts are sceptical of the efforts being taken to close the gap in life expectancy between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal Australians -- currently 11.5 years for males and 9.7 for females -- and believe it could actually be widening. The ABS estimates that for indigenous males, life expectancy at birth is 67.2 years compared to 78.7 years for non-indigenous males. For indigenous females it's 72.9 years, compared to to 82.6 years. Indigenous mortality is falling at a slower rate than non-indigenous mortality. Released Wednesday, the Closing the Gap report says meeting the target remains "extremely challenging" and will not be closed by 2031 (which is the government's target) unless the indigenous mortality rate declines at a much faster pace. Indigenous health experts told Crikey that with chronic diseases on the rise, there are not enough preventative health initiatives in place. One researcher -- who didn’t want to be identified in case their comments jeopardised funding -- thinks progress is going backwards and the life expectancy gap could be increasing. Another researcher believes the public are unaware of how difficult the task is, and are "seduced" by the government's targets. The report shows two thirds of indigenous deaths are from chronic diseases that have lifestyle-related risk factors. Circulatory disease, diabetes, cancer, injury are the leading cause of death for indigenous people and experts say they are largely preventable by treating lifestyle factors. Dr Lesley Russell, senior research fellow at the ANU’s Australian Primary Health Care Research Institute, believes that with a focus on early intervention, mortality rates could be reduced. "We know for things like cancer the death rates are increasing. The risk factors are largely preventable and mortality and morbidity rates can be affected by good intervention and treatment," Russell said. While there are measures outlined in the report, researchers believe they don’t go far enough. "One of the big problems is existing diseases," said Dr Kerin O’Dea, professor of population health and nutrition at the University of South Australia. "Once you’ve got diabetes at an early age you’re not going to reverse it." According to data published by HealthinfoNet, indigenous people are seven times more likely to die of diabetes than non-indigenous Australians. Indigenous people die of cancer at a rate higher than non-indigenous people and are "significantly more likely to have cancers that have a poor prognosis; usually diagnosed with cancer at a later stage; less likely to receive optimal treatment; and are more likely to die from cancers than other Australians". Dr Neil Thomson, professor of indigenous health at Edith Cowan University, agrees addressing upstream factors that contribute to chronic disease  is critical. He's encouraged by the latest data but wants to see more anti-smoking measures -- smoking rates in some indigenous communities are as high as 60% and indigenous people smoke at a rate three times higher than non-indigenous people. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice Commissioner Mick Gooda believes efforts to reduce smoking have failed due to a lack of proper engagement with and involvement of indigenous people. "[Anti-smoking measures] won’t work unless Aboriginal people are there delivering the programs. I’m forever having a go at the government for lack of proper engagement with the Aboriginal community," he said. Russell agreed: "We can’t do these things to Aborigines, we need to do it with them." The idea that programs can only be effective if indigenous people can lead them is not new; it has been championed for decades by Aboriginal leaders. Another issue is the need for a wider concept of indigenous health. For Gooda, any measure of health and wellbeing must address the high indigenous incarceration rate. "It's the biggest gap we’ve got, and it's growing. An important part of our health is social and emotional wellbeing. It [indigenous incarceration] contributes to our ill health," he said. A recent report  found 26% of Australia’s adult prison population is indigenous, despite making up 2.5% of the population. And the problem is getting worse: Aboriginal imprisonment rates increased by 31.9% between 20o0 and 2006. Half of all juveniles in detention are indigenous. With indigenous people dying from intentional self harm at twice the rate of non-indigenous people, Aboriginal leaders believe addressing the incarceration is critical. "We’re lobbying very hard for incarceration rates to be included as a [CTG] target. I think they are receptive," Gooda said. While indigenous health experts are critical of aspects of the CTG report, they recognise the significance of the document, the political capital invested in it, and its bipartisan support. "I think it’s very important we document progress or lack of it. It’s very good the government is confronting the data," O’Dea said. Gooda believes a hallmark of indigenous policy has been a lack of continuity. "The real fault in Aboriginal affairs is we always start something new," he said. Not this time. This is the fifth CTG report and Gooda is "very confident" the initiative will continue, and new national partnership agreements will be signed. The release of the report produced a rare moment of bipartisanship in the Parliament. That at least, is cause for hope.

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

5 thoughts on “Not closing the gap: indigenous lifespans remain too short

  1. Jon Hunt

    Having worked in the field of Aboriginal health I’m probably as cynical as anyone. One of the key issues to be is that western medicine does not suit people who are, for want of a better work, migratory and not compliant (I do not mean this to be a criticism). Once they get sick you have already missed the boat. The only solution I can see is to change their lives, the environment, and provide services which they understand and will engage with. Not to mention do something about alcohol..!

  2. Jon Hunt

    I apologise for my typing errors.

  3. Sharilynn Gerchow

    Dont expect indigenous health to improve in Qld any time soon. The LNP have cut many, many preventative health programs and the TB clinic ini the Torres Strait has had its funding cut. Now sexual health programs are in trouble, with the Govt planning to cut funding to the succesful 2 Spirits program solely because they are associated with those “queer pariahs”, QAHC.

  4. David Coles

    Making progress in this area has defeated governments and organisations for at least 100 years. The current strategy tries to bring all governments together to focus on the issues and has a chance but it wont deliver quickly enough for many.

    The trick is to keep Aboriginal organisations and people at the centre of the strategy, keep counting the progress or lack thereof and, above all, don’t give up when it all gets too hard or someone has a bright idea.

  5. GF50

    Strange times. I worked at the Thursday Island Hospital in the 70’s. I have followed the news of the area since. There was a Tuberculosis hospital on the northern side of this tiny island, Nightingale style wards I believe accomodation 150+? Matron “struggled” to have at least at least one active case (to maintain TB Hospital Isolation Status and funding) she also happened to be the most accurate clinical diagnostician I have ever encountered. The treatment of TB in these times does not appear to follow the regime of the past when committment to treatment was mandatory isolation hospitalisation for the duration of long term treatment and cure. I have no idea what happened to this facility? ? General hospital relocated??
    Antibiotic resistance caused by incomplete non compliance with treatment due to lack of funding for mandatory isolation, patient compliance. From what I have read the majority of TB suffers/carriers are PNG nationals. Very difficult re borders and close ties. TI expession “a walk across the mud flats at low tide”.
    Isolation was not desolation many social and wellfare programs run to aleviate boredom etc visitors allowed but close/frequent/share food/utensile etc verboten!
    Effective outpatient treatment impossible given these circumstances.

    Our Aboriginal communities must be the solution for advising, designing and implementing effective cordinationed, fully funded, education, preventative and treatment programs for our first Australians. Difficult but not impossible!

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details