Federal

Jan 30, 2013

Farewell to McClelland, a ministerial cipher for the security state

Robert McClelland's time as attorney-general were lost years representing how Labor has been co-opted by the security establishment. Farewell.

Bernard Keane — Politics editor

Bernard Keane

Politics editor

Robert McClelland

So, farewell Robert McClelland, former attorney-general, son of Whitlam government minister Doug McClelland.

10 comments

Leave a comment

10 thoughts on “Farewell to McClelland, a ministerial cipher for the security state

  1. klewso

    “Gumby” in a suit?

  2. SusieQ

    Agree with this article. A massive underperformer who perhaps, dare I say, would have been better off in the Liberal party. Difficult not to see him as a classic case of nepotism gone wrong. No great loss at all.

  3. Dogs breakfast

    It is galling to watch the security services get ever increasing resources and legislative backing with such little oversight. As with all bureaucracies, accountability tends to be lost as the budget is increased and the powers extended.

    More galling that a Labor govt hasn’t seen fit to scrutinise them more closely. I for one would be happy to see budget savings directed to the overall security overlords.

  4. paddy

    Spot on Bernard. He will not be missed.

  5. AR

    aka (by his colleagues!) Mr Potatohead. Good riddance.

  6. Suzanne Blake

    Gillard fingered McLelland as the serial leaker from Cabinet, wonder if he will white ant her over the next 7 – 8 months

  7. Harry Rogers

    Bernard,
    There is a bit of history there as ASIO was formed in 1949 by the Labor Chifley government with Spry as the founding director.

    Spry could only get ASIO going with the support of the State’s police forces, notably one of them was the Queensland Special Branch which was also formed by a Labor government under Hanlon.

    Labor has a long history of “spooks’. The worst part is no matter which government gets elected they all re-inforce the politics of fear. It’s a cowards policy however Hloward was expert at it and now Gillard.

  8. bluepoppy

    This article is mostly on target however Howard did let AGD get away with just as much if not more, certainly in terms of oversighting his own ‘rulings’. Howard and Ruddock may have mapped out a plan for national security but did little to ensure the department adhered to the desired outcomes.

    Certainly both LNP and ALP have poor records on surveillance, whistleblowers and increasing intrusions into the privacy we all took for granted

  9. Stephen

    Farewell also to Roxon, a better class of ministerial cipher for the security state.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details

Sending...