SPORT

Jan 25, 2013

Quiet, please! Grunting tennis players are simply cheating

There's a very clear rule in the International Tennis Federation that says if a player is hindering the play -- even unintentionally -- the point should be replayed. So why aren't the female players who grunt getting in trouble?

David Salter

Journalist and former Media Watch executive producer.

Hooray for Li Na, whose defeat of Maria Sharapova yesterday guarantees that there will be relative quiet from at least one end of the court in the Australian Open women’s final tomorrow night.

26 comments

Leave a comment

26 thoughts on “Quiet, please! Grunting tennis players are simply cheating

  1. frey

    If you want to use a Cricket analogy you should at least understand some history.

    The great Spinner Clarrie Grimmett would use a tactic of similar distraction (coy courtesy of CricInfo):

    “After the standard legbreak, topspinner and googly there came the flipper – which took several years to perfect, and which, when batsmen tried to discern by the snap of his fingers, he smokescreened by snapping the fingers of his left hand as he released a legbreak”

    Of which there was no great reaction that the writer imagnies.

    Additionally, if you rely on sound (rather than sight) to gauge the flight of the ball then a grunting bowler is the least of your worries.

  2. Steve777

    I couldn’t agree more. Tennis authorities really should crack down of the grunt. It’s purpose is either to disguise the sound of the ball on the racquet or to put off the opponent. In either case it is cheating. Nothing like that would be tolerated in cricket, for example (bowler ‘ahhhhhhh!!!!!’ and batsman ‘weeeeeeeee!!!!’). And it’s so inelegant, as if the players belched or farted loudly or imitated a barnyard animal when they served or returned. It is not a natural consequence of exertion. It has only been the practice for the past 20 years or so. Greats of the past – Newcombe, Goolagong et al didn’t do it. It should be stopped.

  3. robinw

    Here, here! I’ve long stopped watching women’s tennis because of the grunts and screams of the GruntALotOva’s and her compatriots. As far as I’m concerned a pox on the game and I will never watch it again while the screamers are allowed to continue with their unfair behaviour.

  4. Spike

    Here’s an idea! Tennis Australia/world /universe makes an ironclad rule: ANY noise,from a player loses that player one point. Agreed Steve777.

  5. klewso

    From media treatment, when Armstrong cheats and it’s “all hands on neck”?
    When these women trying for an unfair advantage over their opponents (to distract them) it’s “eveyone line up for a photo op”?

  6. Venise Alstergren

    DAVID SALTER: Could not agree with you more. Not only is the noise unbearable-I now refuse to go to, or switch onto the women’s tennis-but don’t players need to hear the sound of the opponent’s racquet, as the ball comes off it, to help them decide which shot to play?

    Maria Sharapova’s vocal chords should be cut, and Victoria Azarenka sounds as if she is having a mini-orgasm every time she strikes the ball. It would be a great comedy skit, but, that’s not what she’s paid for.

    Non withstanding the fact that a few of the men have started to grunt-the Spanish guy who played Federer in the quarter finals, being a case in point-it is almost revolting to watch as no one at the tennis seems at worried by this flagrant cheating. Three years ago there was a lot of spectator unrest. Today anything goes!

  7. Venise Alstergren

    PS: At one stage it looked as if the women’s finals would come down to Venus Williams versus Victoria Azarenka. The spectators would have needed to wear those orange noise mufflers.

  8. Arty

    and let us not forget the deliberate time wasting. If the 20 second rule was treated as a rule, there would be less need for matches to go beyond midnight.

  9. Pierre de Chazal

    I totally agree with David Salter’s article on the loathsome practice of shrieking when hitting the tennis ball. It is clearly intended to distract the opponent and I am constantly amazed that umpires do nothing about it.

    As I have no other control over it, my reaction is to cease watching a match in which systematic shrieking occurs – advertisers might take note and decline to advertise when players such as Azarenka are on court.

  10. mikeb

    No matter how annoying it is I doubt that the grunting/wailing etc does distract an opponent. If it did they would be complaining about it. As I understand it the sound is used to psychologically help with timing of the hit – although oddly enough you rarely hear it on the practice court. A few of the men also grunt a lot but it is less annoying because of the lower pitch. As an aside – “injury” timeouts, esp prevalent amongst the women, should be looked at. That episode by Azarenka was a disgrace.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details

Sending...