Oct 19, 2012

Walkley nominations: trumpets out to herald their/our own

The Walkley Award nominations for journalistic excellence were announced last night. So which media outlets shone (well, us) and which fell flat?

Matthew Knott

Former Crikey media reporter

Crikey journalists have dominated the nominations for this year's Walkley Awards ... Well, no, we haven't actually. But we were mightily chuffed last night to learn our cartoonist-at-large and self-proclaimed national treasure First Dog on the Moon is up for a gong. Dog -- in the running for this August effort -- will duke it out for the best cartoon award with The Age's Judy Horacek and the Herald Sun's Mark Knight. Sydney-based sketchers, we're unreliably informed, are spewing about the fact they've been upstaged by their comrades south of the border. The consensus among those who gathered in Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane to hear the nominees announced last night was that the events were a vast improvement on last year's poorly-attended soirees. A koala stamp to whoever decided to shift the event from a Monday to a Thursday. The Age's new editor-in-chief Andrew Holden was a notable guest at the Melbourne gathering, with several staffers taking the opportunity to meet him for the first time. Among the 150-odd attendees in Sydney were a bevy of Global Mail scribes and Greg Sheridan's bete noir Eric Campbell. Watching how media outlets cover their own Walkley performance -- while downplaying or ignoring that of their rivals -- is a long-time guilty pleasure here at Crikey HQ. Michael Stutchbury's Australian Financial Review -- not content with a page-two piece on its online renaissance -- blew its trumpet on page four. The Australian raised a toast to itself with "Thomas leads The Oz's Walkley charge", focusing on the two nominations for Hedley Thomas. Fairfax flips the bird to News by noting its reporters have "dominated nominations in print and online categories". The ABC notes it has "dominated several categories". They're both telling the truth. MEAA stronghold Fairfax leads the field with 28 nominations -- including four for The Age's Nick McKenzie and three for SMH veteran (and former busker) Kate McClymont. Aunty -- helped, we hope it's not too churlish to note, by a dearth of competition in the TV and radio doco categories -- was close behind with 24. News Limited, which staged its own rebel News Awards last month, scored 19 noms. Wotif founder Graeme Wood will be pleased to know his now-vertical online venture The Global Mail stood tall with two nominations and a pair of commendations.
Organisation Nominations
Fairfax 28
ABC 24
News Limited 19
Seven Network 3
The West Australian 3
Ten Network 2
The Global Mail 2
Getty Images 2
Crikey 1
Nine Network 1
Quarterly Essay 1
Sky News 1
In a sign the times are most definitely a'changing, Ellen Fanning is in the running for best "newspaper feature writing" for Global Mail piece on the Queensland floods. 7.30 host Leigh Sales looks a good bet in the broadcast interview category for her widely-viewed powwow with Tony Abbott. The big question, of course, is: who will take out the Gold Walkley? To Crikey's eye, it's an even field compared to recent years. Former Gold Walkley winners Thomas and McClymont are strong contenders, given the political ructions caused by their reporting on Julia Gillard's past and the Health Services Union. Judges may also reward The Age for its sustained coverage of the Securency scandal. Or could Sarah Ferguson -- who took out Gold last year for her Four Corners live cattle exposé -- score an unlikely back-to-back win for her Captain Emad scoop? We'll find out on November 30, when the awards are handed out at Parliament House in Canberra.

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

12 thoughts on “Walkley nominations: trumpets out to herald their/our own

  1. paddy

    Congrats to all the nominees. Plus, in the interests of a cracking good show, we can only hope that Glen Milne is invited to the grand final, and has a well stocked table close to the stage.

  2. shepherdmarilyn

    Almost all of McClymont’s stories on Thomson were utter bullshit though.

    Jesus wept, you are a gullible lot aren’t you.

  3. CML

    Doesn’t happen very often, but I agree with Shepherd Marilyn!
    Of course, we could all start a campaign for First Dog on the Moon to win the Gold Walkley? After all, he makes more sense than most of the journos!!

  4. tripper

    I didn’t realise walkleys were awards for witch-hunts – which is surely what the Thomas and McLiemont awards are for.

  5. fredex

    ” ….journalistic excellence ….. ‘


  6. Mel Campbell

    Nice to hear there was “a bevvy of Global Mail scribes” in Sydney – an appropriately boozy collective noun indeed for a group of journos!

    Or perhaps you meant a ‘bevy’?

  7. shepherdmarilyn

    McClymont launched a witch hunt lasting years based on a rejected credit card in the name of someone called ThomPson and none of the MSM noticed.

  8. Mick Buckley

    Great to see the Cartoonist being acknowledged for his efforts.

    In Australian journalism no one has come anywhere near Keane on his coverage of the data retention and security law proposals. End of story!

    The shadows move amid twisted and contorted light
    whatever is written and the facts alone are his might
    he knows the reader can hardly take it this way down
    and torn insideout with nothing but a tawny frown
    who is it? who is he? who cares enough to risk the scorn
    there he is!.. it’s Keane! to the manor was he never born
    it’s mammon that bays and nays to give us the untrue story
    but it’s Keane who breaches the gap and lives another glory

  9. fractious

    @ Mick Buckley, I agree, BK’s reporting on the AGD’s data retention laws should have been a shoo-in for an award, instead of all the fluff and puff pieces the rest of them indulged in (Thomson, self-interested hand-wringing about Finkelstein and Gillard’s arse). But of course very few others have the balls to even mention the subject and I’m sure Roxon & co would rather everyone stfu about it.

  10. shepherdmarilyn

    And Fergusons story about Emad was a sick joke with a nasty war criminal spiv as the source.

    Her first story led to the cancellation of a protection visa of a young man and an extra 10 months in prison because his father was featured.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details