Sep 13, 2012

Cognitive dissonance as Newman flails the coal industry

Concerns about the quality of Australian management, once claimed to be partisan sniping, are now shared by a conservative premier. That didn't fit the narrative at all.

Well, ouch. That didn’t fit the narrative at all.

Campbell Newman not merely raised coal royalties in Queensland on Tuesday, but went on to attack coal mining companies yesterday, blaming poor management for their high cost:

Free Trial

Proudly annoying those in power since 2000.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

162 thoughts on “Cognitive dissonance as Newman flails the coal industry

  1. Jimmy

    More evidence Campbell Newman is the best thing to happen to the ALP in years.

  2. Bob the builder

    If only Labor had Newman’s backbone, they would have vigorously defended their modest mining taxes in the face of outrageous rent-seeking, rather than timorously put their views in a debate framed by the mining companies.

  3. Jimmy

    Bob – It’s pretty easy to have backbone when you have the media on your side and you know that the miners will get the increased royalties compensated under the MRRT so all he is doing is effectively charging the Fed’s more.

  4. izatso?

    Odd ….. Cognitive Dissonance/Media Bias/Management Fudgeing/Incompetence/Inaptitude …… Business As Usual, CYA/Best Practice etc, etc, ad inf….. Not So Odd then ……………

  5. MJPC

    Well said Jimmy;
    ALP had Mark Latham and now the LNP has Campbell Newman (as well as Tony Abbott).

    As for Newman’s backbone…it’s easy to slash and burn when you have no opposition and only one house of parliament which allows you to do as you wish. In another country this would be called a dictatorship.

    Let’s see what happens Queenaland as the mining lobby starts to contract with the mining slowdown and rational voters start to regret what they did to allow a loose canon unfettered power.

  6. Jimmy

    MJPC – I surprisingly found myself agreeing with Clive Palmer last night, he was actually bagging Newman’s austerity measures as counter productive, slashing jobs will lead to lower payroll tax, lower GST take because of lower spending etc.

  7. geomac62

    Bob the builder
    I agree with you but not entirely as The Rudd mining tax came out of the blue . I guess you could say the same about QLD but everyone knew their budget would be a shocker , just didn,t realise it would so bad .
    I had never heard any discussion from Rudd or ministers informing the public prior to the announcement of the mining tax . Industry might have been aware but the public had nothing and thats the first thing a government should do , inform the public to get them onside .
    Trouble with Clive is that he comes across as part parody and part businessman . How many take him seriously or actually separate which hat he is wearing when he speaks is the concern . Imagine QLD slashing health of all things ? One thing Clive did nail was regarding Costello and the vast difference between a large state like QLD and a smaller state like Victoria and the people required to provide public service .

  8. Jimmy

    Geomac – I didn’t see all the interview, I am one of those who don’t take him seriously so I went to bed, but from what I have seen it wouldn’t be hard to point to errors in Costello’s report, it appears to be a very shoddy piece of work that decided what the answer was then set out to prove it anyway it can.

    All three eastern state conservative govt’s have made some stupid decisions re budget cuts, Newman targeting Health, O’farrell slashing education (despite supporting GOnski) and O’Farrell & Baillieu whacking TAFE when everyone is crying out “skills shortage”. If this is a precursor to Abbott (which it almost certainly is) we should be very worried.

  9. CML

    @ JIMMY – I also found myself agreeing with Clive Palmer, to my great surprise! He had many interesting things to say, not the least of which is that Newman will be gone before Christmas. Since Clive is supposed to be the biggest bankroller of the LNP in Qld, and that presumably gives him some clout, there could be interesting times ahead to our north?

    Funny that the Crikey editorial today was used to tip a bucket on Kevin Rudd (as usual), when Clive’s interview was much more pertinent to both the national and state scenes. Go figure!

  10. SBH

    Did I hear someone say ‘Orwell’? No – oh well any way, Bernard Keane seeing as it’s apparently beyond the Ken of a whole raft of people including Alan Kohler and Mitch Hook, Can you please tell us all, wtf ‘sovereign risk’ means or like ‘social capital’ it now just means precisely what I want it to mean (apols Lewis Carroll)

Leave a comment

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details