Crikey Says

Aug 23, 2012

Crikey says: Abbott looks weak when challenged

Abbott is seen within the party as being effective on his pet issues -- boat people and the carbon tax -- but often on shaky ground when forced to venture onto other topics.

"The Opposition Leader, no less than the prime minister, has an obligation to educate and inform the public and not mislead," veteran ABC journalist Barrie Cassidy wrote on The Drum late last week, calling on journalists to challenge Tony Abbott's regular rhetorical furphies. His colleague heard the call. Last night on 7.30, Leigh Sales wasn't taking "the carbon tax is to blame" as the answer ...

Abbott tried to say Labor's tax environment had contributed to BHP abandoning the expansion of Olympic Dam mine yesterday, despite the company carefully blaming everything else but in a statement (which Abbott admitted he hadn't read). He continued the line about the carbon tax starting to hurt "from day one" but in the face of positive economic news couldn't point to any examples. He refused to back down from his description of asylum seekers as "illegals", which every legal mind in the country disputes. He blamed Labor for uncertainty in the business environment while admitting the Coalition had no alternative industrial relations policy. He said the "circumstances of her [Julia Gillard] departure from a previous employer are of public interest", but couldn't nail down a single question or allegation against the Prime Minister over her Slater & Gordon past. Sales posed it as a question: "You were pretty loose with the truth today, weren't you?" He was. He regularly is. All this makes Coalition operatives nervous. Abbott is seen within the party as being effective on his pet issues -- boat people and the carbon tax -- but often on shaky ground when forced to venture onto other topics, particularly economic and financial matters. Some party insiders reckon he lacks substance, lacks depth, lacks vision; a performing parrot only good at reeling out rehearsed lines. The memory remains fresh in some Coalition MPs' minds of Abbott's unfortunate and strange silence when confronted by stupid claims from a reporter over his "shit happens" comment while in Afghanistan. They think he is only a few similar stuff-ups away from serious questions over his leadership. His stuff-ups are rare, party polling is strong, and there's little talk about a replacement. But many in the party are acutely aware of his vulnerabilities. Labor people whine insistently that the media isn't tough enough on Abbott. The interview last night demonstrates why they want him called out.

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

31 thoughts on “Crikey says: Abbott looks weak when challenged

  1. klewso

    So when one of their own (Cassidy) points out “that elephant” in their media room, and what needs doing, that’s all right – but when the rubes do it (as some have, for so long), that’s to be ignored?
    Club Rule #1?

  2. cairns50

    finally last nite on the 7.30 report someone from the main stream press put abbott under the microscope and he scrimed and prevaricated like the serial liar that he is

    congratulations go to leigh sales for not letting him get away with his usual side stepping performance when questioned about serious issues

    people who watched that interview last nite finally saw abbott in the raw and it was not a pretty site

    im betting he wont be going back to have a chat with leigh sales for a long long time

  3. sherman herman

    the guy’s a complete moron. and if the old adage “people get the government they deserve” is true, well i can only conclude that the majority of australians too, are complete morons, if they vote this guy into high office. for all her faults, at least gillard show some modicum of intelligence. this guy has none.

  4. The Pav

    AS we get closer & closer to the election the spot light
    will be turned on Abbott.

    His failure under pressure will be highlighted and I believe
    uder the continued pressure of a campaign he will
    suffer a severe meldt down.

    Remember that he has the slenderst of majorities as leader
    of his own party.

    When Liberal party members realise that Abbot is all that
    lies between them and certain victory he will be dumped.

    The urbane, personable and presentable Turmbull will return
    to the job

  5. klewso

    “Bubbles Abbott” – good with dogs (it’s the whistle) – but “does not play well, with others”?
    And this “Leigh Sales” that ambushed him – he was probably expecting her usual “lean the Right way” starboard-list questions?
    He won’t be going “back there” again for a while either (remember Father O’Brien and what he got out of him at another confession) – better stick to the domesticated Limited News stable of hacks and ponies – at least they won’t buck (him or “The System”).
    And it’s not the first time he’s admitted not “reading (the detail)” – relying on the reading and interpretations of others (he trusts) to have him up to speed is it?

  6. Salamander

    Abbott repeatedly calls the PM a liar over one issue. The media keeps parroting his allegation. Abbott’s claim is a ludicrous distortion. But nobody will call Abbott for what he is – an inveterate liar. The situation is unbelievable.

  7. klewso

    It’s his “glass jaw”.

  8. drmick

    I resent the whining tag.
    You misogynistic churnalists have had a free run with rats in the ranks drip feeding trash to the murdochracy, & wing nut bag and friends reading the script, and all the media running with it.
    Interesting when one out of 99 questions is pointed towards the vacuum painted as the brilliant tactician aka leader of the opposition isn’t it?
    All we ask for is 50-50.

  9. michael r james

    The 7.30 interview was fair enough, though I personally did not find Sales that compelling. It just shows how truly weak Abbott is when anything but the softest of soft interview or media interactions is pointed his way. (And it is the reason he totally avoids a serious interviewer like Tony Jones on Lateline. But I suspect it will be a long wait until his next appearance on 7.30.)

    Because it is so rare, I bring to Crikey’s readers notice a piece in today’s AFR. Alas behind an impenetrable paywall so here is a taster:

    It’s time for Abbott to stump up
    DAVID BASSANESE 23 August 2012
    Although she’s faced enormous criticism and low poll ratings, there’s something to be said for Prime Minister Julia Gillard and the federal Labor government: they are slowing getting the policy runs on the board.
    Since it was first elected to power in 2007, the Labor government has unarguably saved the country from recession. It has since increased spending on health and education, mean-tested the health insurance rebate, pushed through the mining tax and carbon tax, implemented a paid maternity leave scheme, launched trials for a national disability scheme and begun the national broadband rollout.]

    The rest of the article went on to dissect and pinpoint the extreme weakness and hole-filled Lib-Nat budgetary ambitions.

  10. zut alors

    Perhaps the hacks will realise it’s far more productive exposing this loon than constantly slicing away at the PM. This bloke is a walking headline when pertinent questions are posed and he scrambles to respond. He even has trouble when making it up.

Leave a comment

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details