Quitting the exporting and just focusing on the importing

Crikey readers have their say.

Aluminium: Niall Clugston writes: Re. "Aluminium, industry policy and losing our way on reform" (yesterday, item 1). If Bernard Keane really wants to "explain to people in the front line of economic change ... exactly what is going on", he could avoid nonsense such as his reference to the "aluminium smelting industry, which only employs about 5000 people but generates -- at least in normal years -- $5 billion in exports". To put it crudely, a $5 billion industry is going to have costs of up to $5 billion (or more if it's loss-making), those costs will relate to inputs, and those inputs will be provided by people.  And that will be a lot more people than 5000. Of course, some of these related industries, such as bauxite mining, can be redirected to overseas markets, but this knock-on effect has to be considered. He would do a better sales job if he talked about the industries being created -- but they don't seem to exist. Manufacturing and primary industry are out. So we will have an economy that imports manufactured goods, but exports nothing. Alexander Downer: Hugh McCaig writes: Re. "Richard Farmer's chunky bits" (yesterday, item 11). I found Richard Farmer's using Alexander Downer as an intro to another denigration of PM Julia Gillard a shallow analysis of the real situation in our present political scene. Poor Alexander was the leader of the opposition and yet failed to win an election. Gillard is leading an effective government, has negotiated several important pieces of legislation through a difficult parliamentary period, and Australia, our country, is regarded as having coped well with the prevailing difficult worldwide economics. Richard seems all too willing to join the general media bias, aggressively led by News Ltd, against the government and Gillard. I find it a shame that an experienced commentator should show a lack of independent and balanced analysis so regularly in his comments. How about considering balance and objectivity for once, Richard. Churnalism: Debra Hood writes: Re. "'Churnalism sweatshop': ABC News journos fear review outcomes" (Wednesday, item 1). Much to my chagrin, the ABC is already engaged in "churnalism". One only has to watch ABC News 24 to see the results of "stuff" fed to the "chooks" as Joh Bjelke-Petersen referred to the media. I watched ABC News 24 scurry around the voting associated with the caucus vote reaffirming our Prime Minister, where numbers were released that were just wrong. That is not journalism. That is behaving as paparazzi. That is not the level of journalism Australian taxpayers should be funding. As a taxpayer I want an analysis of the facts with the bias of the journalist exposed so that I can make may own decision. Really, it is not that hard!

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

4 thoughts on “Quitting the exporting and just focusing on the importing

  1. Gavin Moodie

    How can anyone claim that Australia will ‘exports nothing’ when its balance of payments is either surplus or near surplus? It is precisely because Australia’s mineral exports are earning so much that aluminium smelting is under pressure. In addition, Australia still has strong exports in education, the third biggest export earner after coal and iron ore.

  2. Simon Mansfield

    Leave Richard alone. He’s just giving a comment. One that Labor supporters should take note of.

    Anyway – Lady Jane Grey will most likely be history before the winter solstice.

  3. Niall Clugston

    If you eliminate primary industry Australia will export very little.

    Both coal and iron ore are in the firing line in the “carbon-free” utopia.

    (Steel production uses coal.)

  4. [email protected]

    Just as the Barlow Health Department scandal in Queensland was the final blow to the Bligh Government, the astonishing decision announced today allowing sections of the mining industry to regularly fly in thousands of foreign workers on temporary work permits, will be the final kiss of death to the beleaguered Gillard Government regardless of how effective a negotiator or legislator the Prime Minister may be.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details