May 16, 2012

War on privacy: committee sends Roxon back to drawing board

Nicola Roxon's efforts to establish a process for expanding national security powers has suffered a hiccup, with the powerful Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security asking her to redraft it.

Bernard Keane — Politics editor

Bernard Keane

Politics editor

As Attorney-General Nicola Roxon prepares to head to the United States to further integrate Australia’s role in the War on Terror into the American security apparatus, the powerful Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security has knocked back her terms of reference for an inquiry into the further widening of intelligence-gathering laws, including the controversial data retention proposal.

The rejection is bad timing for Roxon, who wrote today in The Australian about her pending trip to the US for further meetings with US Department of Homeland Security head Janet “you cannot live free if you live in fear” Napolitano, who was recently in Australia.

Free Trial

Proudly annoying those in power since 2000.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

20 thoughts on “War on privacy: committee sends Roxon back to drawing board

  1. Suzanne Blake

    Bernard, is this to do with internet censorship as well.

    PS what did you think of Stephen Mayne’s performace on Q&A on Monday

  2. botswana bob

    Bureaucrats are born snoopocrats. And then there is Roxon: totally manipulated by Canberra’s Sir Humphrey Applebys.

  3. shepherdmarilyn

    More powers for ASIO who already have no accountability to anyone and can drag kids off the streets and jail them for life without evidence or reason.

  4. Gary Johnson

    ((Roxon’s commitment to holding a transparent and public inquiry into possible expansions of surveillance and law enforcement powers is to be commended)))

    Ceratinly, but Roxon’s pretext of the Undies Bomber mark 2 as serious further justification is very unserious. That happless Western intelligence dupe and the escapade has been exposed all across Europe and the US for the false flag that it was…sigh!

    Australia is looking to Rudd,Faulkner, Wilkie and Brandis to show some honest form. Come on boys!!! show the world we won’t be fooled or absorbed into the US’s terrorism Fasle Flag security apparatus.

    As usual, BK is relentless in his pursuit of the Truth.

  5. Michael de Angelos

    One World Conspiracists are being handed these things on a plate: the USA is demanding sovereign countries everywhere surrender citizen’s rights to comply with USA’s new dodgy laws.
    They are doing it in cyberspace and sadly, tech writers are lining up to support them.

    Watch the howls of anguish on crikey and elsewhere when a court victory is scored against the new Fasle Gods-Twitter, Yahoo, Facebook and Google by ordinary citizens or an Archbishop wishing to negate lies published about them.
    Crikey is also guilty of promoting a view that those who are a gateway to publishing (Google etc) should remain in a sort of untouchable cyberspace free of ordinary laws (at the same time they base themselves in tax havens ) or that laws that have served us well for centuries must change and defer to private companies (fascism?).

    Kiddie Porn, terrorists bomb recipes-supposedly there are “a billion” such websites according to the US government (read it in a Fairfax newspaper so must be true) and so on, threats everywere so our freedoms must be curtailed and we must be watched permanently even in our homes and as shown by a NSW Labor government-police can now secertly enter your premises without a warrant. Expect no joy from Roxon.

  6. Michael de Angelos

    Suzanne Blake- Mayne’s performance was disappointing especially when he claimed an MP should comply and be hounded out of Parliamnet because of accusations.

    I think there is a Young Liberal still struggling to get out.

  7. shepherdmarilyn


    Yes and the major claim of electoral fraud and theft of funds and funds not diclosed and declared was simply not true.

    FWA seem to have been the ones misleading the public and someone should be fired for it.

    Of course Kathy Jackson fed the same lies about others to various investigations going back many years while raking in the dough herself.

    I suspect this poor widdle so-called whistleblower will find her legal bills will rise.

    Because this claim came only from her and FWA swallowed it whole.

  8. GocomSys

    No longer watch shows like Q&A. Also, if someone like doozie Suzie chimes in, its time to move on!

  9. Suzanne Blake

    @ GocomSys

    I am shocked, Q&A is very left wing biased, even down to the tweets selected.

    What is more left wing for you? Green – Left weekly newsletter?

  10. Jimmy

    Not meaning to get off topic but I was wondering if SB could explain this to me

    Joe H.oc key today first refused to commit the Coal ition to the NDIS as he “isn’t going to promise what he can’t del iver” and then;

    “Mr Hockey was tackled on the Coal ition’s commitment to provide tax cuts without a carbon tax, saying the cuts would be made to the tax tables as they stood today, not to the new rates that come into force when the carbon tax is introduced.” So will they del iver tax cuts that actuall y increase the tax rates?
    “In a wide-ranging speech that ana l ysed last week’s federal budget, Mr Hockey flagged a hardl ine fiscal strategy from the Coal ition if it was to win the next election.” SO we are going to wind back means testing of the private health rebate, subsidise Nannies, make the paid parental leave scheme ridiculousl y generous, pay big business to stop polluting, del iver tax cuts and increased welfare and still have a “hardl ine fiscal strategy” – sounds like Greece is looking pretty good if Abb ott becomes PM.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details