Apr 16, 2012

Parliamentary inquiry to take on big IT companies over pricing

One of the greatest frustrations of Australian consumers -- the extraordinary differences in IT prices between Australia and elsewhere, and the cavalier refusal of major IT companies to

Bernard Keane — Politics editor

Bernard Keane

Politics editor

One of the greatest frustrations of Australian consumers -- the extraordinary differences in IT prices between Australia and elsewhere, and the cavalier refusal of major IT companies to explain them -- is set to be examined at a parliamentary inquiry. Crikey understands that as a result of a campaign by Labor MP Ed Husic, the government is considering undertaking a parliamentary inquiry into IT price differentials and legal options for preventing them. Husic flagged his interest in establishing the inquiry in a speech to parliament in March. Among the biggest offenders is Apple. Apple prices its own products differentially in Australia -- a 17-inch MacBook Pro costs $2899 here compared to US$2499 (currently $2408) from Apple in the US, $250 more than the US product with 10% GST. But its iTunes services also features a remarkable array of outrageous pricing differentials. The album Up All Night by British zygote band One Direction is $14.99 for Australians but US$9.99 ($9.63) for Americans, a difference of 55%. Adele’s 21 is US$10.99 ($10.59) for Americans but $16.99 here, a difference of 60%. Apple has persistently refused to explain the reason for the price differences, or whether copyright owners or Apple itself are responsible for the blatant gouging of Australian music fans. However Apple is far from alone in the practice. Husic -- who has conducted a long-running campaign on the issue -- has used Twitter (@edhusicMP) to identify example after example of companies such as Microsoft, Adobe and Canon and games companies selling hardware and software in Australia at prices sometimes double those of the same products offshore. To take only the most obvious example, Microsoft’s Office suite ranges in price from US$119 ($114.69) for a home version to $350 ($337.32) for a single licence professional version in the US; the same range is $169 to $499 here, with both available by download. Nor is IT the only industry where this is rampant, as Crikey showed last year, gouging of Australian consumers is widespread across a range of major product categories. Australian consumers aren’t the only victims of the practice; businesses face inflated costs for key inputs like software and equipment. Adobe’s Creative Suite Premium software, for example, costs American buyers US$1899 ($1830) but will set back Australians purchasers $2886.30 before GST. The parliamentary inquiry is likely to examine the impact on business as well as consumers. The Productivity Commission looked at the issue of differential pricing in its inquiry into the retail industry last year and declared itself unimpressed:
"The Commission is also aware of the longstanding practice by which some international suppliers set differential regional prices. This effectively treats consumers in one region as willing, or able, to tolerate significantly higher prices than those in other regions. Australian consumers have an increasing awareness of such price differences and are now able, in many cases, to circumvent them by directly ordering online. This represents an example of ‘parallel importing’ which is the import of genuine products without the permission of the local licensee. Some international suppliers have attempted to defend price discrimination due to the cost of supplying a remote and relatively small market like Australia, which in some cases has its own unique requirements. These arguments, in most cases, are not persuasive, especially in the case, for example, of downloaded music, software and videos where the costs of delivery to the customer are practically zero and uniform around the world."

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

2 thoughts on “Parliamentary inquiry to take on big IT companies over pricing

  1. Clytie

    Spot on. I hope they look into ebooks: just before Christmas 2011, Hachette and HarperCollins doubled the price of ebooks for Australians. We’re now paying more than twice the new-paperback price for something with no resale or transfer value, something which (according to ebook “sale” contracts) we don’t actually own.

    As a disabled person unable to read paper books, I find this particularly despicable behaviour by the big publishers.

  2. John Bennetts


    Not only software. My wife’s iPad2, purchased in January, was virtually ignored as soon as my Visa card had been swiped. Talk of training and support were replaced by being asked to leave the store after about 30 minutes of the “introductory lesson”, during which the would-be trainer was fully occupied with his other three clients.

    Appropriate disgruntled comments were forthwith placed in the customer dissatisfaction survey which was emailed to my non-Apple address that very same day.

    The Apple Store is almost 2 hours’ drive from our home, because we are rural dwellers. They have absolutely no contact method available for customers wishing to have another go at the “training”. I would have to drive to the store and arrange a date when I could drive there again, etc, etc.

    Apple, this is the first and last appliance I will ever buy from you. Your service stinks. You have some kind of elitist idea that your product is so perfect that even a short introductory manual or cheat sheet is irrelevant and more.

    Eventually, my IT-savvy son and daughter visited and got things going, by which time I had been in China for a couple of weeks.

    Gee, thanks, Apple. Thanks IT geeks with attitude. Thanks for nothing.

    While overseas, I checked local prices for this almost-frisbee. That’s another story.

    We in Oz are not only being ripped off, but are also being abused. It is past time that the truth came out and for action to be taken to ensure that free trade works both ways.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details