Victorian nurses and midwives on Facebook have taken to using code names to discuss protests after the Baillieu government demanded that all comments on the Australian Nursing Federation’s (ANF) Facebook page that “organise, advise or assist” industrial action must be deleted.
A letter written by lawyers acting on behalf of the Baillieu government and sent to ANF lawyers states: “We also require that you confirm in writing that, once deletions have been effected, the ANF continue to maintain its social media websites to ensure that comments of a similar nature are immediately deleted.”
Rather than discussing events explicitly (more than 1000 Victorian nurses have taken part in rolling work stoppages at 15 public hospitals to protest against changes to the patient-to-nurse ratio and substituting nurses for “nursing assistants”) the updates by the Australian Nursing Federation on its Facebook page do not specify that the photos it posts are of workers taking industrial action.
Instead it keeps all of its official comments very general, referring instead to morning teas, bake offs and barbeques:
Get Crikey FREE to your inbox every weekday morning with the Crikey Worm.
Other ANF nurses have taken to calling industrial action “walking clubs” to try and get around the ban. The following posts all come from the ANF Facebook page (although they were not posted by the ANF):
Nurses at Frankston Hospital are expected to protest today and several nurses were referencing “walking” at Frankson this morning:
Other mentions are often more explicit, discussing “walkouts”, “stoppages” and nurses having their pay docked even if they are only attending industrial action protests during their breaks. Currently there are hundreds of updates on the ANF Facebook page from this morning alone.
Not that the protesting nurses are discussing the industrial action only on the ANF Facebook page. Many have taken to their own personal Facebook pages — often changing their profile photos to the ANF’s “Respect our Work” poster or to photos of themselves and other nurses standing in their bright red union t-shirts — to post their thoughts on the current dispute and explain why they are taking action:
Late last month the Federal Court ruled that the ANF stop its industrial action and ordered that it be restrained from “organising or continuing to organise industrial action” or “directing, inducing, procuring, advising or assisting” any person who doesn’t attend work or doesn’t perform it in the normal standard.
The court also ruled that “aiding, abetting, counselling, procuring or inducing” or “threatening or proposing to engage” in any of the conduct above would also be illegal. It is this ruling that the Victorian government is using to demand that the ANF delete comments off its Facebook page.
Social media is discussed in the judgment, but only in reference to how the ANF must inform its members of the order, noting that “… the ANF has communicated with its members about the rolling stoppages using social networking sites and websites” and ruling that it had to post the following instructive on its Facebook and Twitter accounts:
“ANF industrial action cancelled. All members must attend work as rostered and perform work in usual manner. Lisa Fitzpatrick, ANF Vic Sec’y”
The ANF said it would not comment to Crikey about the Facebook ban as it is subject to Federal Court proceedings and another court session will be held this Friday. Crikey asked Victorian Health Minister David Davis the following questions:
- Why has the ANF been asked to delete comments from its Facebook page regarding industrial action?
- I see that the court ruling banned the ANF “directing, inducing, procuring, advising or assisting” industrial action. What does that mean exactly when it comes to social media? What type of comments are allowed? Can ANF nurses openly declare their support for other ANF nurses that are protesting outside hospitals? Are they allowed to offer to bring supplies or extra support?
- Has the ANF abided by the request?
- Are there issues with nurses making comments on their private Facebook pages or just on the ANF page?
- Have nurses been blocked from “liking” Premier Baillieu or Minister Davis’s own Facebook pages and have their comments been deleted from those pages?
In response the minister’s office sent Crikey a copy of the legal letter it sent ANF lawyers demanding for Facebook posts on the ANF page be deleted. The letter references a recent Federal Court case involving the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Allergy Pathway Pty Ltd “which involved comments made by members of the public on social media sites administered by the defendant, which comments were inconsistent with undertakings the defendant had given to the Court. The Court found that the defendant had published those comments, by not removing them from its site. The Court punished the defendant for contempt of Court.”
Davis’ office also added: “Facebook users have not been, nor would they be, prevented from liking the Premier’s page. In fact, it is not technically possible to take such action.”