Nov 21, 2011

Gillard adds ‘ballast’ to shore up Indon relationship

Australia’s relationship with Indonesia is continuing at its all-time high following the conclusion of the East Asia Summit in Bali.

Professor Damien Kingsbury

Crikey international affairs commentator

Australia’s relationship with Indonesia is continuing at its all-time high following the conclusion of the East Asia Summit in Bali. Prime Minister Julia Gillard has come away from the summit confirming a major reduction in tariffs in trade with Indonesia, providing further "ballast" to the once-troubled relationship. Even Australia’s agreement to host US Marines in the Northern Territory has caused fewer problems than sometimes insecure strategic commentators in Jakarta might have indicated in the days immediately after the plan was announced. Having said that, it is unlikely that Australia will take up President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono’s suggestion that Australia also play host to China’s military, by way of balancing assertions of regional power. The ratification of the ASEAN-Australia-New Zealand Free Trade Agreement last week showed that Australia had "no better friend or partner" than Indonesia in the Asian region, according to Trade Minister Craig Emerson. The deal and Emerson’s comment reflect a long-term policy initiative begun by then foreign affairs minister Gareth Evans in the mid-1990s, to add trade "ballast" to the bilateral relationship to help ensure it is not unbalanced by other bilateral issues. This policy appears to be working, with the otherwise tricky issue of increasing a US military presence in Australia not raising nearly the level of concern that it might once have. Similarly, following the trade agreement, discussion has resumed on a prisoner swap deal between the two countries while the issue of bilateral co-operation on people smuggling continues positively as one of a handful of critical issues between the two countries. Even the recent live cattle export drama was off the agenda, being subsumed by the larger trade agreement. Meanwhile, Indonesia is working towards satisfying Australian concerns so the trade can resume, probably early in the new year. Flare-ups such as the live cattle issue are proving to be peripheral to the larger bilateral relationship. Beyond trade, the settling of Australia-Indonesia bilateral relations reflects a maturing of the relationship based on an increasing agreement around underlying principles of governance. Indonesia as a democratising state is vastly easier for Australia to work with than an Indonesia ruled by an authoritarian president with the support of the military. So, too, the particular democratic and reformist temper of President Yudhoyono is much closer to Australia’s world view than any of his predecessors, further allowing bilateral relations to more easily overcome molehills that might have once been portrayed as mountains. While Australia agreed to give Indonesia four Hercules transport aircraft, what was not discussed, at least in public, was the increasing closeness of bilateral defence ties. This, along with the US providing Indonesia with F16 fighter aircraft, further helps explain why Indonesia is not as concerned as it might be about an increased US military presence in Australia. While the past 12 months of the bilateral relationship has been characterised by some media as difficult, this has more highlighted the type of relatively minor problems that occur in most bilateral relationships rather than the substance of the relationship that allows such minor issues to pass without  derailing the relationship. The underlying bilateral relationship is, along with Indonesia’s political health, the best it has ever been. The real test for Indonesia -- and for bilateral relations -- will come with President Yudhoyono steps down at the conclusion of his second term in office in 2014. Australia will be keen to load up further "ballast" ahead of the possibility of his successor not being as closely aligned with those currently shared reformist and democratic values.

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

4 thoughts on “Gillard adds ‘ballast’ to shore up Indon relationship

  1. potatoes

    Julia, what about West Papua?

  2. Gavin Moodie

    Has a President of Indonesia ever visited Australia? If they have, it was a while ago or got little media coverage.

  3. AR

    Sukarno’s rational demand for Indonesian independence declared the unity of the ethnic, religious (tuff, Bali) and linguistic coherence on the Dutch East Indies. West New Guinea (not Papua, Spud, they are a people of the NE) ticks NONE of those boxes, as evidenced daily by the Javan militia’s contempt for semi-naked nigras.
    But it has that damned massive mine at the Orwellian named FREETOWN so too much foreign investment doing very nicely, thank you for shutting up.

  4. shepherdmarilyn

    It’s all about stopping refugees and nothing else.

    Why does Indonesia need all that weaponry when they are only killing the people of Papua and cracking down on their own nationals.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details