You may not know Paul Whittaker but you do know his boss. The new editor of Sydney’s Daily Telegraph ran Rupert Murdoch’s The Australian for four years before taking charge at the tabloid. And he’s already causing a stir by laying into Liberal Premier Barry O’Farrell.

The Tele went hard on the previous NSW government but it’s not going to give this one a rails run,” Whittaker told The Power Index. “Our readers are less patient than they were with the previous mob. They’re just desperate to see something done.”

With his blue-striped shirt, dark blue tie, steel-rimmed glasses and pale blonde hair, Whittaker could be mistaken for a bank manager. But sometime in the past he must have been crossed with a pit-bull. Pugnacious, proud and confident, he’s from the same breed as Murdoch’s favourite newshound, Kelvin MacKenzie, ex-editor of the London Sun.

Certainly, the 42-year-old Walkley-winning journalist has already proved himself at The Australian to be adept at using a newspaper’s power. After all, The Tele is the paper that all politicians fear.

“A bad relationship with The Telegraph sees you get a hiding every day,” said a former NSW Labor premier. “That makes life hard. Their issues, not yours, dominate the political agenda, and you’re forced to talk to them or compromise.”

“Do you as a minister care more about what The Tele says than The Herald?” asked another former Labor premier, before answering his own question: “Yes, absolutely.”

The Telegraph sells around 350,000 copies a day — 150,000 more than The Sydney Morning Herald — and it claims to have almost 1 million readers, or twice the amount of listeners as the city’s top-rating shock jock Alan Jones. But The Tele has a much broader audience than its competitors, so it can swing more votes. And it sets the daily agenda for commercial TV news and current affairs shows, where most people still get their news.

Whittaker was happy to talk to The Power Index, but he wanted our chat to be off the record. Which is ironic, considering his profession. He later agreed to approve a few quotes.

He talks non-stop for two hours straight: ideas, opinions and stories pouring out in a high-speed stream. It’s a sign of how much he loves his job, perhaps, or how much he wants to get this reporter onside.

He drives the paper hard, he says, writing headlines, directing stories and setting the agenda for his 165 journalists. “The best editors have the best ideas,” he said. “At The Australian we tried to do three or four things every day that no one else had got.”

The Tele reflects the views of its readers, adds Whittaker, but it’s clear he shapes and amplifies these views by hammering them home. “I call the issues as I see them,” he told The Power Index, assuring us he pursues his targets relentlessly. “Other papers run a story once and then let it drop. We’re going to stay on the story.”

Whittaker believes The Tele‘s duty in NSW is to pressure the government to move faster and further. And that’s what he’s been doing. At the end of August he ran a front-page headline — “Barrier O’Farrell” — suggesting the premier was getting in the way of necessary reform.

Later that day, former NSW premier Bob Carr wrote on his blog Thoughtlines that the headline was “bound to fix the O’Farrell team with a ‘do-nothing image'” which the Premier would find hard to shake off.

Two weeks later, Whittaker returned to the story with another banner headline — “Barry gets Nicked” — highlighting Nick Greiner’s message to O’Farrell that he needed to privatise electricity and sell state assets — and do it fast — if NSW was to pay for the infrastructure it so desperately needs.

So does the newspaper have enough clout to put a rocket under O’Farrell? “I think we can get his attention pretty quickly,” said Whittaker.

*Read the full profile at The Power Index

Peter Fray

Fetch your first 12 weeks for $12

Here at Crikey, we saw a mighty surge in subscribers throughout 2020. Your support has been nothing short of amazing — we couldn’t have got through this year like no other without you, our readers.

If you haven’t joined us yet, fetch your first 12 weeks for $12 and start 2021 with the journalism you need to navigate whatever lies ahead.

Peter Fray
Editor-in-chief of Crikey