Lord Christopher Monckton has slammed Port Adelaide Football Club for its decision to withdraw its venue for his speaking tour, blaming the club’s decision on pressure from activist group GetUp.
In an exclusive Crikey interview, Lord Monckton laid the blame for the withdrawal squarely at the feet of GetUp who he accused of orchestrating an online campaign to silence him. He expressed supreme displeasure at the cavalcade of venue cancellations on his east coast tour following negative publicity over his use of an on-stage Nazi swastika.
“There has been a long-planned organised attempt to stop me being heard in Australia on this trip. I got wind that plans were afoot to do this some months ago,” Monckton told Crikey.
“And free speech used to be precious to Australians. Giving people a fair go was what Australia was all about. Now it seems things have changed.”
When asked for an explanation for Port Adelaide’s actions, Monckton didn’t miss a beat.
“I know there’s an organisation called GetUp that had a ‘destroy the Monckton tour ‘ page on its website and was encouraging hundreds of members to ring round the venues and try to persuade them not to allow me to speak,” he said.
But GetUp national director Simon Sheikh hit back this morning, denying “any contact with any of the venues that decided to cancel the bookings…nor have we invited any GetUp members to do so.”
On Monday, Crikey revealed that “German” clubs in three cities — Adelaide, Fremantle and Melbourne — had contacted organiser Leon Ashby from the Climate Sceptics party to withdraw their venues in the wake of the Nazi scandal. ln front of a PowerPoint display of a giant swastika last month in Los Angeles, Monckton branded decorated economist Ross Garnaut a “fascist” for his dogmatism in backing the federal government’s carbon tax, an allusion for which he was later forced to apologise.
Yesterday, Port Adelaide — intended as a replacement for the cancelled German club date — also backed away.
Crikey understands that just minutes after 5AA Adelaide radio host Leon Byner mentioned Monckton was speaking at Port Adelaide on his radio show, a club manager jumped on the phone to Ashby to cancel. This afternoon in an email spray, Ashby said the tour was “getting way beyond the [sic] joke”:
“Why are people afraid of being able to have business transaction events with climate sceptics — is everything you or I do tainted with who we associate with?”
Ashby implied that because Port Adelaide often hosts risque sportsman’s nights they should be able to host an anodyne climate sceptic:
“So why the sensitivity on this issue? Are we in a society with people saying ‘unclean unclean’ their minds are evil because they think CO2 is not a pollutant.
“This is footy clubs not giving the public freedom to hear both sides of a story. Is this is [sic] the new world of the thought police?”
Ashby claimed Port Adelaide cancelled because they were afraid to lose government cash and subsidies:
“The corruption of freedom of speech because Government Grants are only given when you support the party line.”
But Andrew Rutter, communications & media manager for the Port Adelaide Football Club told Crikey that “the booking was accepted by a staff member, but was cancelled after management became aware of it and gave consideration to the matter.”
“The Port Adelaide Football Club is a sporting club and that is what we are about. The Club respects everyone’s right to an opinion, but does not see itself or its facilities as a platform for any political viewpoint.”
The ailing Port Adelaide club could have done with Monckton’s room hire fee. Earlier this month, the AFL and SANFL announced a $14 million crisis grant for the club to wipe out $1.5 million in debt.
As for GetUp’s hand in the string of venue shutdowns, Sheikh ruled out any involvement : “Lord Monckton’s claims that GetUp is in any way involved in the decision made by venues to end their involvement in his Australian speaking tour are patently untrue.”
“While GetUp is obviously opposed to Monckton’s anti-climate science stance, we have not at any point sough to limit his freedom of speech — and we don’t intend to so in the future.
“It’s disappointing that Lord Monckton would lash out at GetUp members simply because he’s taken as gospel unfounded accusations made by the likes of Andrew Bolt,” Sheikh said.
“These men may find it easier to digest a fabricated version of events where there has been underhanded, foul play, but the fact of the matter is these venues don’t want to be associated with Lord Monckton and his brand of fear-mongering. This is something they would have discovered if they had engaged in fact-checking rather than making it up as they go.”
The Port Adelaide cancellation makes it six venues to ban Monckton from their premises, including the Broncos’ Leagues Club, Brisbane restaurant Gambaro’s and the three German clubs.
Lord Monckton was unable to name an alternative Adelaide venue yesterday.
41 thoughts on “Power out for Monckton at Port Adelaide as Lord lashes out”
Holden Back
July 6, 2011 at 4:17 pmKayeG, But he did design a jigsaw or two, so he’s clearly a mathematician.
fangfarrier
July 6, 2011 at 5:01 pmHow dare such an obvious heretic continue to have a voice.He should be burnt at the stake lest he infect one believer with his world-defying statements.True believers must pray harder to Bob and Christine that light should only shine on the
faithful.
Amen.
Flower
July 6, 2011 at 5:02 pmNow listen here. Don’t you know who I am, you bunch of “bed-wetting moaning Minnies of the Apocalyptic Traffic-Light Tendency—those Greens too yellow to admit they’re really Reds?”
klewso
July 6, 2011 at 5:09 pmI think he’s funny.
Edgar Bergen had Charlie McCarthy, Effie Klinker and Mortimer Snerd – the Mining industry’s got Mockton, Jones and Cousin Jethro.
Robin
July 6, 2011 at 5:21 pmJust in! Lord Monckton was heard denying gravity and was last seen floating off with the pixies.
Wrigbe
July 6, 2011 at 10:18 pmAh well for all of you who want to see Monckton in all his glory, I believe he will get to present his case at the Press Club… I am not sure that he will enjoy the experience so much though…. kind of almost feel sorry for the poor man really.
michael r james
July 6, 2011 at 10:45 pm[LORRY Posted Wednesday, 6 July 2011 at 2:24 pm |
It amazes me how you are all so scared of a little debate on your religion – what are you afraid of, losing your convictions perhaps.]
I try hard not to feed the trolls but in the context of this article and commentary I think it is worth pointing out your terrific contributions that make it self-explanatory why no sane person would want to engage with you or your fellow-traveller Monckton (or Abbott for that matter).
The following is a post you made on an article (as shown in the web address) on Crikey on 30 June. (It was removed by Crikey as transgressing their commenting rules.) It was even more offensively puerile than your usual, in just 4 words. Bravo.
[(crikey.com.au/2011/06/30/internet-filtering-isnt-compulsory-but-everyone-will-volunteer/#comment-143892)
.
Heil Ju-Liar, Heil Ju-Liar.]
As to his Lordship, I am a bit disappointed we on the east coast are being deprived of his nuttiness. (Being in the electorate of Brisbane, narrowly won by Teresa Gambaro (her father created the famous fish wholesaler and restaurant), I especially wanted his appearance here, sponsored by Gambaro, to go ahead. The Greens vote (Andrew Bartlett), already the highest amongst marginal electorates at 21.3%, would be pushed higher. In all likelihood this is the next HR seat to go Green at the next election, making Gambaro a one-termer.)
The media exposure, particularly if Tony Abbott, or Gambaro, was present, would be priceless. As was his appearance in California. I still hope for another appearance on Lateline to be embarassed (again) by Tony Jones. But I doubt very much that anyone, like George Monbiot, would bother to debate him anymore; he has had his 15 minutes and, excepting a few out-of-touch zany Californian sects and dumb Australian backwoodsmen, no one else takes him seriously.
klewso
July 6, 2011 at 11:34 pmIf some of “us” could work out where they left it – the rest of us could work on changing their minds?
Holden Back
July 7, 2011 at 10:59 amIt is amusing how withdrawal of a private venue from a hire arrangement is immediately characterised as a restriction on freedom of speech, all the while generating further publicity for other dates. Similarly, refuting or not agreeing with Monckton’s positions is seen as stifling debate by those who support him.
I think he’s a fascinating figure, straight out of fiction: an eighteenth-century dilettante Milord, whose opinion of himself is so high, he doesn’t need to makes sense. He does have a rather colourful career of lying to the press for the purposes of publicity – he claimed he had to sell his ancestral home when some mathematicians solved his jiigsaw puzzle rather quickly. He didn’t, and hadn’t, but it got him some column inches.
klewso
July 7, 2011 at 3:09 pmWhat sort of hearing do “supporters of the science” get on “Gloria’s Glory Box”?