Jun 24, 2011

Coup anniversary: where are they now?

Paul Barry and Matthew Knott look back at the main players in the Night of the Long Knives: where are they now?

Yesterday Canberra correspondent Bernard Keane and senior journalist Paul Barry drew a portrait of a man at the height of enormous power, and how quickly Kevin Rudd's base was eroded by his own hand. When Rudd's public popularity collapsed, so too did his prime ministership …Today Paul Barry and Matthew Knott look back at the main players who featured in the downfall of a Prime Minister and chart the year since that pivotal 24 hours. Bill Shorten Before the 2010 election, Julia Gillard promised that the plotters who helped put her into power would not be rewarded. But they have been. And none more so than Bill Shorten -- the man who first told her to challenge Rudd. A week before the coup, Shorten told Gillard that Labor would crash to defeat unless she took the reins. If she dared to challenge, he would deliver the numbers. And so it went. Shorten spent the night of the long knives holed up in a Vietnamese restaurant with Don Farrell and Kate Ellis, marshalling support for Gillard on his mobile. The ambitious ex-AWU secretary felt under-appreciated by Rudd -- although responsibility for Disability Services and the Black Saturday bushfire reconstruction effort was hardly small beer for a novice MP. Shorten now has a full policy plate as Assistant Treasurer and Minister for Financial Services and Superannuation. But that doesn't mean his factional plays are behind him: he still runs the powerful Victorian Right grouping, known as the Short-Cons, in alliance with Stephen Conroy. Paul Howes As Shorten and his fellow plotters juggled mobile phones and rice paper rolls in Canberra, the Australian Workers Union national secretary was in Sydney prepping for a now-notorious appearance on Lateline. Howes was the first Labor figure to publicly call for Rudd to go. The interview did wonders for Howes' profile but angered many in the ALP. Tony Abbott spent the next few weeks whipping up community outrage about a prime minister knifed by unelected trade union thugs. Howes argues the horse had bolted well before he sat down with Tony Jones-- and he's right. But the mythology of him as a powerful factional kingpin lives on. Labor insiders say his influence in the party is wildly overstated. “He doesn't have the power he claims to have,” one senior NSW Labor figure says.  “He didn't swing a vote against Rudd that night,” claims a former Labor Right powerbroker. Although Howes, 29, claims to regret making himself a part of the "Kill Kevin" story, his reputation as a media tart grows apace. Over the past year he has published a campaign diary, been profiled on Australian Story, penned scores of articles for News Limited, repeatedly slagged off Kevin Rudd and accused Rio Tinto of “sucking the blood of blue-collar workers". Howes had been mooted as a candidate for the safe south Sydney seat of Barton, but he says he will renominate for his AWU position. Stung by criticism about his role in the coup, the ex-Trotskyist is focused on building support among his members. This helps explain his about-face on climate change. Howes says his union will withdraw its support for the carbon tax if it costs one job. He also wants the steel industry to be exempt until there is a global price on carbon. Howes doesn't deny that he is keen to head to Canberra one day. Which is just as well: no-one would believe him if he did. Bill Ludwig ALP insiders say it is Big Bill, not his protege Paul Howes, who is the true powerbroker in the AWU. He isn't called “The Godfather” for nothing. Convinced Rudd lost the plot after the failed Copenhagen climate change conference, Ludwig was quick to swing his numbers behind Gillard when it became clear a challenge was on. And his numbers are formidable. The AWU is the only union that boasts its own faction, one that includes key Rudd defectors Wayne Swan and Bill Shorten. Despite his advancing age -- Ludwig is 76 -- the AWU national president still wields significant power. At the AWU national conference in February, Julia Gillard praised him as a “big man with a big heart”. She could have added big mouth: Ludwig slammed Trade Minister Craig Emerson as a "dishonorable rat" for daring to say that he was not a fan of Paul Howes’ anti-Rio Tinto rhetoric. Close ALP watchers were not surprised when Wayne Swan – who has been a loyal lieutenant to Ludwig for almost 30 years -- refused to publicly back Emerson and Gillard in the subsequent spat. Ludwig has hinted that he may step down from his AWU post in 2013 but Howes is pushing for him to serve another four year term. And why not? Chicago’s famous political boss, Mayor Daley Snr, died in office. Why shouldn’t Big Bill do the same? David Feeney The former Victorian ALP secretary and close comrade of Bill Shorten has seen his fortunes rise since Rudd's departure -- but trouble looms on the horizon. A backbencher a year ago, Feeney was promoted to Parliamentary Secretary for Defence after the election. He has also replaced his NSW counterpart Mark Arbib in the powerful position as convenor of the ALP's national Right faction. Yet Feeney's very future in parliament is now under threat, thanks to the rising popularity of the Greens. He's only number three on the Victorian Senate ticket for 2013.  And guess how many Victorian ALP candidates won senate seats last time around: two. Don Farrell The hardman of the South Australian religious Right -- his nickname is The Pope -- remains a key powerbroker. Farrell played a crucial role in roping in SA votes for Gillard last year and, like his fellow plotters, scored a promotion after the election. Farrell is now Parliamentary Secretary for Sustainability and Urban Water. He was accused of handing out jobs to party mates in May when he appointed former Labor MP Leo McLeay to the Sydney Harbour Federation Trust board. Alister Jordan As Rudd's chief of staff, the media-shy Jordan was one of the most powerful men in Australia and he certainly behaved like it. The 31-year-old occasionally sat in for the PM at important national security briefings. And when Rudd became nervous about his grip on the leadership he got Jordan – rather than a  numbers man in caucus – to check his level of support. This infuriated Gillard and is widely seen as the catalyst for her decision to launch a challenge. Like Rudd's other favoured wunderkinds -- Andrew Charlton and Lachlan Harris -- Jordan had few friends within the ALP. When the boss got the boot, so did they. Since September, Jordan has been working in Sydney as a senior manager with Wesfarmers Insurance. He no longer has to sleep at night in a sofa in his office. Andrew Charlton The other Boy Charlton was a latecomer to Rudd's office but soon became one of his closest confidantes. Before becoming Rudd's principal economics adviser, the Rhodes scholar worked at management consulting firm Boston Consulting, received the Oxford University award for the best doctoral thesis in economics and wrote a book with Nobel laureate Joseph Stiglitz. Like Jordan, Charlton has moved on to that great resting place for fallen Laborites: Wesfarmers (former WA Premier Alan Carpenter is also on the payroll). He's been working as the conglomerate's business projects manager in Perth since November. In his spare time the ambitious 32-year old pens articles on economics and politics for the high-brow magazine The Monthly. Lachlan Harris Kevin Rudd's precocious and prickly press secretary admits that he is "looking for the next mountain to climb" in his life. Following the coup, Harris flew to New York for a holiday but was soon called back home by Gillard. Worried that Rudd would run riot, the PM convinced Harris to mind his former boss for the rest of the campaign. After the election, he founded Bondi Belts -- a fashion chain whose mission is to "save the world from boring belts". The 31-year old creator of the "Kevin O7" slogan also writes a weekly column for the Sunday Telegraph, appears regularly on radio 2GB and advises companies on how to spin the media. He'd like to re-enter politics one day but Canberra press gallery veterans will be glad if he stays in Bondi: Harris became notorious for bullying and threatening journalists who ran negative stories about his boss. John Faulkner After Gillard's "blood-soaked knock at the door", as Chris Pyne so poetically put it, the PM called in the elder statesman to help convince her to change her mind. The trio spent three hours in Rudd's office thrashing it out -- joined at one point by Rudd loyalist Anthony Albanese. Gillard allegedly told Rudd she would give him until October to reverse Labor's flagging fortunes. But when she heard from supporters that the numbers were in her favour, she decided to go ahead with the putsch. The then-Defence Minister quit the ministry only two weeks after Gillard's ascension, claiming it was time for "generational change". Following the election he has launched a crusade -- via the 2010 ALP National Review and a withering speech earlier this month --for the Labor Party to expand and energise its membership base. Sceptical observers say it is too little, too late. Lindsay Tanner Let's not forget today's other important milestone: one year since the then-Finance Minister announced his resignation from parliament. Gillard and Tanner were once bitter rivals in the small world of the Victorian Labor politics, but Tanner claims his decision to quit had nothing to do with his fellow Leftie taking the top job. The former "kitchen cabinet" minister now works alongside Paul Keating as a part-time advisor with investment banking firm Lazard. Earlier this year he published Sideshow, a scathing critique of the Australian political media. Unsurprisingly, most hacks hated it. Karl Bitar “Karl has gone from shooting crap inside the Labor Party to shooting craps in the casino,” ex-NSW Premier Morris Iemma quipped last month when this key conspirator took the Packer shilling and signed on with Crown Casino. "Karl doesn’t understand public policy at all, but private interests he definitely does understand,” added former NSW minister Frank Sartor, “So maybe he’s found his true calling.” But many ALP insiders think Packer has bought a lemon. Bitar left NSW Labor a smouldering ruin and almost burnt the house down in Canberra too when he became the party's national secretary. He encouraged Rudd to shelve the emissions trading scheme -- thus trashing the PM's credibility -- then agitated for Rudd's removal as soon as his polling went south. One year late the polls are even worse and Bitar has fled the scene of the crime. A key part of his new lobbying job is to encourage the government to abandon or water down its mandatory pre-commitment pokie reforms. It won't be an easy task. His name is mud in the party -- particularly the Left -- and he's up against the powerful anti-pokie crusader Andrew Wilkie who's threatened to pull the pin on the government if his reforms aren't made law. Mark Arbib The other half of the  "Karl Marks" bromance can weather almost any storm -- from failing to front for a Q&A post-election special to starring in WikiLeaks cables as a US embassy informer. He's still powerful and active behind the scenes, despite the chaos he's caused. But he's no longer leader of the pack, given he has stepped down as convenor of the Labor Right. He's also got his hands full with ministerial duties: Arbib is now Minister for Sport, Indigenous Employment and Social Housing. "Mark wants to be a serious player in government, so he has stepped back from factional games, because he can’t be seen as a plotter," says a friend. But if Arbib has given up his backroom manoevering that’s news to Bob McLelland and Daryl Melham. Both are being white-anted in their safe seats in southern Sydney by the Right wing powerbrokers who want them out. And Arbib is in the thick of it. *This essay is a taste of what’s to come as part of the top-secret project from Paul Barry that Crikey subscribers will soon have access to …

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

22 thoughts on “Coup anniversary: where are they now?

  1. Steve Grant

    Just a thought – did anyone ask John Faulkner whether he was the Cabinet leaker who dumped on Gillard last year? Faulkner quit in the first week of July and about a week later the first leak hit the headlines. Everyone was busy trying to nail Rudd, but his staunch and furious ally Faulkner would have been the more obvious candidate. But I’ve never seen any denials or even speculation reported.

  2. klewso

    Did you mean to make Karl Bizar sound like “Alan Harper”?

  3. CML

    So, I guess the dirt on all the LNP lunatics will be aired next week??? And pigs might fly then as well….!!!
    Crikey – you can’t go around bashing up Limited News (even though they richly deserve it) for one-sided reporting, then want to be taken seriously when you do it.
    I am over the whole Labor/Rudd/Gillard examination of entrails. I think Rudd should have remained PM. He didn’t. So the whole damn lot of them can suffer the consequences which I believe will be annihilation at the next election. Trouble is, we the voters get the worst deal – Mr. rAbbott and his motley crew.

  4. Son of foro

    “Did you mean to make Karl Bizar sound like “Alan Harper”?”

    He sounds more like Alan Partridge to me.

  5. Barbara Boyle

    Thanks for the run down on the coup-ers. May we look forward to regular updates on their activities,.

  6. botswana bob

    To coin a phrase its deja vu all over again. On assassination day the polliepaths are telling us how ab fab is Julia Caesar, whilst carrying on thuging, scheming and plotting. Lets hope after the next election–which looks like an ALP Waterloo–many will be faced with finding Real jobs.

  7. Tom McLoughlin

    Oh come on, the coup-ers were all in corporate board rooms and tv advertising phone conferences. This is not about the coup. It is about the monkeys. We need to read about the organ grinder who made the tune. BHP, Rio Tinto, Fortescue, and the rest. And their favoured monkey – Martin Ferguson.

    These hacks above were the servants of Big Capital, the biggest being the multinational miners, with not so Big Politics simply adjusting their sail to the prevailing winds, and replacing the helmsman to implement the change in tax policy direction.

    When indeed will we get an inside account of the BILLIONS of dollars of tax minimisation, if not avoidance/fraud, by the Big Miners over the super profits tax?

    Not for nothing has totalitarianism being subdivided into communist and corporate hegemony, by such as the Pope and others (ironic coming from the roman church regime, they should know about hierarchy). Morally as suspect as the other for their hierarchical oppression of the genuine public interest, subversives for their special executive overpaid interests, and institutional share holders.

    I know. It will never be written and never be acknowledged. Corporate fascism? Money politics?

    You bet. Keep voting g/Green if you believe in freedom from this tyranny of sly money politics.

  8. AR

    I have printed this list and stuck it on my wall. I shall enjoy adding to it as they, inevitably, inexorably compound their crimes against decency – a leopard doesn’t change its shorts.

  9. Frank Campbell

    This account is a precis of “Power Without Glory”: ambitious Alpha males. Useful, but to understand the incestuous coteries of the political/media class and their intimate links to corporations, we need Jane Austen. (Occasionally Crikey publishes lists of “relationships”, but these are never sustained or amplified.)

    Much is on the public record. This from the “Sunday Telegraph” (2008) on Bill Shorten:
    “Labor MP Bill Shorten has left his wife for the daughter of Kevin Rudd’s newly appointed Governor-General, Quentin Bryce.

    (He) separated from his wife, Deborah Beale, in the past month and is understood to be in a relationship with Chloe Bryce.

    Mr Shorten, who was formerly the Australian Workers’ Union national secretary, has been touted as a future Labor leader for several years…

    …Mr Shorten and Ms Bryce have been friends for at least a year.

    The pair had dinner together at Quentin Bryce’s residence in Brisbane on September 5, 2007, when she was Queensland Governor, according to a Vice-Regal notice in Brisbane’s Courier Mail newspaper.

    “In the evening, the Governor received the call of Ms Chloe Bryce-Parkin and Mr Bill Shorten,” the notice states.

    Mr Shorten then went on to become elected as the Member for Maribyrnong at the federal election and thanked his wife, Deborah, in the maiden speech he delivered in February this year, four months after visiting the now-Governor General with Ms Bryce-Parkin.

    “Above all others – and I can say this on Valentine’s Day – I thank my wife, Deb Beale, an endlessly intelligent, supportive and loving woman,” he said.

    “I knew this instantly from my first outing, when she agreed to visit a picket line with me.”

    He also thanked his parents-in-law, Julian and Felicity Beale.

    Mr Shorten was one of five MPs invited to attend the September ceremony where Ms Quentin Bryce was sworn in as the 25th Governor-General of Australia.

    Chloe Bryce attended the ceremony, with her two children, Georgette and Rupert, from her marriage to architect Roger Parkin.

    Mr Parkin’s works include a house he designed for the late Beatle George Harrison on Hamilton Island and the Hamilton Island resort itself…

    …Ms Bryce, who works as a media consultant for Cement Australia, did not return calls yesterday.
    Deborah Beale and Bill Shorten were considered a power couple in the Labor Party.

    They met while studying for their MBAs.

    Ms Beale, whose father Julian Beale is a wealthy Melbourne investor and former federal Liberal MP, was a powerful political asset for Mr Shorten.

    She provided a strong link to the corporate world through her father’s friendship with multi-millionaire businessman Richard Pratt.

    Mr Pratt flew Mr Shorten back to Australia from the UnitedStates on his private plane when the Beaconsfield mine disaster occurred in 2006.

    Mr Shorten’s role representing workers during the Beaconsfield tragedy significantly raised the former union leader’s public profile.

    “Ms Beale was well regarded by the Labor Party and well-connected in corporate areas,” one source said.

    “Everyone thought they were the Princess Diana and the Prince of the party.”

    Mr Shorten formerly dated and lived with current Federal Health Minister Nicola Roxon, who is understood to speak highly of her new parliamentary colleague.”

    This tells us more about the manipulation and distribution of power than the Knott/Barry thumbnails. There’s Mrs Shorten II’s role as “media consultant” to Cement Australia, which invokes possible carbon grief (cement being wickedly implicated in CO2 emissions). Then there’s the Pratt connection, which facilitated Shorten’s rise from anonymous political pastry to media tart at the Beaconsfield mine collapse.
    The role of the ubiquitous MBA is also instructive…

    Labour’s angst about loss of direction and membership, its empty ideological shell and inclusion into the corporate state need a wider sociological analysis. Jane Austen can help explain why the light on the hill went out.

  10. Suzanne

    That incident has permanently damaged the ALP brand, as witnessed in the polls to a certain extent.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details