Menu lock

Comments & corrections

Apr 21, 2011

Religion in schools

Crikey readers have their say.

Religion in schools:

Keith Binns writes: Re. “Religion in schools: time to cut the Gordian knot” (yesterday, item 11). I sympathise with Tony Taylor’s concerns about religious instruction, or RI, versus religious education. or RE, in schools. So much of it, at least here in NSW, doesn’t seem to take into account the developmental stage of the child.

I would make the following point, however: A lot of parents seem to want it as they are voting with their feet and sending their children to religious schools where immersion in a particular religious culture is compulsory. I would expect a banning of RI in schools will exacerbate that trend and state schools will lose even more students, money and political influence.

Compulsory RI should not be allowed, but to ban it out right will simply aid the drift. A local high school near us had the right idea. The principal allowed students and staff time to attend Catholic World Youth Day activates. He said: “All students should feel welcome at this school.”

Having said that, I find it fascinating that so many conservative Christian schools are springing up as it contradicts one of their basic doctrines. The Great Commission says ” Go into all the world.” They have changed that to “Build it, and they will come.”

St Paul’s command to be “in it, but not of it” has obviously passed them by.

We recommend

From around the web

Powered by Taboola


Leave a comment

4 thoughts on “Religion in schools

  1. Sancho

    Yes, but remember that these are the same religious conservatives who continuously discover that what Jesus wants is identical to what the business lobby wants.

  2. Barry 09

    God doesn’t want the NBN or the Carbon Tax or Mining Tax or plain packet ciggies or to stop people playing Pokies and he don’t want Labor in Power.

  3. Michael Harvey

    Kids need vaccinating. Religious schools provide lifelong immunity for the bright.

  4. sauron256

    The Great Commission doesn’t say “go into all the world.” It says this:

    “Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you.”

    If you’re going to criticize Christians, at least have the decency to get your facts straight before you quote “scripture” at them.