Wayne Swan has made good on his pledge to confront banking reform, yesterday announcing a range of reforms include banning exit fees for new mortgage loans, giving lenders more funding options and providing consumers more information.

The announcements arrive after the fanfare eventually died down for ‘Hockeynomics,’ Joe Hockey’s call for banking reform via his much-trumpeted nine point plan.

Not to be rushed, Swam assured us his package was in the mail, and it arrived yesterday with the proclamation that it will “build up competition in our banking system, which will ensure that interest rates are lower over time.”

Banning exit fees is arguably the most important component of Swanny’s reforms, though it will only apply to new loans and will not cover small business loans.

Media consensus appears to be that the reform package is “mild but measured” but reception was nevertheless varied. Here’s a snapshot of what some of the pundits had to say:

The Australian

A populist package, but will it deliver on rates?

The real test of the banking measures announced yesterday is whether they deliver on the promise made by Wayne Swan himself — lower interest rates for Australians over time. The Treasurer says the package is about “helping customers, helping households and helping business”. Just as he did with the ill-fated Grocery Choice and Fuel Watch projects introduced in the early part of the Rudd government, Mr Swan seems intent on government intervention to fix what he terms market failure.

Jennifer Hewitt: Gulf between PR and reality

There are some modestly sensible measures, such as trying to limit the big banks’ reliance on offshore funding by allowing them to issue covered bonds to enable them to raise more money here, presumably from the superannuation funds.

But the impact of such changes will be minor and gradual. It hardly counts as either bank bashing or major reform.

National Times

Tim Colebatch: Treasurer’s sensible attempt to drive change

We might have to be patient. Most of these reforms are sensible and small-scale: giving consumers more information, giving lenders more funding options. But there are two things on Swan’s list that, in time, could make a difference.

The first is his plan to ban exit fees for new mortgage loans from July 1 next year. It will apply only to new loans. It won’t cover almost $1 trillion we owe already on existing mortgages. Nor will it apply to small business loans.

Peter Martin and Eric Johnston: Swan has no ‘silver bullet’ for banking reform

The ANZ Bank said it had not been consulted by Mr Swan and pointed to the ”difficulties a lack of consultation created in the mining industry”.

Other measures are wins for the big banks and their competitors. Treasury will encourage the development of ”covered bonds” where repackaged and onsold mortgages remain on the lender’s balance sheet.

Australian Financial Review

Andrew Cornell: More consumer power is way to go

The best thing about the Swan reforms is they won’t do too much damage; the worst is they won’t do too much good either.

The Daily Telegraph

Bankers furious at fee reform rebuff

The ANZ Bank has slammed the Federal Government’s lack of consultation on banking sector competition reforms, likening the apparent snub of the major banks to the mining tax debacle.

Money AU

Sharat: Wayne Swan Proposes Banking Reform To Increase Competition

Mr. Swan denied that that his plans for banking reforms were his attempt to play catch up with his opposition counterpart Joe Hockey’s nine point banking reform plan. He added that he will reveal most of his banking reform proposals next month.

The battle between the government and the Big Four Lenders has intensified, as the government threatens more stringent industry regulation.

Peter Fray

Get your first 12 weeks of Crikey for $12.

Without subscribers, Crikey can’t do what it does. Fortunately, our support base is growing.

Every day, Crikey aims to bring new and challenging insights into politics, business, national affairs, media and society. We lift up the rocks that other news media largely ignore. Without your support, more of those rocks – and the secrets beneath them — will remain lodged in the dirt.

Join today and get your first 12 weeks of Crikey for just $12.

 

Peter Fray
Editor-in-chief of Crikey

JOIN NOW