Companies

Nov 8, 2010

Terry Cutler: the dearth and decline of innovation

Countries like Norway and Chile are using returns on natural resource exports to create national funds to diversify and future proof their economic base. This is all about national leadership and vision. And when it comes to innovation, we don't have it, writes Terry Cutler.

Three years ago I had a brief flutter of hope that Australia might allow the topic of innovation onto the main stage.

Topics

27 comments

Leave a comment

27 thoughts on “Terry Cutler: the dearth and decline of innovation

  1. Apathy

    Here, Here.

    Could you put up links to the reports you have referred to

  2. Jonathan Maddox

    I commend those business owners who are happy with the results they are achieving for themselves and their workers, and who do not wish to commit their lives, their souls and their wealth to growth for its own sake.

    If the only priority for every business was growth for growth’s sake, all businesses would have the same culture, and the world would be an extremely dull place.

    Businesses do not need to exist only for the sake of growth. They may have other purposes : to make the founders rich is often the reason for setting up a business in the first place, but it’s a legitimate choice for owners not to make profit maximisation their first priority. I understand that the directors of listed for-profit companies have a legal fiduciary duty to maximise profits, but privately-held businesses are not under the same constraint. Nor, obviously, are non-profit organisations.

    Growth is not in itself an evil and it can indeed be a positive good. But it has many possible negative consequences. To date, economic growth has always gone hand in hand with growth in resource consumption; that growth *cannot* carry on infinitely on a finite planet or in a finite universe (as some resources are not renewable and there are limits to the production of the renewable ones).

    Our end-goals should be other, better, higher things than profits. If we’re obliged to pursue economic growth at all costs just to keep pace with other resource-destroying capitalists of our finite planet, we may as well just all kill ourselves now.

  3. Scott

    Beat me to it Jonathan Maddox. To decry business people for putting lifestyle ahead of expansion and profit maximization seems a bit silly to me.

    Innovation has it’s place (especially in regards to ecological modernization) and is important if it gets us where we want to go (or gets us away from an unhappy state), but let’s not forget that it’s a means to an end, not the end itself.

  4. Joe Hoogland

    I am a small business owner with ambitions to be a manufacturer. We have plenty of product development ideas and are currently grateful recipients of an AusIndustry grant. What changes would I like to see to assist industry?
    1. stable government policies for R&D support. There seem to be program changes every couple of years. Planning product development in our case is not just a month to month process – it is considered over a 2-3 year cycle.
    2. a willingness to address innovation and productivity as a national wealth creation opportunity by politicians and media. There is too much media focus on home ownership as a path to riches – this creates zero national wealth. I remember clearly when Beazley released Knowledge Nation in 1999 it was jeered off the public stage by a ridiculous focus on one diagram, yet take a look at the recommendations today and they are still valid. Neither politicians nor media had the courage to address the thoughtful proposals.
    3. banks willing to invest in business. My banker doesn’t lend to my business based on the business risk, it has mortgages over the assets of the directors. The reality is that if I take a risk to develop a new product and that project fails, I lose everything; personal assets, business assets, everything. The current controversy over bank profitability is all about housing, nothing about business.
    4. business organisations such as Business SA have a narrow and short term focus and add little to key debates. Witness the mining tax response here in SA by the business lobby groups – predictable, hysterical, short term, adding zero value to the discussion.
    5. tax policies which encourage idea development rather than speculation. It doesn’t make sense to me to allow negative gearing on housing speculation, yet I can’t offset my business loss against my personal income.

    I could go on but who’s listening?

  5. Gavin Moodie

    The Cutler review was poorly managed, the report was a massive 228 pages, it lacked a clear and persuasive argument or thesis, Cutler & Company Pty Ltd claimed copyright in what was meant to be a government report and the document was locked so it is impossible to copy parts of the text.

    Cutler is fortunate that Minister Carr was able to salvage as much as he did from the review.

  6. the man on the clapham omnibus

    Having worked in a ‘knowledge’ nation in Sweden for several years their focus on innovation, education and lifelong learning leaves Australia for dead. They are also extremely export focussed to go the high road of value added products and services.

    We also lose a good deal of our intellectual brainpower overseas because innovative jobs and R&D does not exist in any meaningful capacity. Talking to PHD students here, they are at a loss as to their job opportunities once they finish, whereas in Germany and Sweden they are pursued by headhunters and highly desirable.

    The seed and VC funds available in the US don’t seem to exist in Australia, perhaps as some posters suggest the financial structures, tax treatment and regulations do not support innovation or startup finance?

    I also notice a difference in corporate culture and management that may be telling. If we follow the U.S lead and head down to following the quarterly reporting cycle and promote the command and control, kiss up , kick down management style there is no surer way to kill innovation of creative knowledge workers who require autonomy, mastery of skills and purpose to prosper.

    @Joe Hoogland

    Would the Entrepreneurs tax offset help?

    http://www.ato.gov.au/businesses/content.asp?doc=/content/00149627.htm

  7. wilful

    At a recent forum I actually heard people saying they didn’t need to expand or export because they were doing it quite comfortably as things are.

    hear hear!

  8. masseyp

    Well said, if the politicians and bureaucrats actually ventured out here and experienced life as an innovator, those that survived more than 2 weeks might have your perspective…this is the problem!

  9. Bigad

    “At a recent forum I actually heard people saying they didn’t need to expand or export because they were doing it quite comfortably as things are.”

    Sounds just peachy! Trouble is, these people almost always find themselves dead and buried within 5-10 yrs of saying this sort of thing, and acting like they have been robbed and the guvvamint shoulda dun sumfink!!!

  10. PaulF

    Great post. Our current batch of politicians seem to be devoid of innovation themselves, let alone being able to create a framework/opportunity to help other Australians innovate.

    When the leading slogan of the opposition is about “stopping the boats” and a couple of thousand illegal immigrants is of key national importance, then you have to think somewhere along the line our political discourse took a wrong turn.

    Both sides are the same, interested in scoring political points and using nasty ways of doing it. There are the occasional gems in there, like Penny Wong and Malcolm Turnbull, who seem to be mostly rational and can argue policy. But ideologues like Abbott and Gillard have taken control. They focus on whatever earns political points and miss these larger topics.

    When a survey/poll or focus groups tells them to back off on a topic they will, that’s why the last election was devoid of genuine constructive debate and why it was all about stopping boats and stopping debt (despite Aust having debt of 6% GDP, very low)

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details

Sending...