Sep 27, 2010

The Age’s uni poison … SMH loves travel

Monday is normally a news graveyard but surely nothing can top the un-bylined drivel (David Rood's name was later attached to the online version) trotted out in this morning's Age. Plus, the advertisers want compo for Games and other media news.

The Age poisons minds. Monday is normally a news graveyard but surely nothing can top the un-bylined drivel (David Rood's name was later attached to the online version) trotted out in this morning's Age reporting "research" undertaken by dumped ALP state secretary Stephen Newnham. The five-page CPI Strategic report, paid for by the timber industry, wisely concluded that a major factor driving Victorian logging policy, rather than the policy itself, was a succession of Labor premiers' attendance at university. Leaving aside the fact that state Labor has hardly been an enemy of wood chips, the report, entitled 'People NOT like us?', boldly states that job cuts in the late 80s and early 2000s were the result of "inbuilt cultural prejudice" caused by pernicious "white-collar decision makers".

27-09-2010 12-55-47 PM

John Cain, Joan Kirner and Steve Bracks had all committed the mortal sin of attending lectures, whereas industry saviour Jeff Kennett had only done one semester at ANU. Kirner had attended the University of Melbourne, Cain had also frequented Parkville and Bracks had learnt his ways at that hotbed of privilege, the University of Ballarat. Sherryl Garbutt, who was environment minister during the early years of Bracks' reign, went to La Trobe. Shockingly, three out of the gang of four had emerged as "trained teachers". Newnham hedged his bets on what the ALP's current crop means for the state's trees. John Brumby attended both a private school and a university, but has a face-saving farm in Harcourt. Environment minister Gavin Jennings was a "university educated social worker" but also mixed it with the workers at his alumnus Beaufort High. And agriculture minister Joe Helper, God bless him, was a motor mechanic in a former life. It's here where the rub becomes clear. The timber industry is currently battling the Wilderness Society over logging in water catchment areas in the lead-up to the November state election. Higher education, Newnham concludes, has poisoned what was left of the ALP's working class consciousness. But the fact that the self-serving screed ever appeared in Victoria's paper of record should also leave political editors at The Age's Media House checking their heads. -- Andrew Crook SMH in love with free travel. The clearest sign yet that the Sydney Morning Herald's no-handouts policy is now a distant memory was provided in Saturday's edition, where deputy editor Amanda Wilson wrote a smug and thoroughly nauseating travel story about her experience amid the "all-encompassing luxury" of the Silver Spirit cruise liner. Silversea paid for the trip, presumably worth several thousands of dollars. In perhaps the most hateful passage among many, Wilson gushed: "So pivotal is the butler to my Silver Spirit experience that at the end of the cruise I declare: 'Arnel, I think I am falling in love with you.' Suave, and chaste as ever, he replies: 'Yes, madam, I know.'" Many readers have abandoned their hope that the Herald will ever be refashioned as a serious and substantial newspaper. However, they do not expect to be insulted with drivel like this. -- a Crikey reader The global fight against content piracy
"The US government has decided that it has the right to take down content on any website in the world if a movie or recording studio complains about it." --
Advertisers want compo if Games audiences plunge
“Businesses that have spent almost $25 million for prime-time advertising during TV coverage of the Commonwealth Games will seek compensation if audiences plunge because of problems in Delhi.” -- Sydney Morning Herald
Advertisers’ own media group to measure audiences
“Advertisers are putting together their own media research group to scrutinise media audience measurement systems.” -- The Australian
Europe’s parliament addresses patchwork copyright laws
“Last week [the European Parliament] called for a long-overdue overhaul of European copyright laws, aimed at fostering the development of a single European media market.” -- New York Times
BBC magazines for sale
“The BBC is seeking a commercial partner to take a majority stake in its magazines business, in a move that could see flagship title the Radio Times being sold off after nearly 90 years.” -- The Guardian
Twitter, blogs tell hidden story of Mexico's drug wars
“A small army of bloggers and tweeters is filling the gaps left by traditional media in Mexico that are increasingly limiting their coverage of the country's drug wars because of pressure from the cartels.” -- The Guardian

Free Trial

Proudly annoying those in power since 2000.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

3 thoughts on “The Age’s uni poison … SMH loves travel

  1. michael dwyer

    The SMH travel article also appeared in The Age. When The Age ran its own travel section it had a policy of no freebies for its travel writers. Sadly this noble policy appears to have been overturned with the consolidation of the two papers.
    More and more of The Age seems to be coming from Sydney- travel and finance are exclusively Sydney sourced. The process started some years ago when The Age adopted the SMH typeface and style book. Fortunately it is unlikely that the sporting pages will come from Sydney- unless Fairfax don’t want to sell papers in Victoria

  2. Tom McLoughlin

    Get this – the logging industry spend 50-100 years converting rainforest, then wet old forest to dry schlerophyll landscapes. A few islands of bush get spared as original forest but even most national park is a sad echo of the original canopy. Most of it is converted effectively into a wildfire tinderbox.

    Then when the inevitable happens in a blow drier hot climate the logging industry think they have the moral stature to preach to the rest of society about why 170 people burnt to death. And they still go at it in the wet forest in Tasmania and East Gippsland.

    Anyone who has tried to light a log fire with wet wood knows wet forest doesn’t burn. And that modern industrial logging over decades is to blame for tinder dry regrowth forest. Eventually the truth will come out about the culpability of the logging industry in killing people just as they killed the critters and the moist canopy before that.

  3. Frank Campbell

    “a major factor driving Victorian logging policy, rather than the policy itself, was a succession of Labor premiers’ attendance at university.”

    Yes, what a scream…the converse was that Kennett was kind to wood-chippers because the most he could manage was school cadets.

    It’s the ALP right now who have handed control over western Victoria’s pathetic remnant forests to…Vic.Forests. The Dept of Sustainability and Env. has been kicked out. Vic Forests is the govt. agency which sells native forest for a pittance to wood-chippers. Tom is quite right- native forest logging dries out forests making them more fire-prone. It also buggers habitat, spreads weeds and reduces plant biodiversity.

    University therefore endangers the environment. Not least by training a class of professional liars.

    And where are the Greens? Oh yes, in the bunker preparing for Armageddon.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details