Menu lock


Sep 15, 2010

Let them serve: Defence drops ban on transgender soldiers

Chief of the Defence Force Angus Houston issued an instruction Monday revoking the policy that effectively banned transgender service members. The ADF is believed to be the last government agency that specifically fired employees for transitioning gender, writes Harley Dennett.

Chief of the Defence Force Angus Houston issued an instruction Monday revoking the policy that effectively banned transgender service members. The ADF is believed to be the last government agency that specifically fired employees for transitioning gender.

The individual whose recent gender transition lead to the reform work was not available for public comment, but the referral service that assists gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender service members, DEFGLIS, was aware that commanders had been anything but understanding.

While the ADF works on a new policy to address those problems, slated for December, Air Chief Marshall Houston called on commanders to show more understanding. Monday’s signal instructed commanders to “manage ADF transgender personnel with fairness, respect and dignity … and existing medical review provisions; and ensure all personnel are not subjects to unacceptable behavior”.

It comes 18 years after the ADF repealed the ban on gay and lesbian service members, and two years after it started recognising same-sex relationships for family entitlements. Yet Australia still trails Canada, Israel, Czech Republic, Spain and Thailand, which not only allow transgender soldiers to serve but also support them through diversity programs.

Last year the ADF joined a Pride in Diversity sexualities conference with Justice Michael Kirby to look into discrimination in the forces, the first time the ADF consulted outside on the issue. Gay and lesbian soldiers and their families have marched in the Mardi Gras for the past three years but are still waiting for authorisation to do so in uniform like other community events.

Medical discharges for service members who express transgender feelings has become standard across the globe since “gender identity disorder” was included in the third edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM III) in 1980. The draft of the fifth edition has become mired in controversy over whether the diagnoses should remain when many transgender people do not regard cross-gender feelings as a disorder.

Transgender people haven’t had good fortune with Western militaries, with recent examples including:

  • US Army private Barry Winchell was killed by a fellow soldier in 1999 when it was discovered he was in a relationship with a transgender woman. His story inspired the 2003 film Soldier’s Girl and became a point of controversy in the country’s Don’t Ask Don’t Tell debate.
  • British Army soldier Joanne Rushton had served in Kosovo, Bosnia and Northern Ireland as well as the British Army boxing team, but was fired in 2003 after undergoing s-x reassignment surgery. A year later the UK government signed the Gender Recognition Act into law.
  • Last year, French Air Force guard Delphine Ravisé-Giard had been living as a woman for two years with full support of her colleagues and the service when she faced hurdles making the transition official in law. A court ordered she undergo breast enhancement or revert to being a man.

The US-based Palm Centre, which specialises in LGBT military matters, released a report on transgender soldiers in 2007 that found much of the military’s beliefs about transgender and intersex medical requirements were myths and posed no barrier to effective service.

While transgender and intersex people will no longer be fired from government employment, there remains significant discrimination against this segment of the Australian population.

The Australian Human Rights Commission’s Sex Files report last year found systemic barriers for cross-gender and intersex individuals to obtain relevant personal documentation, that in some cases, the absence of which endangered lives. Further, Commissioner Graeme Innes said the commission didn’t have the resources to further investigate other problems such as the lack of access to medical services and appropriate protections from discrimination.

Under order from the Administrative Decisions Tribunal, the Passports Office now provides better documentation to Australians travelling overseas for sex reassignment surgery.

There are no Commonwealth protections against workplace discrimination on the basis of gender status, however the Gillard government has promised to address the issue for the first time when it consolidates existing anti-discrimination laws during this term. The Fair Work Act currently includes sexual orientation as a form of unfair discrimination, but not gender status.

News of the demise of the transgender ban will undoubtedly raise the ire of retired Brigadier Jim Wallace, who heads the Australian Christian Lobby. Wallace has been an outspoken opponent of gays and women serving in combat roles.

We recommend

From around the web

Powered by Taboola


Leave a comment

48 thoughts on “Let them serve: Defence drops ban on transgender soldiers

  1. SBH

    Still, by Guy Rundle’s reasoning, the fact that men, with their hard bodies, have traditionally done the fighting bit, we should think very carefully about letting transgender people into the military. I don’t have a reason, just a prejudice based on some child hood trauma.

  2. Sancho

    [specifically fired employees]

    In Australia employees are sacked. Are we going to see “sidewalk”, “flashlight” and “flip-flop” as the standard terms on Crikey?

  3. Acidic Muse


    I hope you weren’t touching yourself when you were thinking about “men, with their hard bodies traditionally doing all the fighting”

    You are seemingly unaware that women first served in the Aussie military during World War II and that the RAAF was the first service to fully integrate women into operational units in 1977.

    The only positions from which women are currently excluded are those with a high probability of hand to hand combat, like infantry

    Having watched a 6ft Tongan tranny beat 4 bogans who had tried to mug her into unconsciousness in Kings Cross circa 1995, I suspect some would have a lot to offer in combat roles too

    As the prophet Eddie Izzard (all praise be to him/her) once said

    “We all know one of the main factors of war is the element of surprise. And what could be more surprising than the First Battalion Transvestite Brigade – Airborne Wing parachuting in behind enemy lines wearing fabulous make up?”

    From his Dressed to Kill DVD 🙂

  4. SBH

    you’ve missed the point comrade

  5. Daniel

    Cool, now transgender people can kill Afghan civilians too. What a victory.

  6. Nemesis

    Can you imagine what an enemy soldier will be thinking will be done to them, knowing they are facing someone who would cut there own testicles of.

  7. Holden Back

    Acidic Muse you are right- NEVER mess with a fa’afafine.

  8. RadarGrrl

    I am one of the Canadian Forces members who has transitioned while in uniform, the eighth out of likely well over fifty now, in fact. Outside of a few dinosaurs that have given people like me problems, there have been no problems. The Canadian Forces has every reason to accept people like me and to see us through our transition just as they do for any other military member with any other medical issue. I have been serving for over 23 years, and, as a qualified electronics technician, they have untold thousands of dollars invested in my training. Why would they want to throw that away for the sake of a fully treatable medical issue with one of the highest success rates in modern medicine? It seems to me that the Australian Defence Forces would do well to follow our lead.

  9. RJ

    Thank you!
    I have suffered with this secret for years(fearing dismissal), which has taken its emotional toll. I was actually on the verge of coming out this week anyway.
    This is such heavenly timing, my prayers really have been answered. I now feel I have the strength to come out and be the real me. Interesting and rocky times ahead, but its about time the ADF caught up with countries like Canada. Words can not express what a development like this means for my life, and how that improves the workplace.

  10. Harley Dennett

    Sancho, you caught me! I’ve been living in Washington too long and picked up all those dreadful American words. I shall flagellate myself with a Macquarie dictionary at once.

    But perhaps a more apt critique is why was this ADF policy shift only noticed by a single journo who doesn’t even reside in Australia? The ADF has more than 120 press handlers across its labyrinthine organisational structure, but not one considered that this information relevant to the public, or even the servicemembers affected. Somewhere along the line the Australian media stopped reporting Defence department stories that weren’t spoon-fed.

    To my thinking, that weakness in the media is of greater concern than an evolving style guide.

Leave a comment