Sep 13, 2010

Hamilton: Gruen’s gift to the advertisers

The Gruen Transfer encourages Australia’s young "best and brightest" to devote their lives -- not to finding a cancer cure, teaching indigenous kids or campaigning against climate change -- but to making clever TV ads for front groups created by the tobacco industry.

The television ads by the 'Alliance of Australian Retailers' depicting battling shop-keepers crying foul over government plans to introduce plain packaging for cigarettes have been revealed as a sham, all part of an exercise cooked up by the tobacco industry in cahoots with a PR firm known as The Civic Group. The exposé shows again just how grubby the advertising-marketing-PR complex can be. But you wouldn’t know it from the ABC’s paean to the advertising industry, The Gruen Transfer. The popular TV show sells itself as "a show about advertising, how it works, and how it works on us", except it’s hard to see how it has done anything useful other than provide half an hour of light entertainment. The subtext of The Gruen Transfer is that advertisements come out of a switched-on, fast-paced industry full of creative people with their fingers on the pulse. And that’s no accident. In developing the program, its creator Andrew Denton, of production company Zapruder’s Other Films, said he wanted to counter the view that people in advertising "have no moral centre". On the contrary, he maintains, the industry employs "many of our best and brightest". His show puts them on display in a brilliant apologia for advertising. Little wonder then that the advertising agencies have fallen in love with the show, the one that promises to expose their dirty secrets and "defuse" commercial messages. It’s become the "don’t miss" program, and the two agencies chosen to do the weekly "pitch" are the envy of the industry. Some companies now aim to have their ads featured on The Gruen Transfer as part of their marketing strategy, chasing the 1.5 million viewers on a TV channel where the absence of advertisements switches off the bulldust filter. There’s regular panelist Todd Sampson, CEO of Leo Burnett. He’s the funky guy with the edgy T-shirts who represents the conscience of the industry. Wringing his hands, he fearlessly bags ads that transgress some hidden ethical boundary. Except that he always pulls his punches; after all, the miscreants are his mates. When not agonising over the ethics of advertising Todd is helping clients such as Philip Morris to sell more cigarettes, McDonald’s to sell more fast-food to kids and Macquarie Bank to win more influence over our governments. But, hey, he might be advising Big Carbon clients such as Caltex on how to polish its image, but he balances the ledger by backing the "Earth Hour" campaign to stop global warming. The other regular is Russel Howcroft, MD of George Patterson’s Y&R agency (clients include everything from Big Carbon, property developers, the gambling industry, purveyors of junk food and the Queensland Government Department of Main Roads). Russel is refreshingly honest -- he seems to think "ethics" is a county in the east of England. If it sells the product it’s ethical, he reckons, because by promoting mass consumption advertising stops recessions, which are bad. Todd and Russel not only have fun on the ABC but the Gruen gig turns out to be a nice little earner for their agencies. You can’t buy that sort of profile. But putting them on the spot is Gruen host, Wil Anderson. He presents as the cynic, ever ready to expose the hypocrisy and dishonesty of an ad with his barbed one-liners. Except that by making us laugh he defuses our outrage. He’s the sort of critic the industry loves, because he knows that, in the end, it’s all just good fun. The advertising industry recognises it has a PR problem -- people who join it joke to their friends about "selling out". If a bunch of creatives were sitting around brainstorming about how to spruce up the industry’s image, they could not have done better than come up with The Gruen Transfer. Cheers Zapruder. The ABC does not carry advertising, but it provides the industry with something more precious than access to the airwaves -- respectability. So as if to fulfill Denton’s claim, The Gruen Transfer encourages Australia’s young "best and brightest" to devote their lives -- not to finding a cancer cure, teaching indigenous kids or campaigning against climate change -- but to making clever TV ads for front groups created by the tobacco industry. Now that’s a PR coup. *Clive Hamilton is professor of public ethics at Charles Sturt University based in Canberra.

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

37 thoughts on “Hamilton: Gruen’s gift to the advertisers

  1. Neil Walker

    Bill Hicks said it best *swearing warning*:

  2. Delerious

    Sorry, don’t agree except The Gruen Transfer is fun. Do you think you are preaching to the converted. Do you think the advertising industry is amoral. Just remember people/organisations hire them. A bit like attacking the prostitute as apposed to the user. The advertising industry is the ultimate thinking-out-of-the box industry. It would be nice if the people could channel their brilliance into good as apposed to evil but you can’t win all of the time.

  3. martin english

    G’day, Clive
    I’d expect a bit more depth from a University professor, something a bit deeper than Advertising bad, so anything using Advertising bad. Anyway, it did make me curious – where your grocery money comes from ?

    If (because I really don’t know) you got paid for this and other articles you write – both online and in dead trees – then aren’t you actually profiting from Advertising ? That makes you worse than the ABC, it puts you right up with that crusty old capitalist Russel Howcroft.

    BTW, expecting either Russell or Todd to be anti advertising would be a bit silly, if you’d ever watched the show. The only stereotype they miss on the panel is the Art Director with a pony-tail.

  4. Phil

    O Clive, cheer up a bit mate. It’s a TV comedy show not an ethics committee.

  5. Pete from Sydney

    it may be a must watch for the advertising industry but there’s another 1.480 million that watch it each week and don’t work for the advertsisng industry Clive..seriously, the modern consumer is the most cynical ever, they take everything with a grain of salt, the show is clever and fun, and that’s it

  6. Ern Malleys cat

    I thought the Election series was incredibly shallow.
    Where they had a chance to actually critique the whole drift to saturation negative advertising, most of the panellists just seemed happy to judge which would suck more people in.
    Interesting also were the two ads which got praise for being intelligent and persuasive — the pitched Greens ‘I Think’ one and the Brazilian ‘This is the truth’ one. But as Todd Sampson pointed out, the Brazilian candidate received less than 1% vote.
    Everyone seemed happy to conclude that dishonest and negative works. Says it all.

  7. Frank Campbell

    The original Savonarola wasn’t big on humour either. Burned at the stake for failing to see the joke. Any joke.

  8. Stevo the Working Twistie

    You’re right as usual Clive. All shows on Our ABC should feature earnest people in sensible shoes discoursing in an academic fashion about topics that are crucial to… umm… themselves. Hint – go to bed early on Tuesdays and tune in for Sunday Arts instead. Much more your style, and I’m sure you’d get on a treat with the other four people who watch it.

    (Disclaimer – I actually do watch the ABC on Sunday afternoons sometimes, but I don’t wear sensible shoes, and hardly ever talk to the other three).

  9. Pete

    Pretty much my feeling too. All one needs is a few weeks in upper secondary school learning how to make an advert to get the gist of this entire show and practically any point it will ever attempt to make. Apart from showing the occasional YouTube video from overseas, it’s little more than a marketing tool for marketing, which I agree is a little odd because all the ABC should be marketing is themselves (oh, and their products on Apple iPhones and iPads, of course… but that’s another story)

  10. baal

    The Gruen Transfer is nothing more or less than the Will Anderson Show – who probably wears ‘sensible shoes’ – sorry STEVO but your phrase is code for ‘progress-hating Greenie in a beanie’ – you know like lighten up guys it’s a trivial universe where fear and loathing should be shoved to the margins – together with subversive art – land for chrissakes leave us chuckleheads alone to have ‘fun’.

Leave a comment

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details