South Australia

Mar 9, 2010

Rann’s approval takes a caning as Libs firm in SA election market

As the South Australian election campaign enters its final fortnight, a complacent betting market continues to rate the Liberals a $3.60 long shot -- but that should change following today's Newspoll.

William Bowe — Editor of The Poll Bludger

William Bowe

Editor of The Poll Bludger

As the South Australian election campaign enters its final fortnight, a complacent betting market continues to rate the Liberals a $3.60 long shot. That should change following today's Newspoll: it shows a dead heat on two-party preferred, with the Liberals leading on the primary vote 39% (up 4% on the previous October-December poll) to 36% (down 1%). Equally alarmingly for Labor, Mike Rann’s disapproval rating (up 10% to 48%) has surged past his approval (down 5% to 45%). This is remarkably similar to what happened to Alan Carpenter in 2008, when his net rating went from 9% positive at the start of the campaign to 6% negative at the end. However, there is perhaps some consolation for Labor in that the period covered by the poll extends all the way back to January. The poll that recorded Carpenter's collapse was conducted in the final week of the campaign, and captured the backlash from his opportunistic decision to go to the polls six months early. Furthermore, while the Western Australian ALP's campaign was blighted by a panicky response to its declining public standing, their South Australian counterparts have had the better of the past fortnight. Shortly before the formal campaign period began, the government outmanoeuvred the Opposition over the duplication of the Southern Expressway, an artery that currently flows in one direction towards the city in the morning and in the other direction away from it in the afternoon. On the very day the Liberals were to make their own announcement, based on a $280 million costing the government had floated earlier, Labor got in first with a more detailed new plan with a price tag of $370 million. The rug having been pulled from under them, the Liberals sent out shadow finance minister Rob Lucas to "take one for the team" (in the words of a Liberal source quoted by Greg Kelton of The Advertiser) by announcing that while Labor’s promise would be matched, the details would now have to wait until later. The Liberals have also hit static over the future of the Royal Adelaide Hospital, where they are proposing a $700,000 expansion in place of a $1.7 billion Labor plan to replace it with an entirely new facility. It emerged the Liberal plan had been drawn up by an architect with no experience in designing hospitals, and that the $700 million estimate had come from a consulting firm that considered it merely a "ballpark" figure. Even so, media reports have indicated both parties' tracking polls point to swings of up to 7% in the key marginal seats, a figure perfectly consistent with the Newspoll result. A uniform swing of that size would see seven seats shift from Labor to Liberal, which net of other changes would leave both on 21 seats, with four independents and Nationals MP Karlene Maywald in the middle. Four of these seats -- Norwood, Newland, Hartley and Morialta -- are located in a cluster in the eastern suburbs, where Labor sources say their sitting members are encountering a particularly hostile environment. A potential saving grace for Labor is that the Liberals have nominated contentious former federal MP Trish Draper in Newland, where voters are receiving regular reminders of her considerable personal baggage in their letterboxes. Labor observers believe they are travelling better on Adelaide's periphery. Aided in no small part by the Southern Expressway issue, they are thought to remain at least competitive in the outer southern seat of Mawson, despite its slender 2.7% margin. At the opposite end of town, rapid urbanisation is improving Labor's position in the Gawler-based seat of Light, although a margin of just 2.4% means the odds remain stacked against sitting member Tony Piccolo. Labor has more reason to be optimistic about the southern coastal suburbs seat of Bright, where the popularity of incumbent Chloe Fox is such that her 6.9% margin should be enough. If five of the aforementioned seven seats should fall without corresponding gains, Labor will find itself teetering without a parliamentary majority. However, Labor is bullish about its prospects of recovering the southern suburbs seat of Mitchell from ex-Labor independent Kris Hanna. This is partly because Hanna won't enjoy the spillover effects from ally Nick Xenophon's staggering upper house vote in 2006, but also because the Liberal resurgence will make it harder for him to stay ahead of them at the second last count. The Liberals would have done well to have played dead in the electorate, but the local party branches have had other ideas, fielding an attractive candidate and making a determined effort on her behalf. On the other side of the equation, the Liberals are a strong chance of recovering two seats currently in independent hands, and also of unseating Karlene Maywald in Chaffey. Strongly conservative Mount Gambier is being vacated by long-serving sitting member Rory McEwen, and despite the efforts of Grant district mayor and independent candidate Don Pegler, most observers expect Mount Gambier mayor Steve Perryman to recover the seat for the Liberals. The Liberals are also unquestionably travelling better now than they were when they lost the Frome by-election to Geoff Brock a year ago, and are hoping that result will prove to have been an aberration. The one cross-bencher who is sitting pretty is Bob Such, who holds the southern Adelaide seat of Fisher. Such effortlessly retained his seat at two elections after parting company with the Liberal Party in 2002, and nobody expects different this time. If there's any substance to today's Newspoll result, a lot could depend on his attitude to his former Liberal colleagues over the coming weeks.

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

10 thoughts on “Rann’s approval takes a caning as Libs firm in SA election market

  1. Diogenes

    The Libs plan for the RAH might be on the cheap but it’s $700M not $700K.

  2. chinda63

    Beat me to it, Diog.

    I still think Tony Piccolo will hold Light. He’s worked very hard over the past 4 years and, as Mayor of Gawler before entering parliament, was well-liked and already had a high profile.

    Trish Draper running in Newland is the one thing that will save the seat for Labor. I also think the choice of Joe Scalzi in Hartley will prove to be a mistake.

    These three seats are must-wins for the Libs. If they can’t win these, they can’t win government.

    Oh, and I still think Brock will hold on in Frome and that Karlene will hold Chaffey.

  3. Toorak Toff

    The Tiser poll last week had the Libs trailing in Newland. If this holds up, it’s hard to see how they can win the election.

  4. Independently Thinking

    I can still not believe how every pseph is ignoring the high Independent vote and that will no doubt help sitting Indies. Such is a gimme, and with Brock and Hanna having worked their electorates hard in the meantime since elected, the ‘sick of Rann’ vote is parking there before even going to the Libs. Xenophon helping Hanna is also helping in Mitchell. Maywald is another issue – she is teetering but my personal belief is she is a goner – there is a lot of anger in the Riverland and her membership of the Ministry has divided the community.
    I can’t see any other Indies doing that well – people in Mt Gambier are pretty wary of Indies after the disappointment of Roaring Rory and Steve Perryman has a positive profile for a major party candidate.
    I believe the ALP will retain Newland (Liberals shot themselves in the foot with that candidate) and Bright – ALP polling there shows Fox is safe-ish. The ALP will lose Norwood, Hartley, Light, Morialta and Mawson.
    In the Upper House, the Libs will get 4, ALP 3, Greens just 1 and Family First will need prefs but will get over the line easily with them. This leaves 2 to go and I think it will be tight between the 4th ALP who will get there though, just, and then it will be a lottery between Winderlich, Democrats and a few Independents or microparties with intricate preference deals. The Greens have no hope of a second – they are kidding themselves. My gut feel is the Democrats may cause a big upset by getting up for the last seat but my smokey is the Climate Sceptics.

  5. Lysistrata

    There is a factor in the east that has slipped past comment so far. The city is in gridlock now and will be for several days until after the Clipsal race on Sunday. This means that for the next seven days any commuter from the eastern suburbs is going to be sitting in traffic – even those travelling on O’Bahn buses. Isobel Redmond in her advertisements specifically mentions the traffic conditions. It has been bad out in the West for months. In the east though the road closures add a lot of time to commuting and make people quite grumpy. No wonder the incumbent Labor politicians are looking at defeat.

    Mr Rann suggesting that the Festival could be every year has not helped the disposition of those in the East who are really over having so many events held in March. Why have we got the Fringe, the Festival, Womad, Adelaide Cup and Clipsal all at the same time? It might have looked good in the lead up to an election to make everyone happy but not everyone is ecstatic.

  6. Alexander Berkman

    Again it’s a case pf tweedledumb tweedledumber – what choice do we have, 2 parties both representing the high end of town – both want to waste huge money on the southern expressway, increase funding to the mining industry, throw $450m at the adelaide oval while at the same time, we are running dry on water, our public transport system is utter shite and we’re busy turnign the state into one big armaments factory. bring on the greens & winderlich I say -get rid of this damn stupid preferential voting system and get some true democracy in this state!

  7. Jeremy Williams

    Perhaps this is may be a lesson to Rann and others that telling a lie about something no one cared about anyway is not rewarding.

  8. SBH

    What lie was that Jeremy Williams. Saying “I didn’t do it” is a denial not a lie.

  9. abarker

    @Lysistrata – I get the oBahn every day and what pisses me off worse than the traffic is the fact the extension has apparently been canned. That would have provided an exclusive bus lane which is something Adelaide sorely needs.

    Sure the Clipsal is inconvenient (I had to walk from South Tce to Hindmarsh Square last night – and I beat the bus – AND I was carrying a 14kg delivery) but they simply do not provide any alternatives. I see cars fill the bus lanes on North Tce and Botanic Road every night, nobody fines them, nobody does anything about it.

    If Public transport were actually decent and given priority, and could handle the capacity, it would help with this problem in a big way.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details