TV & Radio

Feb 4, 2010

ACA and NSW Police digging a hole over fake hoon story

Nine's A Current Affair has been forced into an embarrassing backdown over a "hoon driver" story, after Crikey Andrew Crook — Former <em>Crikey</em> Senior Journalist

Andrew Crook

Former Crikey Senior Journalist

Nine network flagship A Current Affair has been forced into an embarrassing backdown over its public pleas to "track down" an alleged hoon driver it already knew the identity of, claiming it wanted to give the driver a chance to "explain" himself. As Crikey reported yesterday, on Tuesday night ACA host Tracy Grimshaw asked Australia for help to track down "Crazy Carlo", even though they were aware of his real identity and the real reason behind the controversial "drifting" clip -- Carlo was auditioning for Top Gear. Nine had used two-year-old YouTube footage lifted from a Top Gear audition tape to kick along its dangerous driving crusade. As 1 million viewers huddled around ACA last night for the follow up story, reporter Tom Steinfort, under the headline "Hunt for Carlo", claimed that the network had "withheld" Carlo Arena's identity because he wanted him to "explain why he was behaving this way". But Crikey understands that ACA left a message on Arena's voicemail claiming it wanted to get his side of the story -- at 6.35pm on Tuesday, as the episode airing the two year old footage of him went to air. "Now we thought it would have been unfair to splash the drivers' full name and face across the country without first giving him the chance to explain why he was behaving this way on a public road. With that in mind we withheld a portion of the video in which he does indeed name himself, and claims he wants to be a stunt driver on SBS' local version of Top Gear," Steinfort explained mysteriously. But if Nine really wanted viewers to find him, wouldn't it have been helpful to tell viewers his name? Just to be clear on this, this is what Steinfort said in the original story:
"But first we have to find him, and that's where you come in. We believe his name is Carlo, Crazy Carlo".
And then, this:
"So what do we know about this mad man? We know his registration plate. "And the one thing we know for certain is that we can't afford to have this dangerous driver anywhere near our roads."
Even the Police were stumped.
"Police are asking for everyone's help to catch this clown."
Grimshaw ended the report with this:
"Well if you know this "Carlo" from Sydney and his Nissan, please call or email us and we'll do our best to track him down for tomorrow night's program".
Not only did Nine know him, but they also had his mobile. Steinfort made no mention of Channel 9's heavily promoted acquisition of the rights to the Australian version of the show, referring instead to the old "SBS" program, which hasn't aired for months. As part of their original story, Nine also consulted Ian Luff, a motoring expert it invited into ACA headquarters to sink the knife in. Crikey contacted Luff yesterday, who repeatedly refused to deny he had seen the full unedited YouTube clip that revealed Arena's identity and the Top Gear link. But here the story gets even murkier. Arena told Crikey through his spokesperson that he had spoken to Luff at a wake for Sydney's Oran Park raceway last Monday. Arena also received a certificate of excellence from Luff after he attended one of his driver motivation courses. Oran Park was a key legal site for the controversial "drifting" depicted in Arena's audition, before it was closed and earmarked for sale for a new housing development late last year. The story has received major traction. Today Tonight, also boasting a million viewers, led with the video last night, linking the real reason behind the clip -- the Top Gear audition tape -- to the potential for more trouble on the roads. They may have a point. As Arena has pointed out, the production company behind Top Gear, Freehand, explicitly encouraged drivers on its website to strut their stuff for the cameras under the promise of anonymity. The real identity of the mysterious Stig is never revealed on the show. But what about Nine's promised "police investigation"? Is there any prospect of a two-year-old YouTube audition tape being used as evidence to throw Arena "behind bars"? Last night NSW Police Acting Superintendent Dave Evans told ACA viewers that the plod was launching an investigation into Arena and, amid prodding from Steinfort, said that he should be locked up. "We'll certainly be knocking on his door," Evans said. "Activity like that on NSW roads. That's where he should be: behind bars". Crikey contacted Evans this morning who clarified his comments, claiming that " vision alone is not enough to charge the driver." And Evans confirmed that under NSW law, the statute of limitations on "drive manner dangerous"  and "hoon legislation" is six months, contradicting last night's assertions from both Steinfort and himself that Arena and his film crew were "facing charges".

Free Trial

You've hit members-only content.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions




Leave a comment

24 thoughts on “ACA and NSW Police digging a hole over fake hoon story

  1. meski

    Everytime I read an article about ACA of late I am saddened by what it has degenerated into.

  2. SusieQ

    As I said in a post about the earlier story, why the heck do people still watch these types of programs??? I am constantly astounded when I see the ratings figures at the numbers watching – please explain!!!

    Oh, and I look forward to the next edition of this absurdity….there must be more to come!!!!

  3. Greg Angelo

    Exploitative duplicity

  4. Greg Angelo

    The exploitative duplicity of the commercial channels is exceeded only by the moronic insensibility of their viewing public. One redeeming feature of the audiences is that their sensibilities are probably numbed by mindless repetition of crap advertising. The producers of these programs have no shame in their rush to the bottom and are rapidly approaching the shamelessness of politicians as obfuscation and misrepresentation is the order of the day.

  5. Jean

    Back in the 60s a friend of mine wrote half a dozen hippie-drug-shock articles, with his scruffy mates posing for the photos, and sold them to the old Truth (!!!) newspaper to use on slow news days.
    Why criticise a grand tradition? The media today is no more a vehicle for truth than Truth was 🙂

  6. stephen martin

    I thought that the original Crikey story stated that the road used by Arena had been closed for his high speed run.

  7. meski

    It was implied that it had been closed, whether it had been officially closed, or just by parking cars across the road to block traffic, wasn’t entirely clear. Hard to see the police, with their attitude, giving permission.

  8. Blair Martin

    Whether it is old style “Truth” newspaper (cough) journalism (god, what a read that used to be!) or why many Australians have no idea that the mindless drivel they watch is actually mindless drivel, the (cough) best part about the follow-up is the idiocy of Acting Superintendent Dave Evans making on the record remarks about criminal charges, prosecution, sentencing and time “behind bars”. What an absolute fool.

  9. ty_webb

    ACA has turned into the champion of gutter journalism. Stories that range from “12 months ago i was broke and a single mother of 3, now I own $1M of property” to “my next door neighbours house is a rubbish tip” to “carlo the hoon driver” illustrate my assertion. ACA is merely a visual media continuation of the Herald Sun, the Advertiser etc etc. ugghhhhh.

  10. bakerboy

    Top Gear didn’t finish ‘months ago’ on SBS – it was on last week!

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details