What Kyle said:
Magda could have another run out of [the Jenny Craig contract] ... She could get another season out of them, easy ... she's not skinny.And then when Jackie O suggested her build was just a big one -- and perhaps she couldn't lose more weight, he made the comment that spawned 100 articles:
That's what all fat people say ... You put her in a concentration camp and you watch the weight fall, like she could be skinny.Today on his radio show Sandilands addressed the controversy in typically glib style. He didn't mean to "offend her [Szubanski] or anyone else with those comments". It was "just one of those things". Yada yada. Beyond the Kyle-says-something-offensive shock, the real question now is surely whether the provocative tactics that have made his career, will also break it. But where is the tipping point? Despite public outcry over the rape scandal, viewers were still tuning into the Kyle and Jackie O show, with ratings up last month. But ratings only mean something if you have advertisers -- and sponsors like American Express and Optus did pull their dollars from the show following the controversy. Ad exec Adam Ferrier backed their reaction calling on advertisers to use their dollar-power for good:
Those in the advertising industry, who buy media space, sponsor radio shows, or advertise on radio will in the future think twice about working with Kyle and Jackie O. They may achieve good ‘reach’, but at what cost. What brands want to: • support two nasty bogans? • be associated with the exploitation of damaged people? • be associated with the sexualisation of children? • be associated with rape, bigotry, and misogynistic behaviour? • contribute to a show that’s contributing to the demise of our culture?The rape scandal also cost Sandilands more personally. He lost his job as an Australian Idol judge thanks to pressure from Nineteen, the London-based owner of the Idol franchise and the show's sponsors. The decision was also influenced by Channel Ten's recent decision to move the show to the more family-friendly timeslot of 6:30pm. More generally, Kyle and Jackie O are on the nose. A survey by UMR released on Monday highlighted this. As The Australian's Media Diary notes:
70 per cent of Australians feel negatively towards Kyle and 60 per cent towards Jackie. ‘ When asked if the pair should have been sacked, 43 per cent of respondents said yes and 18 per cent said their suspension should have been longer than two weeks.Then again, people love a villain, and unpopularity does not necessarily mean poor ratings. As Amanda Meade notes, "Sandilands has never been well liked, despite his impressive media profile". For TV celebrities like Sandilands (and The Chaser and Gordon Ramsay), "when your insulated world collides with the world most other people live in, things can become really ugly really quickly", says Mia Freedman. In the face of such extreme public anger and media castigation, she says, "some boundary pushers have understood faster than others that they’ve gone too far. Some remorse has been heartfelt and sincere like The Chaser." So far Sandilands hasn't grovelled very hard over the Szubanski incident. Will he have to? And will he live to insult another day? Jewish leaders are speaking out publicly against Sandilands. And Evan Moloney's asking whether jokes about the Holocaust are ever OK? Conclusion: they are sometimes... just not Kyle's. Meanwhile, the Magda factor cannot be discounted in all this. She's hot media property at the moment -- the women's mags fought to have the slimmer Szubanski on their cover. By insulting Jewish people and a woman whose weight loss battle many identify with (not to mention the public at large) in just one sentence, Sandilands has invited the wrath of large segments of the community. But whether the outrage means anything depends on advertisers' response. Perhaps the only path to restore his career now is for tubby Kyle to become Jenny Craig's next weight loss star -- rumours are the company's looking for a male ambassador...