Nov 25, 2008

Banshee on a rampage: the full Keating text

In full at last: Paul Keating's letter to former Unions NSW secretary John Robertson.

Paul Keating's letter to former Unions NSW secretary John Robertson not-so congratulating him on taking his seat in the NSW Upper House, has been much leaked, and much commented upon. Here, though, for the first time is the full, fruity text. If you have trouble reading the image below, we've linked to the letter here

Free Trial

Proudly annoying those in power since 2000.

Sign up for a FREE 21-day trial to keep reading and get the best of Crikey straight to your inbox

By starting a free trial, you agree to accept Crikey’s terms and conditions


Leave a comment

10 thoughts on “Banshee on a rampage: the full Keating text

  1. Craig

    Keating’s was a nasty letter. It could not be described as anything but negative. How this type of personal vindictiveness can be cheered is beyond me. Does the Left really harbor so much hatred?

    If this is to be applauded, if this type of mean-spirited corresponence is to represent the Left’s tendency to communicate an “I-told-you-so”, then I fear for its loss of compassion and sensibility, becuse Keating in his letter goes far beyond the point at hand.

    This was the same Keating who used to make fun of Hewson’s lisp. Crude and lacking any finesse.

    Such spiteful insensitivity is indicative of neither a progressive nor a liberal. It’s indicative of a man who hates.

    Jim: The fact is that Howard would never write such a letter in the first place. He has too much class to lower himself to such personal name-calling. Another great example of the difference:

    Keating after his one and only election victory: “How sweet it is”

    Howard after his fourth election victory: “How humbled I am”

    They are a class apart. Paul Keating is the gutter man.

  2. StuN

    I actually thought he was relatively controlled. Lets face it, whichever side of the fence you sit on, he is right on the money with this one. This Mr Robertson and others like him have totally compromised the NSW govt.
    Say what you want about the Mr Keating, but he is always articulate and informed. Whether he was negative towards the liberal Party and or individuals in politics-on the bigger picture he was always looking to Australia’s future and the a creation of a positive vision of our place in the world. He attempted to do this through both his social and economic policies.
    HIs reformation of our economy, tweaked by the Liberals with the addition of the GST, have put us in a strong position today. There is no doubt he was beset by depression but…..HE’s BACK !

  3. Kevin Charles Herbert#2

    Craig: Nah………..I’ve met old fogeys who were 25……..Keating’s an ideas man…..how many do we have in Oz ????……if you don’t get it, you are OLD…………old son………..& unless you’re going to stun we Crikey readers with an alternative progressive Australian political model….then stand back …….and let the magnificent Australian progressive that Keating surely is, continue his on-going stimulation of public discourse.

  4. Doug Senwick

    Keating obviously has a fair bit of spare time on his hands these days, but he can still craft a very effective letter (or speech) in plain english.Maybe the Kruddster could employ him as a speechwriter?

  5. mike smith

    Craig, you can’t really write PJK off as a one term wonder, as he and Hawke were regarded as a team for much of their political life.

    Great letter, Paul.

  6. John

    You’ve gotta hand it to this guy. He has guts and intellect., qualities sadly missed on the broader political stage. Makes life interesting for a change.

  7. gary hutchens

    remind me not to get off side with Paul.

  8. Craig

    Kevin Charles,

    Errrr ….. I’ m actually young enough (29 yo) to recall Keating getting thumped. He was a one-term wonder.

    On the plus side, it provides a few giggles to see him frantically try make himself relevant again. He just has absolutely no idea how the vast majority of the population see him.

    One of my favourites: The first Monday after the 2007 election, he saw fit to say on ABC that, regarding his own election defeat, the Australian public “made a mistake”. The guy hasn’t a clue. I’d suggest your mate Keating can’t take a loss. Compare that to Howard. Of his loss: “You win some, you lose some”

    It seems Keating just can’t let go.

    Good for a laugh, though. The media do a terrific job of crucifying him.

  9. Glen Preema

    Keating is a dead-set legend. Not only can he say so much in a few brutal words, those words hold an enormous wealth of thought and intellect in them.

    The only time I skipped school was the day Prime Minister Keating came to visit my home town – and went down to Main Street to shake his hand – he’s still showing that I wasn’t wrong to want to meet him.

  10. Jim Tsolakis

    John Howard could only dream of writing letters like that,oh & seeing over the dash board !

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details