When is a
bribe not a bribe? When Austrade’s working on your behalf? Well,
those experts at analysing broken companies that are breaking news, Bruce and
Barryhave some pointers on the matter they picked up last week at a seminar on doing
business in Indonesia.
Bruce and Barry say “The seminar was
presented by Austrade’s man on the ground in Jakarta, Mr X and his
Y, a Vice President Director of an Indonesian firm Austrade had brought
Australia and who was looking for Australian suppliers.” And Bruce and
Barry – like all business heads – just love PowerPoint. This
part of the presentation made a particular impression on the pair.
That “Upfront fees disbursement required” seemed especially
noteworthy. And it appears Bruce and Barry weren’t the only members of the
audience who felt that way. As they observe, it is illegal for Australian business to pay bribes in
foreign markets to secure business. So, naturally, some queries came for
Austrade’s Mr X. But they can tell the story:
Get Crikey FREE to your inbox every weekday morning with the Crikey Worm.
response was that, ‘…if you look into the Indonesian government official or
businessman’s eyes, you will just know if they are looking for
then chimed in to say that, “…yes we are talking about facilitation
at this response from an Australian Government official, the question was then
asked by another member of the audience, “…are you honestly suggesting
that, as we sit here in Austrade offices, we pay bribes to Indonesian
Mr X then cottoned on to the problem, and back-peddled so fast he almost fell
Indonesia’s Mr Y, not realising what the real issue was,
continued on about how, “… of course most non-bureaucrats in Indonesia are
much more embarrassed about taking bribes…”, but he is eventually shouted down
by Mr X who rapidly changed the subject.
other important piece of advice on Mr Y’s presentation was the last dot point
that a ‘Chief Entertainment Officer’ was a big advantage. Presumably
necessary for when the forex transfer window at the bank is closed for the day.
clear that Austrade treads where the angels in DFAT fear to go; not only
acknowledging but encouraging Australian business to pay bribes to Indonesian
Government officials. Given the subsequent covering up by Mr X this must
however be advice only for private clients.
Such a refreshing change after the AWB obfuscation!