Ian Neering writes: Re. “How Mike Carlton got it wrong” (yesterday). Philip Dalidakis may be correct to be critical of Mike Carlton’s strident tone in his recent criticisms of Israels’s foreign policy, but Dalidakis is being disingenuous when he asserts the invasion of Gaza was all about Palestinian rockets. We have only to look at Israel’s recent announcement that it will expropriate four square kilometres of Palestinian land in the occupied West Bank to affirm that Israel’s goal is hardly consistent with the much touted two state solution.
Dalidakis denigrates the Palestinian Authority for not building shelters to protect their citizens from Israeli rockets as the Israelis did against Palestinian missiles. It’s hard to see how this could have been done, given the way that Israel has starved Gaza for resources such as bricks and mortar. Yet another example of the snide propaganda being used by Israeli supporters.
As another one of those pesky secular Jews who abhors the lies and hypocrisy of the Israeli state I wonder how in this day and age we can continue to support the Israeli land grab on the basis of ”a gift from God”.
Robert Kinnane writes: I don’t expect to see much change in Israel’s prospects in my lifetime, but if I were Jewish relying on a country for my safety against persecution, Israel, an Eastern European settler colony of 6 million on a land area of 20,000 square kilometres, primarily dependent on fading US imperial power, bordered by the Mediterranean to the west and over a billion Arabs in a dozen countries to the north, south and east, would be my last choice.
Take their symbols
Thomas Richman writes: Re. “Rundle: the real target in Iraq intervention is not IS, but Iran” (yesterday). A more humane and effective way of de-fanging the likes of Hamas and IS than bombs, rockets and strafing would be to concurrently eliminate each one’s symbolic strengths. For example, why not also place an embargo on, or destroy their sources of, black, white and green cloth used for flags, balaclavas or tunics … the same obliteration for wherever these are assembled? This would be like the Nazis shorn of the swastika and dramatically reduce all the cohesive power that came with it.