Australia’s refugee problem has attracted global attention. This from the New York Times.
Winners. Losers. And what next?
|
It’s pretty clear who the biggest winner from the election is. Kevin Rudd. But the biggest loser? It’s not John Howard. It’s Peter Costello. Howard has been humiliated, but he has had 11 and a half years in the nation’s top job. He is our second longest serving prime minister. That will look good in the history books. Lists of treasurers don’t get consulted that often. John Howard has been prime minister. Peter Costello never will. John Howard’s stubbornness contributed to the Coalition’s defeat, but Peter Costello’s weakness is just as much to blame. He put his leadership skills on display in July last year and gave us a few days of petulance and vacillation. All the polling suggests voters only wanted a minimal change in direction. Peter Costello was too weak to try to give them that. He will probably be leader of the opposition for a while, but the Coalition’s only winner is Malcolm Turnbull. The Coalition ran a dismal campaign. A senior Liberal source described federal director Brian Loughnane as “a dead man walking” this morning. “I’ve never seen so many yes men,” they said of Liberal strategists.
Crikey is aware of an occasion where a major corporate tried to raise climate change as an issue with Loughnane. The response was almost Sir Joh – a “Don’t you worry about that”. The Liberals’ troubles stretch from the Party Room in Parliament House down to the grassroots of the branches. The Lindsay pamphlet farce was a direct product of the Taliban takeover of the NSW Division. The party needs a new direction. That could be hard to define, as public language is another loser from this election. Howard’s and Rudd’s speeches were both utterly pedestrian – our incoming prime minister’s in particular. It contained no eloquence. Is that a sign of the real winner of this election? Will that be process? Kevin Rudd is very much the cautious bureaucrat. He is a bureaucrat who has only sketched the barest details of the direction he has planned for the nation and dressed it up with clichés and catchphrases. Popular and populist oversimplification and government by mission statement and media unit drives our dismal state Labor government. Their best and brightest will soon be moving to the Ming Wing in Canberra. If Kevin Rudd can’t give them better direction that their current bosses, we will all be losers. |
|
|
12 Comments
Agree with the comments about Rudd’s victory speech. I understand he writes all his own - he badly needs a Graham Freudenberg or Bob Ellis and some training in delivery. He improved towards the end but Kevin does not communicate passion all that well.
‘Passion’ in political speeches might be good as a vote-winner, but that wan’t required. Otherwise it’s just entertainment. The speech was actually very encouraging, once initial expectations of ‘We Stuck It up Them’ were disabused.
Agree with Gary re the ‘sour grapes’ — the petty jibe at Kevin’s victory speech is an example; what did you expect, Christian, a latter day version of the Gettysburg Address? How about looking ahead with some enthusiasm?
Christian, there appears to be a little sour grapes in your comment. The real culprit for the Liberal demise is Costello and his gutless attitude to Howard. He refused to challenge, and has now got his right ‘wack”. WorkChoises was, and is, a disaster.
Come on Christian show a bit of charity, I thought both Rudd and Howard gave very good speeches, particularly Rudd’s. I agree that the country needs visionary leadership now more than ever. The past 11 years of Howard has been marked by its absence.
Christian is right that Peter Costello is the one who has missed out on fulfilling his ambition. He is also probably right with the assessment of Costello’s part in his “failure”. But, Christian is hoplessly wrong in his assessment of the Rudd speech.
Well, it’s taken 11 years, but I finally feel relaxed and comfortable!
Christian, you have been so busy mercilessly ‘bagging’ John Howard that you forgot how pathetic Kevin will be. I thought John’s speech was excellent, given the circumstances (he had to admit he had lost his seat). I am not optimistic
As someone who couldnt wait to see the back of the libs, I hope they don’t implode because one thing they have shown us is how bad an ineffective opposition is for the ruling party. Turnbull seems the only one who can fill the role of opposition leader.
At last, this anti-human, anti-green and anti-union gang of profiteers disapears in a flash. Funny how they call for the heads of the yes-men and quietly resign overnight. My only hope now is for Mr Rudd + Ms Gillard make good on their promises. Godspeed!
Rudd deserved to win and now Costello will not be there to taunt him in the future will be able to steer Australia to new heights.
Good luck to all the Labour Members who won their seats.
Now that Lazarus has been laid to rest the Libs best hope for a new leader under current circumstances is not Malcolm Turnbull. It’s Moses and even he would be struggling.